Say you’re shown a new tool that makes a regular report faster to produce. You picture finishing early. Then you learn the plan is to give you more reports in the same working day.
In this made-up situation, the tool could deliver the speed it promised without giving you the benefit you expected. What happens to the time it saves? And who gets to decide?
Old arguments about machines help explain why those questions matter. The Luddites’ own documents include demands about pay and the quality of goods, alongside opposition to particular machines and violent threats. We can learn from their questions about work without copying their tactics.
This module is for working adults choosing a tool, or discussing one at work, where they have some choice or a real way to negotiate the terms.
What you’ll get from this module
In this module
By the end of this module, you’ll know how to separate the improvement a tool promises from what you would actually gain. We’ll look at Luddite documents, different estimates of past wages, workplace studies and a writers’ agreement from 2023. You’ll pick an everyday situation and think about the benefit, the information you share, how hard it would be to leave and who can change the terms. You’ll finish with one realistic request or safeguard, or a clear note of what is still unresolved.
Ask Jing
Become a Jingius.
What history and workplace research reveal about the terms
Old documents: pay and standards were part of the fight.
Kevin Binfield’s 2004 collection of documents includes a declaration by framework knitters dated 1 January 1812. It threatened textile machines, called frames, when they were used to make poor-quality goods or when workers weren’t paid the agreed rates. It also demanded payment in the country’s current coins.
These demands said what should be made and how workers should be paid. The dispute involved machines, but it was also about who set the terms of work. The writers claimed a charter gave them the right to destroy machinery. That claim did not make it legal.
The same collection includes a letter from Yorkshire, dated 9 or 10 March 1812, demanding that shearing machines be removed. It threatened destruction, burning and murder if anyone resisted. We don’t know for sure who received it, or where.
Why it matters: The documents show both worries about pay and opposition to particular machines. Seeing the grievances doesn’t turn the threats into harmless bargaining. Nor does it mean everyone involved wanted the same thing.
Read the documentary edition of Luddite demands.
Official reports: targets weren’t always chosen by pay.
The National Archives has an undated teaching resource that reproduces reports from 1812. In a February report from Nottingham, Robert Baker said anger at employers who paid lower rates was the main pattern he saw in the attacks.
He also described attacks on wide frames, and incidents whose motives he couldn’t trace. Pay helps explain the pattern he saw, but his report doesn’t explain every attack.
A reward poster dated 25 January 1812 makes the picture more complicated. It reported five stocking frames destroyed at George Ball’s premises in Lenton, though the poster said the workers using them were paid the full rates.
That poster was trying to get the attackers convicted, so it had reasons to show the employer in a good light. Full pay rates also don’t tell us everything about working conditions. Even so, this report means we can’t confidently say that employers who paid full rates were always left alone.
Why it matters: We can say that pay mattered. We can’t turn that into a rule that only employers who treated workers unfairly were attacked.
Read the archive documents on Luddite protests.
Estimates of past wages: output, pay and time worked tell different stories.
Robert C. Allen’s 2009 analysis compares estimates of British output and wages built from historical records. In the measures he chose, output per worker rose by 46% between 1780 and 1840, while real wages rose by 12%.
Real wages mean what pay can buy once prices are taken into account. In Allen’s comparison, workers produced much more, but what their pay could buy grew much less.
Allen also reports later gains. From 1840 to 1900, output per worker rose by 90% and real wages by 123%. Pay grew much faster in that later period. The link between output and pay changed over time.
Historians disagree about how much workers gained, and when. Gregory Clark’s 2005 estimates for English building workers suggest bigger wage gains over a different period. Much of the difference comes from his lower estimate of how much the cost of living rose.
Even in Clark’s account, real wages didn’t rise above their mid-1700s level until the 1820s. His results cover different workers, periods and measures, so they can’t simply replace Allen’s figures.
Jane Humphries and Jacob Weisdorf’s 2019 study adds another distinction. They looked at English records of yearly pay, mostly for men working on farms outside London. These suggest yearly income grew faster than estimates that multiplied daily pay by a fixed number of working days.
