Concept

Waiting has consequences, and sometimes it has benefits worth keeping.

Issue

An open decision can hide both the cost of your current arrangement and the reason you might want more time.

Solutions

Understand what another interval would change, then compare your next choices.

You open the same comparison again. You could change the arrangement, but you still haven’t decided. Meanwhile, the arrangement you already have continues.

That doesn’t by itself make waiting a mistake. Perhaps something useful will become clearer before you commit. Or perhaps another month will bring the same cost and no new information.

The useful distinction is what happens during the wait. A cost can keep adding up without each extra month costing more than the last. Waiting for a specific answer is also different from leaving a question open with no end set.

This module is for nonurgent personal decisions you’ve been putting off. These are decisions where your current arrangement continues and you can still choose when to act.

What you’ll get from this module

In this module

By the end of this module, you’ll benefit from a clearer way to compare three choices. They are acting, waiting on purpose and keeping your current arrangement. We’ll connect research on workplace enrollment and specific task plans with theory about investment timing. You’ll explore the practical meaning. You’ll choose a situation from daily life. You’ll finish a written comparison with a next step or a specific unresolved question.

What changes while a decision stays open?

Natural experiment: making an enrollment choice explicit.

Gabriel D. Carroll and colleagues’ 2009 study looked at enrollment in a retirement plan at a U.S. financial-services company. The company had asked new employees to state their enrollment choice. It changed to a system where they could opt in themselves.

The researchers compared two groups of employees. One was hired under the earlier arrangement in 1997. The other was hired in 1998. Three months after hiring, enrollment was 28 percentage points higher under the active-decision arrangement than under standard opt-in enrollment.

These groups were hired in different years. They were not assigned at random. Other administrative changes happened too. One was a change from paper to telephone enrollment. The study couldn’t separate the active-decision effect from that change in enrollment technology.

The comparison shows what can happen while a choice stays open. Leaving enrollment open didn’t mean employees had already begun taking part. The choice could stay open while they continued not to take part.

Why it matters: This example comes from an institution. So its result isn’t a personal prediction. What it adds is a useful distinction. Having a choice open to you is one thing. Having carried it out is another. An unresolved decision can leave an existing arrangement in place.

Read the study of defaults and active enrollment decisions.

Laboratory experiments: giving an unfinished task a specific plan.

An open question and an unfinished task need different kinds of attention. E. J. Masicampo and Roy F. Baumeister’s 2011 paper helps explain the second situation.

In Study 1, undergraduates were assigned at random to one of three groups. One group reflected on completed tasks. One reflected on unfinished tasks. One reflected on specific plans for finishing tasks. The plan group described how, when and where they would act. The students then did unrelated reading.

The analysis included 69 students. Four others had been left out for guessing the study’s purpose. Those who made plans reported significantly fewer distracting thoughts about their tasks. The comparison was with those who reflected on unfinished tasks without planning.

This result was immediate and self-reported. It came during a reading task in a lab. The same paper’s Studies 5A and 5B measured goal-related emotions. There, planning did not significantly improve them compared with unfinished tasks.

The distinction matters. Giving a pending action a specific occasion can address how it will get done. That doesn’t settle which choice is best. And fewer intrusive thoughts needn’t mean less anxiety.

Why it matters: Say you have chosen what to do. Planning how to carry it out then answers a different question from comparing the options again. The uncertainty that remains may be about carrying out the choice, not about choosing it.

Read the experiments on planning unfinished tasks.

Does leaving a choice open change anything?

Economic theory: preserving the option to learn before committing.

Sometimes the missing answer really does matter. In their 1994 book, Avinash K. Dixit and Robert S. Pindyck explain investment timing under uncertainty. They look at cases where a commitment cannot be fully undone and you can still act later.

Acting now can give up the chance to learn something before committing. Later information may reveal a poor opportunity. If it does, someone who waited may still avoid it. That flexibility has value within the models.

Waiting also gives up current benefits. And it can expose an opportunity to expiry. So the comparison includes both sides. One is what useful information could change. The other is what is lost while it arrives.

Some information comes only after a first action. In that case, just letting time pass doesn’t produce the learning. A first step can itself have information value.

Why it matters: These are conditional investment models. They are not experiments on personal decision worksheets. They explain why speed alone isn’t enough of a goal. A worthwhile wait keeps a useful choice open or improves the information you have for making it.

Read the chapters on investment under uncertainty.

Is wait and see enough?

What this means for you

Bring those distinctions together. Compare what each choice would mean from now. You can act. You can wait for a defined reason. Or you can keep, on purpose, an arrangement that suits you.

Use this comparison for an ordinary, nonurgent decision. Never use the exercise to replace an urgent or specialist assessment. If the choice needs expertise you don’t have, finding suitable help can be the next step.

Name what continues

Start with the arrangement that remains in place while you think. It may be a previous choice. It may be a default set from outside. Or it may simply be what happens while the question stays open.

Describe it without assuming it’s wrong. The enrollment example shows why a choice open to you and a choice you have carried out are different. It doesn’t show that every current arrangement needs changing.

Ask what would continue over an interval that fits your decision. If the arrangement suits the situation, keeping it on purpose is a possible conclusion. If it creates a relevant cost, make that cost visible before you compare other choices.

Separate a growing total from a growing monthly cost

Keep known recurring costs and benefits you are missing separate from uncertain gains. Also note any mental burden you feel. Don’t treat it as a measured financial cost. Keep an unknown benefit marked unknown. Don’t treat the best outcome you can imagine as certain.

