Say you’ve chosen to send your colleagues a short written update. You open your notes again and begin comparing it with a meeting. The choice is back on your desk, but what has changed?
Perhaps a colleague now needs a discussion. Perhaps you’re looking again at the same information. Those two cases call for different responses. A record gives you an account of the choice. You can compare it with what you know now.
The useful outcome is a clear choice, a next action and a way to spot reasons to revise it. You don’t have to make the decision permanent.
This module is for an ordinary work decision you’ve already chosen. You stay open to important changes in the reasons behind it.
What you’ll get from this module
In this module
By the end of this module, you’ll benefit from telling three jobs apart. They are risk exploration, recording a choice and reviewing its execution. Practitioner guidance, planning experiments and research on progress monitoring explain each job. You’ll use the practical lessons to choose a situation from daily life. Then you’ll try a written exercise. You’ll finish with a usable decision record or a clearly named missing fact.
Ask Jing
Become a Jingius.
What helps a choice become a next action?
Practitioner guidance: explore risks while the plan can change.
Gary Klein’s 2007 account describes a project premortem. After hearing the plan, team members imagine that the project has failed. Each one writes down plausible reasons alone. They share them, then use the list to strengthen the plan.
The imagined failure gives the discussion a specific question: what could explain this outcome? The purpose is to bring up possible problems while the plan can still change. Imagining a failure doesn’t show that it will happen.
Why it matters: This is a practitioner procedure. It comes with stories, not a controlled estimate of project success. The order matters. Explore possible problems while you can still change the plan. Do that before you commit to it or put it into action. It has a different job from recording a decision already made.
Read the practitioner account of a project premortem.
Practitioner guidance: preserve the reasoning before acting.
Shane Parrish’s decision-journal guide for Farnam Street describes what to record before acting. You record the situation, the alternatives, what you expect and your reasoning. Its webpage was first published in 2014 and later updated.
That timing matters. The entry describes the decision as you understood it then. Later review can compare that account with what happened. It doesn’t have to start from a newly written explanation of an old choice.
Why it matters: This is practitioner guidance. It is not a controlled test of whether people gain a sense of closure. The record gives you something concrete to return to. It holds what you thought when you made the choice. Writing that account and reviewing the outcome are separate moments.
Read the practitioner guide to keeping a decision journal.
Online experiment: specify an action rather than collect possibilities.
E. J. Masicampo and Roy F. Baumeister’s 2011 research looked at unfinished tasks and planning. In Study 5B, people described a task. Then they either made a specific plan or listed several possible actions. Another group described a completed task.
After a reading task, they said how much they had thought about their earlier task. The study recruited 80 people online and paid them. It analyzed 77 after exclusions.
On the 1–7 thought scale, the specific-plan group averaged 2.14. The group listing possible actions averaged 3.37. The difference was statistically significant. The plan said how, when and where to act.
Listing ways to do a task leaves the choice open. A specific plan says which action you intend to take, when and where. Both groups wrote, so the finding doesn’t single out writing itself. It concerns reported thoughts during a short reading task. It is not about how final a decision is.
Why it matters: Planning didn’t significantly reduce anxiety or increase contentment in that comparison. Fewer thoughts about a task and feeling better are different outcomes. A next-action line can be specific without promising emotional relief.
Read the experiments on planning and unfinished tasks.
Laboratory experiment: a plan can help until another route is needed.
In their 2012 study, Masicampo and Baumeister gave 102 undergraduates a task. They had to find an actor’s birth year while visiting websites. Some made a specific plan to use IMDb. Others had the same goal without that plan.
When people could reach both Wikipedia and IMDb, 95.5% of planners succeeded. Among non-planners, 68.0% did. When the task ended before IMDb was reached, Wikipedia offered an earlier chance. In that condition, 36.7% of planners succeeded. Among non-planners, 71.4% did.
Why it matters: The same planning approach helped in one condition and got in the way in another. Sticking to the planned website could mean missing the answer on another one. This was one lab task. Still, it shows a useful distinction. Reaching your goal and following your original plan are not always the same thing.
Read the experiment on plans and missed alternatives.
Research synthesis: review what happens after the choice.
Benjamin Harkin and colleagues’ 2016 meta-analysis—a study that combines results from other studies—included 138 randomized studies. Together they had 19,951 people. These studies tested methods that encouraged progress monitoring. They compared them with control conditions and measured how well people then reached their goals.
On average, the methods helped people make more progress toward their goals. The activity studied was checking progress toward a goal. Comparing rejected options again and again is a different activity.
Why it matters: For this lesson, that distinction gives later review a purpose. You can compare what you did and what happened with what you intended. Then you decide whether to adjust your approach. The research covers different goals. It offers no single review interval for every work decision.
Read the research synthesis on monitoring goal progress.
What this means for you
Try a brief record that keeps what you’ve chosen apart from what you’ll do next. Keep room for important changes. The aim is an account you can use. It does not declare that the choice can never change.
Give risk exploration a finishing point
Say the plan isn’t firm yet and important risks need attention. Then keep the premortem separate from the decision entry. Imagine failure and list plausible causes once. Then work out what each important risk requires.
A risk might call for a change to the plan. Or it might leave an unanswered question to resolve. Finish the exercise with those outputs. A longer list alone doesn’t tell you what to do differently.
If a required fact is missing, name the question. Don’t label the choice finished. This exercise doesn’t settle how much research a decision deserves. Required checks and safety constraints still come first.
Record the choice and its reasons before acting
Write the date, the chosen course, the main reasons and the assumptions. An assumption is something your reasoning depends on being true. Preserve any uncertainty that could change the choice.
