Say you’re in a meeting about improving how your team shares information. You have an idea, but someone else is speaking. By the time your turn comes, the group has moved on to a new proposal.
The meeting may still be worth your time. You might learn about a constraint you hadn’t thought of, such as a limit on what will work. You might help make someone else’s idea better. But those gains don’t answer a separate question: did each person have room to think of ideas?
You can make space for your own thinking and still help the group develop ideas and choose what to pursue. Those are different jobs. Knowing them helps you see what to add next.
This module is for working adults who take part in a session that asks for several ideas before the group chooses what to pursue.
What you’ll get from this module
In this module
By the end of this module, you’ll know when thinking on your own can help and what discussion still adds. We’ll connect lab experiments, workplace research on swapping written ideas, a review of electronic brainstorming and a study of one firm. Then you’ll choose a situation from your own life. You’ll plan what to add before, during and after the shared discussion.
Ask Jing
Become a Jingius.
What changes when everyone has to wait?
Laboratory experiment: separating waiting to speak from listening.
Michael Diehl and Wolfgang Stroebe’s 1987 experiments compared groups that worked together with the pooled ideas of people who worked apart. In one experiment, 60 psychology students in Tübingen thought of ways to reduce unemployment in Germany.
Signal lights controlled when each person could speak. Some had to wait for their turn, even though they couldn’t hear anyone else’s ideas. Others could speak with no wait.
The set-ups that made people wait led to significantly fewer distinct ideas than the ones that let them speak freely. The loss showed up even though they heard no one else. In this experiment, the wait itself cut the number of ideas.
That helps explain what private thinking offers. You can work on an idea without waiting for a gap in the talk. The experiment also shows that hearing someone else’s idea isn’t needed to explain this loss.
Why it matters: The comparison was small, with three units of four people in each condition. It shows how waiting can cut output in a lab. It can’t tell you the size of the loss in your own meeting.
Read the experiments on brainstorming productivity.
Product-design experiment: stronger possibilities still need a good choice.
Avoiding a queue to speak may help people come up with ideas. A separate question is whether they then choose the strongest ones.
Karan Girotra, Christian Terwiesch, and Karl T. Ulrich’s 2010 experiment compared two set-ups among 44 trained product-design students. One used 30 minutes together. The other used 10 minutes of work alone, then each person ranked ideas alone, then 20 minutes together.
Both set-ups then had five minutes to agree on five chosen ideas. Separate panels rated the ideas for business value and purchase intent. These ratings were about possible commercial value and how likely people said they were to buy the product.
The set-up that mixed solo and group work led to more ideas and higher average ratings. The five strongest ideas it came up with also got higher ratings. But the five ideas the students actually chose told a more mixed story.
In the mixed set-up, the chosen ideas got higher purchase-intent ratings. Their business-value ratings did not differ significantly between the two set-ups.
In other words, a group can have stronger options in front of it and still not choose a better set each time. Coming up with options is one job. Seeing which ones to pursue is a second job, and each needs its own care. A longer list gives the group more to weigh. It doesn’t settle the choice.
Why it matters: These were student product ideas and ratings, not real sales. The experiment changed the set-up for the whole group. So its gains don’t forecast what one person will gain by preparing alone.
Read the experiment on idea generation and selection.
Workplace studies: shared ideas can feed later private thinking.
The product-design experiment started with solo work. That doesn’t mean private thinking must always come first.
Paul B. Paulus and colleagues’ 2015 exploratory studies involved the same 57 employees in an Israeli technology unit. They swapped written ideas. They did not take turns to speak.
One study compared two orders. In one, people wrote alone and then swapped ideas. The second order was the reverse. Starting with the swap led to significantly more ideas rated good for both originality and usefulness. The gap in the overall number of ideas per person fell short of the usual bar for statistical significance.
Why it matters: This limited workplace comparison gives a reason to leave room to think after a swap. Something another person adds can give you material for a later round on your own. The result also depends on what you count: all ideas, or only those rated good.
Read the workplace studies of written idea exchange.
