Concept

A benchmark is useful when it fits the judgment you need to make.

Issue

You can mistake an exceptional performance for the standard you should already meet.

Solutions

Understand what different comparisons can tell you, then review one benchmark.

Say you’ve finished a presentation. Then you watch an award-winning speaker give a polished talk. You look back at your own slides and decide you’re behind.

But behind what? You might need to know whether your presentation meets its requirements. You might want to learn how the speaker explains hard ideas. Those questions call for different comparisons.

An exceptional talk can offer something to learn. But it doesn’t show what people usually produce under your conditions. It helps to tell two things apart. One is judging where you stand. The other is finding a model for your next improvement.

This module is for working adults choosing comparison benchmarks for a specific everyday goal, outside clinical care.

What you’ll get from this module

In this module

By the end of this module, you’ll benefit from knowing how to choose a comparison for the question you actually need answered. We’ll use a sociological account, a role-model experiment and field studies of savings, exercise attendance and pay information. You’ll look at what they mean in practice. You’ll choose a situation from daily life and review one benchmark. You’ll finish with a useful comparison to keep, a change to try or missing information to find.

What changes when you change the comparison?

Sociological account: a performance leaves some things out.

Erving Goffman’s 1956 account describes how people show others a polished version of themselves. They may fix mistakes before a performance. Then they hide the signs of those fixes.

Goffman uses examples to show how people present themselves in daily life. His account helps us tell the finished performance from the work behind it.

That difference matters when a polished result becomes your benchmark. You may see the result without seeing the fixes. Goffman’s account also places this problem before digital networks. Meeting someone locally doesn’t mean you see their whole life.

Why it matters: The useful question is what the visible performance lets you judge. A finished result may show a technique worth studying. It may still leave the preparation unclear.

Read the sociological account of everyday presentation.

Field experiment: similar peers did not always encourage participation.

John Beshears and colleagues’ 2015 paper looked at peer information in retirement-savings mailings at a US manufacturing firm. In 2008, employees were sent one of three things at random. Some got details about five-year age peers. Some got details about ten-year age peers. The rest got no peer information.

One group had not enrolled. Their contributions stayed at 0% unless they chose to join. Among these Quick Enrollment recipients, 9.9% enrolled without peer information. With it, 6.3% enrolled.

The other three employee groups showed no statistically significant average response to the peer information. So the result depends on which employees got it.

The researchers suggested that the peer information put some employees off. Their findings didn’t show that this was the only reason. What the study does show is this. In this setting, peer information matched by age can lead fewer people to take part.

Why it matters: Matching people on one feature didn’t make the comparison helpful for everyone. The person’s starting point and the task still mattered. This study informs how we think about comparisons. It doesn’t give you a personal savings decision.

Read the field experiment on peer savings information.

Role-model experiment: an outstanding performer can inspire.

The savings result doesn’t mean an ambitious model always puts people off. Penelope Lockwood and Ziva Kunda’s 1997 study looked at accounting students. It tested how they responded to an outstanding made-up graduating student.

Their second experiment recruited 69 first-year and fourth-year students at the University of Waterloo. Of those, 65 stayed in the analysis. Students were split at random. Some read about the made-up graduating student before rating themselves. Others rated themselves without reading about anyone.

First-year students who read about the model rated themselves more positively than first-year students who didn’t. Fourth-year students who read about the model rated themselves less positively than fourth-year students who didn’t. But that difference wasn’t statistically significant.

The authors thought the difference came down to whether similar success still seemed within reach. First-year students had more time ahead of them. But students weren’t assigned at random to their year of study. That limits the explanation. The measured benefit was in how students rated themselves straight away. It wasn’t in how they performed at work later.

Why it matters: This gives a reason to keep useful ambition. Someone ahead of you can stand for a possible direction. They needn’t be a verdict on what you should have achieved by now.

Read the experiment on outstanding role models.

Randomized field trial: comparison helped a shared, observable task.