Take the made-up update example. Say you chose writing because colleagues need a record they can look at later. That reason explains the choice. Writing only “send an update” would leave out why it made sense.
Keep the entry once it is usable. It should give an account of your thinking at that moment. Polishing it again and again would leave the recording task unfinished.
Turn the selected course into a next action
Add what you’ll do next, and when and where you’ll do it. This makes the difference between a choice and its execution visible.
For the made-up update, “prepare the written update at my desk after the project check-in” names an action and its setting. “Think about communication options” opens the choice again instead.
The planning experiment gives a reason to tell a specific action from possible actions. That study measured thoughts during reading, not certainty about a work choice. Keep the next action specific. Don’t expect the entry to provide emotional relief.
Name what would justify a change
Write the changes in evidence, requirements or feasibility that would justify reconsideration. Tie them to the reasons for your choice. That link helps you explain why a change matters. You are not reopening the choice for just any reason.
Say the update was chosen because people need a written reference. A new requirement for live discussion then changes what the communication must do. That is a reason to reconsider the format.
Important new evidence may also arrive that you didn’t expect. Treat the listed conditions as prompts for judgment. They are not a ban on responding to surprises. Never let a “decided” entry override required reassessment or safety constraints.
When the basis changes, keep the original entry. Then add the new date, the change and your revised choice. You then keep both the earlier reasoning and the reason for moving on.
Review execution at a useful checkpoint
Choose a checkpoint when the decision naturally needs one. Ask what action happened and what outcome is visible. Ask whether the basis of the choice has changed.
For the made-up update, the question could be whether the written update met the communication requirement. That looks at execution and new information. Comparing every rejected format again would answer a different question.
Use the review to find an adjustment or the next action. Finish the review when you have that result. You can still respond sooner if important evidence or requirements change.
How about your daily life?
Which ordinary work choice have you made but keep returning to? Perhaps it’s the format of an update. Perhaps it’s the order of a task or a way of preparing a document.
Where would a record of the reasons help you see whether anything important has changed? Where have you chosen a direction but left the next action unclear?
Write down ideas. One suitable idea is enough. Add others if they help you choose.
| A situation in my daily life | What I would like to improve |
|---|---|
| ____________________ | ____________________ |
| ____________________ | ____________________ |
Which would be most useful to work through now?
My chosen situation: ____________________
You can change your choice. Carry this situation into the exercise below.
Make a usable decision record
Start with your chosen situation. If you came straight here, choose an ordinary work decision. Pick one you have already made and are about to act on. Stay open to important changes in its basis.
Never use the record to override required reassessment or safety constraints. If a required fact is missing, record the unresolved question. Don’t call the choice finished. This exercise doesn’t decide how much research is enough.
- Record your choice and date. State the selected course plainly, before acting.
Choice and date: ____________________ - Preserve the reasons. Write the main reasons and assumptions that justify the choice now. Include uncertainty that could change it.
Reasons and assumptions: ____________________ - Name reasons to revisit. Write down changes in evidence, requirements or feasibility that would justify reconsideration. Add a checkpoint when the decision naturally needs one. Important evidence you didn’t expect can also justify a change.
Revisit conditions and checkpoint: ____________________ - Specify the next action. Write what you will do and when and where you will do it. Once the entry is usable, finish it and move on to that action.
Next action, when and where: ____________________ - Keep the record and update it when needed. Review execution and outcomes at your checkpoint, or sooner when the basis changes. Add a new date, the change and any revised choice. Preserve the original.
Ask Jing
Become a Jingius.
Your next step
You have finished the entry when it preserves your choice, reasons, revisit conditions and specific next action. If essential information is missing, your useful output is the named question that still needs an answer.
A note on the evidence
The sources look at different things. They are practitioners’ advice about decisions, people’s reported thoughts, success in a lab task and progress toward goals across studies. Progress monitoring concerns action over time. The planning result about thoughts doesn’t show emotional relief. Its counterexample shows why changed circumstances matter.
How we prepared this module
This module connects practitioner guidance with planning experiments and a research synthesis on progress monitoring. The made-up written-update example shows how a reason for choosing can also point to a reason to reconsider. The exercise brings those distinctions into one ordinary work situation.
Sources
- Gary Klein. (September 2007). Performing a Project Premortem. Harvard Business Review, reprint F0709A. Web-print version, PDF page 2, procedure following “A premortem is the hypothetical opposite”.
- Shane Parrish / Farnam Street. (2014; updated 2025). How a Decision Journal Changed the Way I make Decisions (Template Included). Farnam Street. Webpage retained October 14, 2026; “What is a Decision Journal?” and “A Decision Journal Template”.
- E. J. Masicampo and Roy F. Baumeister. (2011). Consider it done! Plan making can eliminate the cognitive effects of unfulfilled goals.. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 101(4), 667–683. Author-hosted advance-online publication, Study 5B, printed pages 12–13 / PDF pages 13–14.
- E. J. Masicampo and Roy F. Baumeister. (2012). Committed but Closed-Minded: When Making a Specific Plan for a Goal Hinders Success. Social Cognition, 30(1), 37–55. Published PDF, Method and Results, printed pages 44–47.
- Benjamin Harkin, Thomas L. Webb, Betty P. I. Chang, Andrew Prestwich, Mark Conner, Ian Kellar, Yael Benn, and Paschal Sheeran. (2016). Does Monitoring Goal Progress Promote Goal Attainment? A Meta-Analysis of the Experimental Evidence. Psychological Bulletin, 142(2), 198–229. Accepted manuscript, Abstract, manuscript page 2 / PDF page 3.
