Say you’ve tried writing the opening of a presentation, but every version sounds the same. You reach for your phone, then stop. Would a quiet pause help, or would it just leave you staring at the same problem?
The useful line is between taking a break and trying to make yourself bored. Research supports some benefits of short breaks, and of stepping away from a problem you’ve already tried. Those findings don’t make boredom the goal.
This module is for working adults choosing how to use short idle moments. Taking a break from a creative problem applies after you’ve made a first attempt.
What you’ll get from this module
In this module
By the end of this module, you’ll be able to match a short break to what you want from it. We’ll use reviews of short breaks and boredom, plus experiments on creative incubation, walking and smartphone use. You’ll link what they found to everyday choices, pick a situation from your life and finish with a break to try and a way to review it.
Ask Jing
Become a Jingius.
What a break can help with
Research review: feeling less tired is a useful result on its own.
Patricia Albulescu and colleagues’ 2022 review brought together studies that tested breaks of up to ten minutes. Some put people into groups at random. Others compared groups without random assignment. The studies involved students and employees, and used different activities and comparisons.
After short breaks, people said they felt a little more energetic and less tired, on average. The combined result for performance was not statistically significant: the review didn’t show an overall gain in performance.
This separates two reasons you might want a break. Feeling less tired can matter even when a study doesn’t find better work on the task. And feeling refreshed doesn’t tell you that the work you do afterward will be better.
Why it matters: The activities varied, and many studies used laboratory tasks. The findings support short breaks for feeling more energetic and less tired. They don’t show any special advantage in making the break empty or boring.
Read the review of micro-breaks and well-being.
Laboratory experiment: coming back to a problem matters.
Rest isn’t the only possible purpose. Benjamin Baird and colleagues’ 2012 experiment looked at creative incubation: putting a problem aside after trying it, then coming back to it.
The 145 university students first came up with unusual uses for everyday objects. Each then had one of four conditions: an easy task, a hard task, quiet rest or no break. The three breaks lasted 12 minutes.
Afterward, everyone worked on problems they had seen before and on new ones. The group that did the easy task improved more than the other three groups at giving unusual answers to problems they’d already tried. On new problems, the differences between groups were not statistically significant.
That comparison is the useful part. The gain came on another try at something people had already worked on. It wasn’t a general boost that carried over to every new problem.
Why it matters: People reported that their minds wandered, but the experiment didn’t show that this caused the improvement. An everyday creative task is also different from listing unusual uses for objects in a laboratory. A pause between attempts may help with a problem you’ve already started. You still need to judge whether it helps with your own task.
Read the experiment on creative incubation.
Educational research review: boredom isn’t a reliable way to get ideas.
A break that helps with a problem you’ve tried doesn’t show that boredom itself brings better ideas. Anke Zeißig and colleagues’ 2024 scoping review gathered research on boredom and creativity in schools, colleges and universities.
Its 19 publications covered 27 studies with data. The findings were mixed. Taken together, they didn’t show that boredom makes creativity better or worse.
These were schools and universities, so the review doesn’t test a break routine at work. Its mixed results don’t mean that making people bored can never help. They do mean you can’t count on boredom to bring better ideas.
Why it matters: This helps separate taking a break from trying to feel bored. The studies give you reasons to try stepping away. They don’t make boredom something you need to reach.
Read the educational review of boredom and creativity.
Laboratory experiments: coming up with options is different from finding one answer.
What you do during a break can also matter to the kind of thinking you need. Marily Oppezzo and Daniel L. Schwartz’s 2014 paper tested walking and creative thinking in four experiments.
In the first experiment, 48 psychology students did tasks while sitting and then while walking on a treadmill. Walking increased the number of unusual, workable uses they found for objects. But it lowered their scores on a task that needed one answer linking several words.
The first experiment used a fixed order. A later experiment changed the order of sitting and walking while testing how many ideas people came up with.
One task asked people to come up with possibilities. The other asked them to find one answer that met set requirements. Walking may help you come up with options. You still need to judge which ideas are useful.