Jingwen Zhang and colleagues’ 2016 paper reports on an 11-week exercise program. It was held in Philadelphia in 2014. It put 790 graduate and professional students into conditions at random. The conditions combined comparison, support and rewards for individuals or teams.

The program put people into peer networks and showed attendance details. In the groups with comparison, people went to an average of 1.9 classes each. In groups without comparison, the average was 1.0.

The outcome was attendance at program classes. These totals show a modest difference in actual classes. Only the relative gap looks large.

How strong the evidence was also depended on the analysis. The researchers used a model that took account of people being grouped into networks. Before adjusting for what people were like at the start, the range of plausible effects included no increase in attendance. After adjusting, that range excluded zero and supported an increase.

In this organized setting, comparison could support a concrete activity. The program gave people peers, visible progress and incentives together. To apply that lesson to an ordinary work goal, pay attention to those different conditions.

Why it matters: The contrast with the savings study helps. Comparison can help people take part or hold them back. The task matters. So do the people who get the comparison and the way it is set up.

Read the trial of exercise attendance and peer networks.

Do similar peers always help?

Workplace field experiment: useful information can feel uncomfortable.

David Card and colleagues’ 2012 paper looked at salary information at three University of California campuses. In 2008–2009, they told some employees, chosen at random, about a website showing salaries.

The main analysis included 6,411 people. They had answered a survey, and their answers could be matched to salary records. Take employees earning below the median for their unit and occupation. For them, being told about the website lowered satisfaction. Employees above the median showed zero or weakly positive effects.

The median marks the middle of the relevant spread of pay. So the comparison was about where employees stood among coworkers. It wasn’t about an exceptional public success.

Employees were picked at random to receive a notice. They chose whether to view the website. Few answered the follow-up survey. Response rates differed between groups. So we can’t be sure whether the people who answered affected the results.

Why it matters: In practice, this means discomfort alone can’t tell you whether information is worth keeping. A comparison may show a gap that matters for fairness. Removing that information just because it feels unpleasant could leave the question behind it unanswered.

Read the workplace experiment on peer salary information.

Should she stop comparing?

What this means for you

Choose a comparison for the job it needs to do. The research gives reasons to look at its purpose, context and effects. It also gives reasons to keep both ambition and the information you need.

Separate a requirement from a typical benchmark and a learning model

Start with the judgment. Are you checking whether a task meets a requirement? Are you judging typical standing? Or are you looking for something to learn?

For a requirement, use the actual criteria for the task. To judge typical standing, look at results from relevant peers. Know how those people were chosen and what was measured. For learning, choose a relevant model. Then pick out a next action within reach.

Go back to the made-up presentation. The award-winning talk might help you study a clear explanation. On its own, it doesn’t tell you whether your slides meet your assignment. It doesn’t tell you how presenters like you usually perform.

You can keep the speaker as a learning model. Use the assignment criteria to judge whether your work is good enough. Changing the model’s role keeps the useful example. It stops you treating exceptional achievement as typical performance.

Record the context you have and the context you need

Write down who or what you really compare yourself with. Your benchmark might be a person, a group or a ranking. It might be an ideal put together from several people.

Then ask how it reached you. Did you choose it? Did an institution supply it? Or did someone choose what to show in public?

Check the task, career stage, available time, resources and measure of success. These details help you decide whether the comparison answers your question. As the savings study shows, matching on age alone doesn’t guarantee a helpful result.

Write “unknown” when a detail is missing. Goffman’s account gives a reason to notice missing preparation. It doesn’t give permission to invent another person’s hidden struggles.

Missing context can get in the way of a fair comparison. If it does, look for a better-documented benchmark or leave the judgment open. You can still study a technique you can see. You don’t have to decide that the person’s whole performance compares with yours.

Keep ambition connected to something you can learn

An ambitious model is useful when their work relates to your goal and you can name a realistic next action. Look for something to learn about how they worked or what they used. The finished result alone doesn’t show you how to get there.