Say an avoidable extra cost is the same each month. The total grows, but each extra month still adds the same amount. The cost adds up without speeding up. A claim that each month of waiting costs more than the last would need a different basis.

An expiry date has another pattern. An option may stop being open to you at a set point. Check that date and what is actually available. Don’t assume every opportunity is shrinking.

Don’t count the same loss twice under different names. Keep past costs as information for learning. Then compare future consequences over the same interval. A past loss alone doesn’t show that changing now is your best choice.

Ask what waiting would let you learn

Name a specific answer that could change your choice. Explain how you expect to obtain it and when it could arrive. If learning needs a first action, include that action in the comparison.

Use a comparison in words when exact values would be guesses. The question is whether the expected information or flexibility is worth the interval’s cost. Feeling uncertain doesn’t itself name anything useful that another interval will bring.

Turn the comparison into a feasible next step

Choose action when the future comparison favors a feasible change. Include the costs of making that change, not just the benefit you hope for.

Choose a defined wait when useful information or flexibility is worth its cost. Give the wait a review date or evidence trigger. Say what should be different then. A date alone doesn’t explain the reason for waiting. If nothing relevant will change before then, think again about what that wait would achieve.

Keep the current arrangement when it suits the situation. Keeping it on purpose is a choice too. You can name a relevant change that would make it worth reviewing.

Once the choice is clear, describe what you will do, when and where. The planning research makes this distinction useful. Knowing what you intend is one task. Spelling out how you’ll carry it out is another.

If an answer that matters is missing, finish with that question. Add a feasible way to seek information or qualified help. You don’t have to force a decision from invented numbers.

What is your wait for?

How about your daily life?

Is there a nonurgent arrangement you keep comparing but haven’t decided whether to change? Perhaps you’re weighing a subscription, a work routine or an optional project commitment.

What keeps happening while that question is open? What answer would make another period of waiting useful?

A situation I’d like to understandWhat is still unclear?
________________________________________
________________________________________

One suitable idea is enough. Choose a situation where you can still control when to act. Then carry it into the exercise.

My chosen situation: ____________________

Choosing it means you’ll examine it. It doesn’t mean you should change the arrangement.

Compare your next choices

Start with your chosen situation. If you came directly here, choose a nonurgent personal decision you’ve put off. Pick one where the current arrangement continues and you can still choose when to act.

Never use this exercise to replace an urgent or specialist assessment. When a decision needs expertise you don’t have, find suitable help instead of inventing an answer.

  1. Name the continuing arrangement. Complete: “Until I decide, __________ continues.” Is this a previous choice, a default set from outside or what happens while the question stays open?
  2. Choose the future interval. Use one that fits the actual decision. Compare acting, waiting and keeping the arrangement over that same interval.
    Interval: __________
  3. Separate the consequences. Record each of these separately: known recurring costs, benefits you are missing, checked expiry dates, uncertain gains and any mental burden. Mark each cost as fixed, recurring, changing under stated assumptions or unquantified.
    Known consequences and their basis: __________
    Unknowns and actual option constraints: __________
    Don’t count the same loss twice. Keep past losses outside the new forward comparison. Include the costs of acting.
  4. Explain what waiting buys. Name information or flexibility that could change the decision. Say how and when it arrives. Include any action needed to learn.
    Useful answer or flexibility, how to obtain it and when: __________
    Compare its expected usefulness with the interval’s costs and risks. Use words or ranges when exact values would be guesses.
  5. Choose the next course. Act if the comparison favors a feasible action. Wait for a defined reason if the expected benefit justifies the cost. Keep the arrangement if it suits the situation.
    If you lack an answer that matters, record the gap. Record a feasible step toward information or qualified help too.
    Choice or unresolved question, and why: __________
  6. Make the next step specific. State what you’ll do, when and where. For a wait, record a review date or evidence trigger. Record what should change before then too.
    Next action, when and where: __________
    Review date or relevant change: __________

Ask Jing

Become a Jingius.

Weigh up your wait

Loading interactive tool…

Your next step

You’ve finished when the next interval has an explicit course and reason. A clearly stated question with a way to address it counts too. Your record should explain what waiting would cost and what it could give you.

A note on the evidence

The enrollment comparison involved one institution. Administrative changes happened at the same time. The task experiments examined short-term thoughts and emotions. The investment account supplies conditional reasoning about uncertainty and commitment.

These sources answer different questions. Keep your own decision’s costs, the other choices you have and useful information visible. Don’t borrow a study’s outcome as a personal forecast.

How we prepared this module

This module connects a workplace enrollment study, lab planning experiments and economic theory about waiting. The closing exercise brings those distinctions to one nonurgent personal decision.

Sources

  • Gabriel D. Carroll, James J. Choi, David Laibson, Brigitte C. Madrian and Andrew Metrick. (November 2009). Optimal Defaults and Active Decisions. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 124(4), 1639–1674. Published version; abstract, p.1639; Sections II–III and footnote 5, pp.1643–1646; Section IV.A, pp.1648–1650.
  • E. J. Masicampo and Roy F. Baumeister. (October 2011; online June 20, 2011). Consider It Done! Plan Making Can Eliminate the Cognitive Effects of Unfulfilled Goals. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 101(4), 667–683. Advance online version: Study 1, printed p.3; Studies 5A–5B, pp.11–13; General Discussion, p.14.
  • Avinash K. Dixit and Robert S. Pindyck. (1994). Investment Under Uncertainty. Princeton University Press. Chapters 1–2 extract; Chapter 1, “2 The Option Approach,” internal p.3; “3 Irreversibility and the Ability to Wait,” pp.4–5; “4.A A Few Introductory Examples,” pp.6–7.