The authors argue those gains probably came from working more days each year. Their estimates still show the share of income going to workers at a low point during industrialization. Earning more over a year doesn’t always mean being paid more for a day’s work.
Why it matters: Each measure answers a different question. Did workers produce more? Did they earn more over the year? Did their work buy more? How much time did they spend working? And later average gains can’t tell us whether the particular workers pushed out of work during the Luddite years got their income back.
Read the analysis of output and wages by Allen. Read the reconstruction of building workers’ wages by Clark. Read the study of annual incomes by Humphries and Weisdorf.
A study of a change in the law: worker seats on the board did not bring a pay rise the researchers could measure.
Simon Jäger, Benjamin Schoefer and Jörg Heining’s 2021 study used a change in German company law to look at worker representation. The rule required worker representatives to hold one-third of the seats on the supervisory board of stock corporations, a particular legal type of company.
A 1994 reform removed that requirement for stock corporations set up after the change. Older corporations kept it, as did new ones with more than 500 employees.
The researchers compared corporations set up just before and just after the change. They also compared limited liability companies, another type of company whose rules hadn’t changed. That second comparison helped them separate the effect of the board rules from differences linked to when a company was set up.
They found no measurable rise in wages, or in the share of the value produced that went to workers’ pay. Smaller pay rises were still possible within the margin of error. The result doesn’t prove the effect was exactly zero, and it doesn’t settle the value of every kind of worker representation.
Why it matters: Having representatives and getting a pay change are separate outcomes. The study shows why it helps to ask what a particular arrangement actually changes. Having worker representatives doesn’t, on its own, tell us whether workers were paid more.
Read the study of labour representation on company boards.
Surveys: sharing arrangements depend on the workplace around them.
Douglas Kruse, Richard Freeman and Joseph Blasi’s 2008 working paper looked at pay arrangements linked to how well a company performs, such as profit sharing. It used US national survey data and a separate survey of employees in companies that make heavy use of these arrangements.
Workers more involved in these arrangements tended to have higher pay and benefits, more say in decisions and other good outcomes. The results depended on other workplace policies. The researchers couldn’t show that sharing caused those benefits.
Sharing can be part of an arrangement that benefits workers. But the label alone doesn’t tell you who qualifies, how gains are worked out or what risks workers carry.
Why it matters: When discussing a tool, look at the sharing terms on offer. The survey findings don’t promise a pay rise just because you ask to share the gains.
Read the working paper on employee outcomes under shared compensation.
A negotiated agreement: questions about technology can become written terms.
The September 2023 agreement between the Writers Guild of America and the Alliance of Motion Picture and Television Producers gives a concrete example. It set several rules for generative AI in the film and television writing the agreement covered.
When a company gave a writer AI-generated material that hadn’t been published or used before, as the basis for their writing, it had to say the material came from AI. Protections for the writer’s pay and writing credit also applied. Writers needed the company’s consent to use generative AI themselves.
Companies couldn’t make using generative AI for covered writing a condition of the job. Some requirements for other uses, ones that didn’t produce written material, were still allowed. The rules depended on the use. They weren’t a blanket ban on AI.
The document shows what the agreement set out, not how much income those terms protected in the end. It is an example from history, not a statement of your rights today.
The example makes the questions specific. Who supplies the material? What must be disclosed? How is the writer’s work treated? Who can approve a use?
Why it matters: Those questions link the modern example to the older concern about terms. The comparison doesn’t make the technologies, job markets or outcomes the same.
Read the 2023 writing agreement’s AI provisions.
What this means for you
Start with one tool and one piece of work. What benefit do you expect? What would it cost you, or make you depend on? Which terms can you realistically influence?
Name the benefit you would actually receive
Before you take up an optional tool, or discuss a rollout at work, name what should become faster or better. Then separate that improvement from the benefit you expect: time for other work, a changed workload, pay, or useful results you get to keep.
Go back to the made-up report example. Faster reports could make room for more assignments. If your aim is fewer working hours, finishing more reports wouldn’t on its own tell you whether you got there.
Include checking and fixing work when you describe the change. A quicker first draft doesn’t settle the total workload. Ask what will happen to the time freed up, and who can agree to that.