Why it matters: These were tests of particular thinking tasks, so they don’t show any gain in productivity at work. The research also didn’t compare walks with and without something to listen to.
Read the experiments on walking and creative thinking.
Smartphone experiment: a difference between groups doesn’t show a change in patience.
Creativity and rest are purposes for right now. The claim that filling idle moments wears down patience asks a different question: does using technology change how willing someone is to wait?
Aviad Hadar and colleagues’ 2017 study included young adults who used smartphones heavily and others who hadn’t used smartphones. It measured choices between smaller amounts of money now and larger amounts later.
In the first comparison, heavy users valued later money less, compared with money now. But giving smartphones to some people who hadn’t used them, for three months, did not significantly change their money choices compared with a control group.
The two comparisons answer different questions. A difference between people who already use smartphones and people who don’t can’t show what caused that difference. The small trial tested what changed after people got smartphones. Finding no significant change over three months doesn’t show that longer use has no effect.
Why it matters: Choices about money are also different from putting up with an everyday wait. This evidence gives no reason to promise that an empty break will build lasting patience. Choosing a useful break doesn’t need that promise.
Read the smartphone study’s final report.
What this means for you
Choose an activity for the result you want from the moment. Rest, another try at a creative problem and useful contact with someone can each be fair purposes. Quiet time is one option.
Decide what you want to notice afterward
If you’re tired, the question that matters is how you feel after the break. Notice how tired you are before you pause, then check again afterward. Feeling less tired is worth noting even if you don’t get more work done.
If you’re taking a break from a creative problem, ask whether another try gives you a useful option. To find out, you need to go back to the problem and judge the idea. Time away on its own doesn’t answer that question.
Keep those results apart. A break could leave you less tired without giving you a new idea. You can judge it as helpful for rest while the creative problem is still unsolved.
Try the problem before stepping away
For incubation, make a first attempt at the creative problem. Then do something short and easy and come back to it. This keeps the order behind the evidence: work on something, step away, then try again.
In the made-up presentation example, you’ve already written some possible openings. After the break, go back to those attempts and ask whether another approach makes the point more clearly. A different idea still needs that judgment before you use it.
If you haven’t tried the problem yet, start there. If you keep stretching the break instead of going back, change the setup so the pause doesn’t turn into avoidance. The studies don’t give an ideal length for your own problem.
Match the activity to the purpose and setting
Choose something you can do that fits what you need: quiet rest, an easy routine activity, something interesting or contact with someone. You don’t have to make yourself bored or put up with distress. If a choice leaves you more drained, stop or change it.
Walking is an optional choice for coming up with options when the setting is practical and safe. Judge the options afterward. Never do this exercise while driving or where walking needs your attention on traffic or other hazards.
You could choose an easy activity while sitting instead. It hasn’t been shown to give the same creative benefit as walking. Choose what you can reasonably do, then notice your own result.
Use the result to choose what comes next
Afterward, compare the result with the purpose you named. If you felt refreshed, or found a useful option when you came back, you can keep that activity as a choice. If it didn’t help, change it or drop it.
You may finish without a clear result. Write that down. Don’t read discomfort as training, and don’t assume a new idea proves the break caused it. What you notice can guide your next choice even when you aren’t sure what caused the result.
You can also choose to use your phone on purpose. A useful message or conversation needn’t count as a failed break just because the moment wasn’t empty. Decide what the moment is for, then choose to match.
How about your daily life?
When would a short break be useful to you? You might think of feeling tired between tasks, getting stuck after trying a creative problem, or choosing how to spend an ordinary wait.
Write down situations you’d like to handle with more thought. One good idea is enough. Add others if they help you choose.
| A situation in my daily life | What I would want from the moment |
|---|---|
| ____________________ | ____________________ |
| ____________________ | ____________________ |
Which situation would be most useful to look at now?
My chosen situation: ____________________
You can change your choice. Carry it into the exercise below. Picking a situation doesn’t yet tell you which activity will help.