Research review: entering ideas together changes the comparison.
Swapping ideas in writing also changes how people add them. Several people can enter ideas at once. No one has to wait for a speaker to finish.
Darleen M. DeRosa, Carter L. Smith, and Donald A. Hantula’s 2007 review looked at electronic brainstorming. It compared electronic groups with face-to-face groups and with the pooled ideas of people who worked apart. Electronic groups came up with more distinct ideas than conventional face-to-face groups.
Pooled solo work puts those separate ideas into one list. Against it, the result depended on group size. In larger groups, electronic groups had more distinct ideas. In smaller groups, the pooled solo workers did better.
Why it matters: Calling all these set-ups “group brainstorming” hides a useful difference: whether people must wait to add ideas. This historical evidence came mainly from labs. It doesn’t set a group size that holds in every case. It doesn’t show a gain for any one application in use today.
Read the review of electronic brainstorming.
Organizational study: discussion can do more than produce new ideas.
Idea counts tell us something about a session. They don’t capture all that people may gain from it.
Robert I. Sutton and Andrew Hargadon’s 1996 study looked at brainstorming at the product-design firm IDEO. They watched 24 sessions and held 60 interviews with about 35 people.
Their reading of the sessions included two things the sessions did. People shared what they knew of earlier design solutions. Designers got chances to use and build a wider range of skills. Those roles help explain why a discussion can matter beyond the number of new ideas.
Why it matters: A colleague’s experience may help develop a proposal, while your private thinking adds options to talk about. The two can serve different needs. The study was qualitative observation. It was not an experiment that set apart the effects of discussion.
Read the organizational study of brainstorming at IDEO.
What this means for you
Make room to think on your own. Use discussion to develop ideas. Give the final choice its own care. You can shape what you add even when you don’t control the meeting format.
Prepare possibilities when you know the question
If you have the question ahead of time, write down possible approaches before you hear the opening suggestions. Keep them open to change. The aim is to give yourself room to think. It isn’t to turn up ready to defend your first answer.
In the made-up meeting about sharing information, you might prepare a few ways to get key updates to people. In the meeting, you may find out that some colleagues can’t use a proposed channel. That new constraint is a reason to revise your options.
Preparing takes extra time of your own. Choose what is practical for you. A study’s schedule is not a routine you must follow.
If you can’t get the question ahead of time, don’t make one up just to follow these steps. Join the discussion. Then use what you learn to think again on your own when you can.
Stay involved in developing and choosing
Use discussion to clarify constraints, improve proposals and help choose what to pursue. Your private list gives you something to offer. Listening helps you grasp parts of the problem that other people know more about.
Notice whether the session needs more options or more work on one it has. If an option is unclear, ask what it would involve. If a constraint rules it out, help revise it or offer a new one.
When the group moves toward a choice, ask how useful the chosen option is for the problem. The product-design experiment shows why having stronger options to hand doesn’t settle that call.
Think again before the choice closes
Go back to your notes with what the discussion showed you. Look for a missing option or a useful revision. Then offer it through the session’s normal route.
In the made-up meeting, a channel that seemed handy might shut out some colleagues. Thinking again could help you revise the proposal around that constraint. Look for something to add that fits what you’ve learned. Don’t add an idea only to make the list longer.
Where you can, use a pause or a suitable follow-up before the choice is settled. If the choice has closed, a late idea may reopen work. Another round isn’t automatically useful.
Match the capture method to the situation
If the format lets people write at the same time, they can record ideas with no wait for a turn to speak. Reading and reviewing still take attention. So a shared document doesn’t remove every demand on the group.
Your private notes don’t change the set-up for the rest of the group. Keep taking part in the discussion that is needed, and respect the format you are authorized to use.
Writing doesn’t work equally well for everyone. Language, literacy or access needs may call for some other suitable way to record ideas. What matters is having room to put ideas forward. It isn’t making the whole group use the same method.
Private preparation also doesn’t remove the fear of being judged in a punitive setting. Judge what you can appropriately add in your own circumstances.