Make one concrete request, such as an agreement on workload or a review with someone who can act. A general promise to make work easier leaves the result open. A talk about workload, with a set point to review it, gives you something specific to ask about later. Write down what is promised, what is agreed and what is still undecided.
Examine a sharing arrangement before relying on it
If a real sharing arrangement is on offer, ask how the gains are worked out, who controls the measure and which workers qualify. Check what happens when output or revenue falls.
Look at what the measure includes. A measure that leaves out checking, extra duties or quality standards may not capture the benefit you care about. A rise in revenue also isn’t automatically money available to share out.
If you don’t know how the payment is worked out or whether you qualify, find out before you count it as a benefit. If you would carry a loss when results fall, include that risk in your decision. This is a check on pay terms, not advice to buy shares in your employer.
Find the person who can change the relevant term
Name the decision you want changed: rates, quotas, access, workload or another rule. Then find out who can approve that change, and whether you have a manager or representative you can actually go through.
Being invited to discuss a change gives you a place to raise a question. It doesn’t mean the person listening can change the term that matters to you. If they can’t approve it, ask which channel reaches someone who can.
If the tool is compulsory, or pushing back would be unsafe, write that down. Use a suitable existing channel where there is one. The exercise doesn’t ask you to refuse a rollout at work or pretend you have a choice you don’t.
Check the information and the way out
For a tool you choose yourself, work out what work, personal information or behaviour it takes in. Check who may see, reuse or keep that information under its terms.
If optional use asks for information you didn’t expect to give, get the terms clarified or share less where sharing is optional. For workplace tools, ask the person responsible. Never move confidential work into a service you’re not allowed to use, just to test an alternative.
Also check that you can get the work you need back out in a usable form before the tool becomes essential. Count time, fees, permissions and lost features in your picture of what leaving would take.
Say you can download a file, but the task also needs access permissions or links between items that the download doesn’t keep. In that made-up example, having the file isn’t enough to carry on the work somewhere else.
Test the specific retrieval or handover you need, through an approved route. If it fails, name the missing permission, feature or help with moving. Keep a usable copy or another route where you’re allowed to. Don’t treat one successful export as proof that everything can move.
Review what happened, then choose one feasible improvement
Once you’ve used it enough to see whether the promised benefit shows up, compare what you intended with what happened. Look at pay, hours, workload and useful output, including checking and fixing.
If the work got faster but extra assignments swallowed the time, write that down. It may still be useful capacity, but it isn’t the protected time you expected. Take that difference into your next conversation with someone who can act.
Pick one improvement you can actually make, rather than treating every open question as a reason to reject the tool. If a particular use is optional, asking for changed terms or turning down that use may be open to you. Where your power is limited, a clearly stated open question may be the useful result.
How about your daily life?
Where are you thinking about a tool, or being asked to use one, without yet having pinned down the benefit?
You might choose a regular work report, a writing service you picked yourself, or a team tool that holds work you need to get back. Think about what you want to keep and what you’d need to ask.
Write down a situation you’d like to understand better. One good idea is enough.
| A situation in my daily life | The benefit or term I want to understand |
|---|---|
| ____________________ | ____________________ |
| ____________________ | ____________________ |
My chosen situation: ____________________
Choose a situation where you have some choice, or a real channel for discussing terms. You can change your choice. Take it into the exercise below. Picking a situation doesn’t yet decide whether you adopt or refuse anything.
Check the terms of one tool
Start with your chosen situation. If you came straight here, choose one tool you can decide about, or discuss through a real channel at work. Write about one task it would affect.
For workplace tools, follow approved routes and ask the person responsible about terms you’re unsure of. Never move confidential work into a service you’re not allowed to use. If the decision is compulsory, or pushing back would be unsafe, write down that limit and use a suitable existing channel where there is one.
- Describe the intended benefit and who would receive it. What becomes faster or better? Who gets the money, time, capacity or useful output? Include checking, fixing and extra duties when you think about workload.