Choose and review a break
Start with your chosen situation. If you came straight here, choose one ordinary short idle moment, such as a pause between tasks. For a creative problem, make a first attempt before using a break for incubation.
Quiet time and walking are optional. Never do this exercise while driving or where walking needs your attention on traffic or other hazards. Choose a setting and activity that are practical. Don’t put up with distress to finish the exercise.
- Name the purpose. Decide whether you want to feel less tired, go back to a creative problem you’ve already tried, or use the moment for something else useful.
My purpose: ____________________ - Name what you’ll notice. For rest, note how tired you feel now. For incubation, name the problem you’ve already tried and what you’ll come back to judge.
Before the break: ____________________ - Choose an activity you can do. Try quiet rest, an easy activity or another useful choice. Walking can be an option for coming up with ideas in a safe setting. Judge those ideas afterward. An easy activity while sitting is another option, though it hasn’t been shown to give the same creative benefit as walking. Stop or change an activity that leaves you more drained.
My activity: ____________________ - Return and review. Notice how tired you are again, or go back to the creative problem and judge any new option. If you haven’t gone back to the problem, you can’t yet judge whether the break helped you find a useful idea. Write down an unclear result honestly.
What I noticed: ____________________ - Keep, adjust or drop the choice. Decide what you would do next time. What you noticed can guide that decision without proving what caused the result, or showing that you’ve trained your patience.
My next choice and reason: ____________________
Ask Jing
Become a Jingius.
Your next step
You’ve finished when you have a purpose, something you noticed or an unclear result, and a reason for your next choice. A useful break doesn’t have to bring every possible benefit.
A note on the evidence
The studies measured different things: how energetic or tired people said they felt, scores on particular creative tasks, and choices about money. Much of the evidence comes from laboratories, schools or universities. Those differences matter when you apply the findings to everyday work.
Match what you notice to the purpose you chose: feeling less tired, or finding a useful option when you come back. Neither one success nor one attempt that didn’t help settles the wider research question.
How we prepared this module
This module brings together reviews of short breaks and boredom with experiments on incubation, walking and smartphone use. A made-up presentation example explains coming back to a problem you’ve tried. The written exercise helps you apply these ideas to one everyday situation.
Sources
- Patricia Albulescu, Irina Macsinga, Andrei Rusu, Coralia Sulea, Alexandra Bodnaru, and Bogdan Tudor Tulbure. (2022-08-31). “Give me a break!” A systematic review and meta-analysis on the efficacy of micro-breaks for increasing well-being and performance. PLOS ONE, 17(8), e0272460. Published HTML; Abstract, Methods: Eligibility criteria, Results meta-analyses and Discussion.
- Benjamin Baird, Jonathan Smallwood, Michael D. Mrazek, Julia W. Y. Kam, Michael S. Franklin, and Jonathan W. Schooler. (2012; online 2012-08-31). Inspired by Distraction: Mind Wandering Facilitates Creative Incubation. Psychological Science, 23(10), 1117–1122. OnlineFirst version; printed pp. 2–4, Method and repeated/new-exposure results.
- Anke Zeißig, Julia Kansok-Dusche, Saskia M. Fischer, Julia Moeller, and Ludwig Bilz. (2024-04-06). The association between boredom and creativity in educational contexts: A scoping review on research approaches and empirical findings. Review of Education, 12, e3470. Published HTML; Abstract and Conclusion.
- Marily Oppezzo and Daniel L. Schwartz. (2014; online 2014-04-21). Give Your Ideas Some Legs: The Positive Effect of Walking on Creative Thinking. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 40(4), 1142–1152. Published PDF; Experiments 1–2, pp. 1143–1145.
- Aviad Hadar, Itay Hadas, Avi Lazarovits, Uri Alyagon, Daniel Eliraz, and Abraham Zangen. (2017-07-05). Answering the missed call: Initial exploration of cognitive and electrophysiological changes associated with smartphone use and abuse. PLOS ONE, 12(7), e0180094. Final published HTML; Methods: Participants, monetary-choice measure, Results: Delay discounting and Figure 3a.
