Say you’re writing a report and open your email to find a missing detail. You spot another message and start reading. Then you realize you’ve stopped looking for the information that brought you there.
The first switch had a clear job. The later reading had a different one. Calling both moments “getting distracted” leaves out the point where your purpose changed.
A useful question is what you’re trying to do by leaving. Sometimes you need information or help. Sometimes you need rest, or another obligation deserves attention. Sometimes the reason for the detour has already gone.
This module is for ordinary working adults who can choose when to pause unfinished work.
What you’ll get from this module
In this module
By the end of this module, you’ll understand the difference between a needed switch, a checking routine and a pause with a purpose. We’ll link workplace observation, notification experiments, a phone-use study and reviews of breaks and problem solving. You’ll learn how to respond to the purpose of a switch. You’ll choose a situation from your daily life. You’ll finish with a short written response for that situation.
Ask Jing
Become a Jingius.
What happens between leaving and returning?
Workplace observation and an online experiment: a lookup can grow.
Borghouts, Brumby and Cox’s 2020 work began with nine finance-administration workers. They processed expense claims at two public universities. The researchers watched them work and asked them to explain what they were doing.
When information was missing, workers had to leave the task and search elsewhere. One worker opened emails to find information for the task. He saw that one message wasn’t relevant, but he kept reading because it reminded him of another task.
What the researchers saw here shows how a useful departure can become something else. Opening email was part of doing the expense work. Reading on through unrelated material changed what the departure was for.
The same paper describes an online data-entry experiment. People in it had to fetch expense codes from email. One group got feedback after each trial about its average time away from the entry window. The other group got no such feedback.
The analysis covered 47 people. It left out those who didn’t complete the task or had no recorded switches. People were put into the two groups in turn, not at random.
The average switch lasted 4.76 seconds with feedback and 7.13 seconds without it. Both groups averaged 10.6 switches per trial, with no significant difference in the number of switches. The feedback group also had a lower error rate.
Needed lookups stayed part of the task. The useful difference is between how often you leave and what happens while you’re away. A task can still need switching even when its detours get shorter.
Why it matters: These results come from a small, specific data-entry task, reported in the linked manuscript version. Noticing your own detours in an informal way is a different activity from the automated feedback studied here.
Read the study of information lookups and interruption-duration feedback.
One-day randomized experiment: starting a check isn’t the same as interrupting work.
Ohly and Bastin’s 2023 study analyzed 247 employees and students. Some were assigned to turn off communication notifications as far as possible for one work or study day. The others were assigned to keep their usual settings.
All the results came from people’s own reports. The researchers asked whether a check was started by the person or by an alert. As a separate question, they asked how often people interrupted themselves to check messages or missed alerts.
With alerts turned off, people reported starting more of their checks themselves. Turning alerts off did not lead to a significant rise in reported internal interruptions compared with the control group. Both groups reported fewer internal interruptions.
Why it matters: The difference matters because choosing to check tells you who started the action. It doesn’t tell you whether unfinished work was interrupted. The authors suggested that some checks could happen at planned times or where one task ends and another begins. But they didn’t observe that timing.
Read the one-day communication-notification experiment.
Week-long randomized trial: fewer alerts can exist side by side with continued checking.
Dekker, Baumgartner, Sumter and Ohme’s trial was published online in 2024. Young adult Android users took part. Some were assigned to turn off app notifications for a week, apart from the research app. The others were assigned to keep their usual settings.
The researchers analyzed 205 people. They had left some out for missing data or for not following the instructions. People assigned to turn them off were counted only if their alerts fell by the required amount. So the comparison left out people who did not make that change.
Alerts fell sharply. But the trial found no significant effect on how often the logs showed people checking, or on screen time. A logged check meant one phone session, from unlocking the phone to locking it again. It wasn’t classed as an interruption of unfinished work.
People reported less checking out of habit but more fear of missing out. So their own sense of their checking and the logged count told different stories.
Why it matters: Together, the two experiments help explain why quieter devices don’t settle every question about checking. They measured different behaviors over different lengths of time. Neither shows that silencing alerts must cause more self-interruption.
Read the week-long notification-disabling trial.
Video and replay interviews: a routine can outlast its starting purpose.
Heitmayer and Lahlou’s 2021 study had 37 people aged 21–29, mainly from Europe. They filmed their everyday activity and talked about their phone use while watching the recordings.