How about your daily life?
Where are you asked to offer several ideas before a choice is made? You might join a project-planning discussion, suggest ways to tackle a shared work problem or help develop ideas for a community activity.
Choose an open-ended idea session. Leave out urgent coordination, and any question with one answer that can be checked.
| A situation I could explore | What I want to contribute or understand |
|---|---|
| ____________________ | ____________________ |
| ____________________ | ____________________ |
One suitable situation is enough. Which would be useful to work through now?
My chosen situation: ____________________
Carry this situation into the exercise below. You can change your choice.
Plan your next contribution
Start with your chosen situation. If you came straight here, choose a session that asks for several ideas before the group chooses what to pursue. This exercise is about what you add. It gives you no authority to change the format for the rest of the group.
Use a way to record ideas that fits your language, literacy and access needs. Keep taking part in the discussion that is needed. Private notes don’t make sharing safe in a punitive setting.
- Identify the question and whether it is available. Write what the session is trying to explore. If you don’t know the question, plan to clarify it in the discussion. Then think again on your own afterward when you can.
Question, or what I need to clarify: ____________________ - Prepare possibilities if you can. If you have the question, write down possible approaches on your own before the session. Allow for the extra time this takes. Leave the ideas open to change when you learn more.
Possible approaches, or why advance preparation isn’t available: ____________________ - Use the exchange. Add your ideas through the ordinary route, clarify constraints and help develop proposals. Take part in the choice. Don’t treat a longer list as proof of a better choice.
A constraint, question or useful development to carry forward: ____________________ - Revisit before the choice closes, where possible. Use a pause or a suitable follow-up to think over what you learned. Offer a useful missing option or revision through the normal route. If the choice has closed, record that limit before you propose to reopen it.
My revised contribution, or the limit on making it: ____________________
Ask Jing
Become a Jingius.
Your next step
Finish with a contribution you can make and a clear account of what is still unknown or unavailable. You don’t need another idea just to complete the exercise.
A note on the evidence
The strongest comparisons came from lab tasks. They covered limits on speaking and work that mixed solo and group time. Evidence on writing at work is more limited, and swapping written ideas differs from taking turns to speak. When you judge a session, keep three things apart: the number of ideas, their rated quality and the options chosen.
How we prepared this module
This module connects experimental findings, a research review and workplace studies to practical choices about adding ideas. The made-up example about sharing information shows how new constraints can change a proposal. The exercise helps you plan one contribution.
Sources
- Michael Diehl and Wolfgang Stroebe. (September 1987). Productivity Loss in Brainstorming Groups: Toward the Solution of a Riddle. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 53(3), 497–509. Published article; Experiment 4, pp.505–507.
- Karan Girotra, Christian Terwiesch, and Karl T. Ulrich. (April 2010). Idea Generation and the Quality of the Best Idea. Management Science, 56(4), 591–605. Published article; methods pp.597–598, Table 2 p.599, §§6.1–6.6.
- Paul B. Paulus, Runa M. Korde, Jubilee J. Dickson, Abraham Carmeli, and Ravit Cohen-Meitar. (September 2015). Asynchronous Brainstorming in an Industrial Setting: Exploratory Studies. Human Factors, 57(6), 1076–1094. Author proof; Study 1 Method pp.5–6, Results pp.7–8.
- Darleen M. DeRosa, Carter L. Smith, and Donald A. Hantula. (May 2007). The medium matters: Mining the long-promised merit of group interaction in creative idea generation tasks in a meta-analysis of the electronic group brainstorming literature. Computers in Human Behavior, 23(3), 1549–1581. Published article; procedure pp.1550–1551, methods pp.1555–1557, results §§5.2–6.5 and limitations §7.3.
- Robert I. Sutton and Andrew Hargadon. (December 1996). Brainstorming Groups in Context: Effectiveness in a Product Design Firm. Administrative Science Quarterly, 41(4), 685–718. Published scan; methods p.691, organizational memory pp.695–700 and skill variety pp.700–701.