Intended benefit, who receives it and relevant work: ____________________
If a sharing arrangement is offered, check how gains are worked out, who qualifies, who controls the measure and what happens when results fall. Write down what you don’t know before relying on it. - Identify information and exit terms. What information goes into the tool, and who may see, reuse or keep it? What would leaving take in time, fees, permissions or lost features?
Information, exit requirements and unknowns: ____________________
For a tool you chose yourself, try getting back the specific work you need before it becomes essential. Use an approved route and check whether the result works for that task. If it fails, name the missing help or feature. An export on its own doesn’t show that your whole way of working can move. - Find who can decide and choose one feasible request. Who can change the rate, quota, access rule or workload in question? Can you ask directly, or through a manager or representative?
Person or channel, and one request or safeguard: ____________________
Keep a promise separate from an agreed term. If you have no real route, say so. For an optional use, consider changed terms, sharing less where it’s optional, or turning down that particular use, depending on what is unresolved. - Name the result you will review. Once you’ve used it enough to judge the promised benefit, check what happened to your pay, hours, workload or useful output. Include checking and fixing work.
What I will check, and what would prompt a further discussion: ____________________
Ask Jing
Become a Jingius.
Your next step
You have finished when you can name the intended benefit, who receives it, and your main cost or dependency. Include one request you can realistically make, or a clear limit on what you can change. Keep the result you plan to review with that record.
A note on the evidence
The old documents preserve different demands and points of view. Estimates of past wages disagree about how big the gains were and when they came, and higher yearly income can mean more work. Later average gains don’t tell us what happened to the particular workers pushed out of work.
The modern sources answer different questions. One studies a specific board arrangement, another links sharing arrangements with outcomes for employees, and the agreement records terms that were negotiated. A link found in a survey doesn’t prove cause and effect, and an agreement doesn’t show what people gained in the end.
How we prepared this module
This module brings together old documents, wage estimates, workplace research and a past agreement to explain questions about who benefits and who decides. Made-up report and export examples make the decisions concrete. The written exercise helps you look at one tool’s terms and choose a realistic next step.
Sources
- Kevin Binfield (ed.). (2004). Writings of the Luddites. Johns Hopkins University Press. Digital reproduction; M10, printed pp.89–90 / PDF pp.120–121; Y5, printed pp.208–210 / PDF pp.239–241.
- The National Archives. (Undated; documents January–March 1812). Why did the Luddites protest?. Education resource, 14-page PDF. Source 2, HO 42/119 f.135, PDF pp.7–8; Source 3, HO 42/120 f.3–4, PDF p.10.
- Robert C. Allen. (2009). Engels’ pause: Technical change, capital accumulation, and inequality in the british industrial revolution. Explorations in Economic History, 46(4), 418–435. Author-hosted article-in-press version; introduction p.2 and Appendix B, pp.15–17.
- Gregory Clark. (December 2005). The Condition of the Working Class in England, 1209–2004. Journal of Political Economy, 113(6), 1307–1340. Author manuscript; p.12, paragraph beginning “Figure 8 shows”.
- Jane Humphries and Jacob Weisdorf. (2019). Unreal Wages? Real Income and Economic Growth in England, 1260–1850. The Economic Journal, 129(623), 2867–2887. Accepted manuscript deposited October 2018; §3, printed pp.6–8 / PDF pp.7–9; §4.3, printed p.18 / PDF p.19.
- Simon Jäger, Benjamin Schoefer and Jörg Heining. (2021). Labor in the Boardroom. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 136(2), 669–725. 20 October 2020 author manuscript; introduction, printed pp.1–2 / PDF pp.2–3.
- Douglas Kruse, Richard Freeman and Joseph Blasi. (August 2008). Do Workers Gain by Sharing? Employee Outcomes under Employee Ownership, Profit Sharing, and Broad-based Stock Options. National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER), Working Paper 14233. Abstract, PDF p.2; printed pp.1,9 / PDF pp.3,11.
- Writers Guild of America and Alliance of Motion Picture and Television Producers. (September 2023). Memorandum of Agreement for the 2023 WGA Theatrical and Television Basic Agreement. Historical 2023 MOA; §25, Article 72.C–E, pp.69–70.