In one replay interview, a person described checking the time, moving through a familiar checking routine and forgetting the purpose they started with. Later, the person remembered they had meant to check the weather.
This is one person’s account of a sequence. It isn’t proof of what caused everyone’s checking habits. It shows a useful possibility: starting with a reason doesn’t mean that reason keeps guiding the whole visit.
Why it matters: The workplace lookup and this phone account reach a similar practical question by different routes. Is what you’re doing now still linked to what you came to do?
Read the study of smartphone use in everyday contexts.
Research review: recovery is a worthwhile reason to pause.
Albulescu and colleagues’ 2022 review combined experimental and quasi-experimental research on short breaks among healthy employees and students. It included 22 independent study samples, with 2,335 people in total.
The review found small average benefits for reported energy and fatigue. It found no significant overall gain in performance. Break activities, tasks and settings varied.
Why it matters: Feeling less tired and performing better are different results. A pause can support well-being without having to earn its place through an immediate rise in output. That difference matters when fatigue is the reason you want to leave.
Read the review of brief breaks, well-being and performance.
Problem-solving review: setting a problem aside can help after initial work.
Sio and Ormerod’s 2009 review looked at incubation: setting an unsolved problem aside before returning to it. Experimental studies compared this pause after initial work with continued problem solving.
The review found a small average benefit, with differences across types of problem. Demanding activities during the pause gave smaller benefits. The studies covered a narrow range of problems. The review also noted that significant findings may have been more likely to appear in the research that was available.
Why it matters: This gives stepping away another valid purpose. You may have worked on a problem and become stuck. Returning after a pause is different from never working on it at all. The findings don’t point to an ideal waiting time for everyday work, though.
Read the review of incubation and problem solving.
What this means for you
When you notice an urge to leave unfinished work, briefly name what the switch is for. You might need information, help with an obstacle, time for another obligation or rest. Or you might be carrying on with a detour that has already served its purpose.
Use this reflection while you’re staying in one place. Never do the attention exercise while driving or moving.
Give a necessary lookup a clear destination
Before you search, name the exact information you need. Then return when you have it. The university example shows why this difference matters: a needed search and unrelated reading can happen in the same place.
Say you need an invoice total to finish a report. Finding that total meets the need you have now. Reading an unrelated invitation doesn’t help you enter it, even if the invitation is about something you’ll need to do later.
If the lookup is growing, compare what you’re doing with what you came to find. In the made-up example, the invoice total is still the destination even when a message reminds you of something else. If the information is still missing, name that gap or the help you need. If you already have it, return to the unfinished work.
Separate an obstacle from an urgent obligation
If you’re stuck, state one next action you can take or the particular obstacle that needs help. “Finish the report” names the whole job. In the made-up example, “enter the invoice total” names something you can actually do next.
If you can’t find the total, the next action may be to ask for the missing information. Naming that obstacle gives the request a purpose. Without it, you’re left to search without knowing what’s missing.
An obligation you’ve remembered calls for a different choice. If it is truly more urgent, switch on purpose. If not, leave a short reminder and return. Remembering another task doesn’t by itself decide which task should come first.
Notice when a checking routine has finished its useful job
A check you started yourself doesn’t by itself mean you’ve interrupted important work. Look at the actual situation: what were you doing, and what did you open the phone or app to do?
If that purpose is done, or has been lost in unrelated activity, close the detour and return to the next action. The phone interview shows why the starting reason and the current activity deserve separate attention.
Keep this question short. You don’t need to score yourself or turn every switch into something to monitor.
Allow rest and a return to an unresolved problem
If fatigue is the need, allow a rest with a purpose. The break review supports valuing recovery for its own sake. It doesn’t promise that any short diversion will improve demanding work right away.
If you’ve worked on a problem and can’t get any further, you can set it aside and choose an occasion to return. A demanding task in its place may give less incubation benefit, so don’t assume any change of activity serves the same purpose.
For either kind of pause, make the planned return clear. That keeps the unfinished work in view while leaving room for a useful departure. The purpose question should help you choose. It shouldn’t become a reason to hold back every pause.
How about your daily life?
Where do you leave unfinished work to fetch information? When does a routine check carry on after you’ve found what you needed? Which tasks leave you tired or stuck after a real attempt?
You might choose report writing, expense processing or a problem you’ve been trying to solve. Write down situations you’d like to understand better, along with what you’d like to handle differently. One idea that fits is enough.
| A situation in my daily life | What I would like to understand or improve |
|---|---|
| ____________________ | ____________________ |
| ____________________ | ____________________ |
Which situation would be most useful to work through now?