In the presentation example, you might look at how the speaker explains one hard idea. If you can’t find a route you can use, look for someone doing similar work. Or find out more about the process.

For a shared task, peers working on that task and a measure everyone understands may give a useful comparison. Taking part and competitive pressure should stay choices you make on purpose. The exercise trial supports taking the setup seriously. It doesn’t support assuming that any leaderboard will help.

Judge usefulness by the next task, not comfort alone

Change one benchmark when it doesn’t answer your question. Do the same when it includes people who are a poor match for the task. You could choose results from relevant peers, someone doing similar work or a benchmark whose circumstances you know more about.

Keep objective requirements and information you have good reason to keep. A comfortable group can hide a gap in performance that matters. The pay study helps explain why an uncomfortable comparison may still deserve attention.

The next time the task comes up, make a note. Did the changed benchmark help you choose or carry out a useful action? Feeling better alone doesn’t show that the comparison is accurate or helpful.

Keep what informs the task. Revise what misleads you. If the answer is still unclear, name what is missing. Don’t declare the new benchmark a success.

Who do you measure yourself against?

How about your daily life?

Where do you decide that you’re behind? You might compare your presentations, your creative work or your progress in learning a work skill.

Which comparison helps you choose a next action? Which leaves you unsure what standard you’re using?

Write down situations you’d like to understand. One idea that fits is enough.

A situation in my daily lifeWhat I need the comparison to tell me
________________________________________
________________________________________

My chosen situation: ____________________

Choose one everyday task outside clinical care. Carry it into the exercise below. You can change your choice.

Review one benchmark

Start with your chosen situation. If you came straight here, choose an everyday task. Pick one where you already compare your progress with someone else. Keep this exercise outside clinical care.

  1. Name the judgment. Are you checking a requirement, judging typical standing or looking for a learning model? Write the task and the question you want answered.
    Task and question: ____________________
  2. List the comparison you actually make. Name the person, group, ranking or combined ideal you use when deciding how you’re doing.
    My current benchmark: ____________________
  3. Trace its context. Record who chose it and how it reached you. Note the task, career stage, time, resources and measure. Mark missing details “unknown”. Don’t invent hidden difficulties.
    Known context and missing information: ____________________
  4. Give it a purpose. Use the actual criteria to check requirements. To judge typical standing, use relevant peers. Check that the way they were chosen gives you a fair picture. Keep an ambitious learning model when you can name a relevant next action within reach.
    If you don’t have enough context, name what you need to know or leave the judgment unresolved. Keep useful information about fairness and real performance requirements. Keep it even when the comparison feels uncomfortable.
    Purpose, reason and any unresolved question: ____________________
  5. Change one unsuitable benchmark. Choose results from relevant peers, someone doing similar work or a benchmark whose circumstances you understand. You may keep the old target as a learning model. If the comparison you have fits, record why you’re keeping it.
    What I will change or keep, and why: ____________________
  6. Inspect the next task. The next time the task comes up, make a note. Did the comparison help you choose or carry out a useful action? Include what is still unclear. Feeling better alone isn’t enough to show it was useful.
    Action informed, observed result or missing information: ____________________

Ask Jing

Become a Jingius.

Review your benchmark

Loading interactive tool…

Your next step

You’ve finished this review when you have a reason to keep or change the benchmark, or a clear question to settle. Keep that reason with what you observed on the task. Then you can revise the comparison when you need to.

A note on the evidence

The studies are about different outcomes: self-ratings, savings enrollment, class attendance and satisfaction. Their effects depend on who got the comparison and how it was set up. They don’t give a single prediction for your task.

Use the distinctions to look at what a comparison tells you. Keep useful challenge. Leave missing context open until you have evidence to fill it.

How we prepared this module

This module combines a sociological account with lab and field experiments on comparison. The made-up presentation example shows how one person can serve different purposes. The written exercise brings those distinctions to one everyday task.

Sources