My chosen situation: ____________________
Choose ordinary unfinished work where you can decide when to pause. You can change your choice. Carry the situation into the exercise below.
Choose a response that fits
Use your chosen situation. If you’re starting here, choose ordinary unfinished work where you can decide when to pause. Think through a recent departure or an urge to leave.
Complete this written reflection while you’re staying in one place. Never do the attention exercise while driving or moving.
- Name the unfinished work and the purpose of leaving. What were you trying to do? Were you looking for information, stuck, remembering another obligation, tired or carrying on a routine?
Work and purpose: ____________________ - Choose the response that fits the need. For information, name the exact item and return when you’ve found it. If it’s missing, name the gap or the help needed.
If you’re stuck, state one next action you can take or a specific obstacle that needs help. If another obligation is truly more urgent, switch on purpose. If not, leave a short reminder and return.
If you need rest, allow a pause with a purpose. If you’ve worked on a problem and can’t get any further, set it aside and choose an occasion to return.
If the detour has lost its purpose, close it and return to the next action. Keep the decision short, and don’t score your discipline.
Response or unresolved need: ____________________ - Make the return clear. Write the action you’ll return to, or the occasion when you’ll come back to the problem after a pause. If information or help is still missing, name that gap.
Return action, occasion or missing help: ____________________
Ask Jing
Become a Jingius.
Your next step
You’ve finished when your short record links the reason for leaving with a response and a return or unresolved need. Use that choice for the situation you’ve picked.
A note on the evidence
These studies tell apart needed lookups, checks people start themselves, phone sessions and interruptions of unfinished work. A count of phone sessions, for example, does not tell you how often someone left unfinished work. The notification findings cover one day or one week, and the phone account comes from a young sample.
The reviews support different reasons for stepping away: recovery and another try at a problem. Their tasks and activities varied, so the purpose of your pause deserves attention.
How we prepared this module
This module links workplace and phone-use observations, notification experiments and reviews of breaks and problem solving. Made-up report-writing examples explain the choices. The written exercise helps you look at one situation from your own work.
Sources
- Borghouts, J., Brumby, D. P., and Cox, A. L. (2020; August 2020 publication). TimeToFocus: Feedback on Interruption Durations Discourages Distractions and Shortens Interruptions. ACM Transactions on Computer-Human Interaction, 27(5), Article 32, 1–31. UCL-hosted review manuscript, cover dated 22 May 2019; Study 1 §§3–3.1.2 and §3.2.2, manuscript pp.4–5 and 10; Study 3 §§5.1–5.2.3, manuscript pp.18–20.
- Ohly, S., and Bastin, L. (2023; published online 6 June 2023). Effects of task interruptions caused by notifications from communication applications on strain and performance. Journal of Occupational Health, 65, e12408. Published PDF; Methods §§2.1–2.3, pp.5–6; Table 2, p.8; Discussion §4, p.10.
- Dekker, C. A., Baumgartner, S. E., Sumter, S. R., and Ohme, J. (Online 28 March 2024; issue 2025). Beyond the Buzz: Investigating the Effects of a Notification-Disabling Intervention on Smartphone Behavior and Digital Well-Being. Media Psychology, 28(1), 162–188. Published version with repository cover; Method and Participants, pp.170–172; Measures, p.173; Table 1, p.174; Results, p.176.
- Heitmayer, M., and Lahlou, S. (March 2021; DOI assigned 2020). Why are smartphones disruptive? An empirical study of smartphone use in real-life contexts. Computers in Human Behavior, 116, Article 106637. Institutional author manuscript; §4, PDF p.6; §5.1, PDF p.8, P19 replay interview.
- Albulescu, P., Macsinga, I., Rusu, A., Sulea, C., Bodnaru, A., and Tulbure, B. T. (31 August 2022). “Give me a break!” A systematic review and meta-analysis on the efficacy of micro-breaks for increasing well-being and performance. PLOS ONE, 17(8), e0272460. Published article; Abstract; Results and Table 3, PDF p.13.
- Sio, U. N., and Ormerod, T. C. (January 2009). Does Incubation Enhance Problem Solving? A Meta-Analytic Review. Psychological Bulletin, 135(1), 94–120. Published article; Abstract, p.94; Results, pp.102–103; Discussion, pp.107–110.
