Concept

A tool change is worth making when it removes something that gets in the way of the action you want.

Issue

When the same task keeps going wrong, it’s hard to tell whether you need a different tool, a clearer plan or better support.

Solutions

Learn what to look for in a work problem that keeps coming back, then choose a targeted change.

Say you leave a meeting with a clear next action. Later, you open your task list and can’t find it. You start thinking about moving everything to a new app.

Before you decide, work out what happened between leaving the meeting and looking for that action. Maybe you never wrote it down. Maybe you wrote it somewhere you couldn’t find again. Those two possibilities call for different changes.

A new tool can add something that was missing, or make the right action easier. A clearer plan can help you use something you already have. The place to start is the action that failed and what was going on around it.

This module is for working adults with a work problem that keeps coming back, where mistakes have limited consequences and they can influence what happens.

What you’ll get from this module

In this module

By the end of this module, you’ll have a clearer way to decide what needs changing when a work routine keeps failing. We’ll draw on workplace studies, a daily-reporting experiment, research on smartphone use and accounts from people who stopped tracking. You’ll learn to tell a missing capability from a missed action, pick one situation from your own life and work through a written exercise. You’ll finish with a targeted change to try, or a clear note of the information or help you still need.

What changes when the conditions change?

Field experiment: a different default on existing printers.

Johan Egebark and Mathias Ekström looked at printing at a Swedish university in a 2013 working paper. On 25 printers across 18 departments, the researchers changed the default from single-sided to double-sided printing. Each department switched at a randomly chosen time.

Daily paper use fell by about 15%. People were still printing double-sided six months later, while the new default was still in place.

A default is the option you get unless you choose another. The printers could already print double-sided. Changing the starting option changed how that ability was used. This shows how a change to the working environment can help bring about the action you want.

Why it matters: The setting kept helping because it stayed in place. People used less paper without having to choose double-sided every time. That useful result doesn’t show how they would print without the setting.

Read the working paper on printer defaults.

Workplace study: planning and convenient facilities.

Could a specific plan help people act differently? Could making the action easier help too? Rob W. Holland, Henk Aarts and Daan Langendam looked at both questions in a 2006 study of 109 office workers across six departments of a Dutch telecom company.

The departments got different arrangements: plans for when, where and how to recycle, paper-recycling boxes close by, both together, or nothing new as a comparison. The researchers measured the waste in people’s personal bins over a two-month follow-up.

Both the plans and the nearby boxes cut the paper in those bins. The planning group also threw away fewer cups. The paper results for planning and for boxes weren’t significantly different. That doesn’t prove the two approaches work equally well.

The authors call this a quasi-experiment. Whole departments got the different arrangements, rather than people being assigned one by one. With only six departments, differences between departments limit how sure the comparison can be. Even so, the findings give you a reason to think about both a clear plan and how easy the action is to carry out.

Why it matters: A plan and a more convenient setting deal with different parts of the situation. The study didn’t compare which should come first.

Read the workplace study of planning and recycling facilities.

Which change fits what went wrong?

Daily-life experiment: completing an action and doing it automatically.

In a 2015 study, Katarzyna Stawarz, Anna Louise Cox and Ann Blandford asked people to send a daily text about their lunch for 28 days. Of the 133 people randomly assigned, mostly students, 96 finished the study and were included in the analysis.

The researchers compared reminders, a cue tied to finishing lunch, and no assigned cue. They also varied whether people got a confirmation message. The reminder groups sent an average of 94% of the expected reports. The lunch-cue groups sent 76%, and the groups with no assigned cue sent 75%.

Yet by the end, the people with reminders said the action felt less automatic than both other cue groups did. Lunch cues did no better than no assigned cue on that measure.

Completing an action and doing it automatically are two different outcomes. The reminders helped people send their reports more reliably, even though the action still felt deliberate to them.

Why it matters: These results come from the people who finished an assigned reporting task. The study didn’t test what happened after the reminders were taken away. Doing something reliably with support can be a worthwhile result on its own.

Read the study of reminders and habit formation.

Explain what a streak shows

Field observation and separate experiment: making an unwanted action easier to stop.

Sometimes the problem is an action you want to stop. David J. Grüning, Frederik Riedel and Philipp Lorenz-Spreen studied an app called one sec in a 2023 paper. The app adds a pause when you open a chosen app, and offers you the choice not to open it after all.

Of 719 people recruited, 280 used the app for six weeks. Among them, attempts to open the target apps fell from an average of 166 in week one to 105 in week six. These were volunteers, and there was no randomly chosen group without the app to compare against. So the drop can’t show that the app caused it.

A separate online experiment with 500 people tested the parts one at a time, using videos. An explicit option to skip a video before it started worked best. A delay helped too, but adding a delay to the skip option gave no clear extra benefit. A message asking people to think about what they were about to watch made no difference on its own in that task.

Why it matters: This points to a useful design question: does the interruption give you a real way to stop? More interruptions are not automatically better. Keep the field observation separate from the controlled task when you weigh the evidence. One more thing to know: the app’s creator was one of the authors.

Read the smartphone-use study and separate component experiment.

Qualitative study: different reasons for leaving a tool behind.

In 2016, Daniel A. Epstein and colleagues studied people who had stopped tracking their activity, money or location. The researchers collected follow-up answers from 193 people and interviewed 12 of them.

People gave several reasons for stopping. Some doubted the quality of their data. Others had learned what they needed, or their circumstances had changed.

These are people looking back on why they stopped, and they were chosen because they had stopped. Their accounts describe possible reasons for giving up a tool. They don’t say how often users give up, or point to one single cause.

That variety changes the question to ask about a tool you no longer use. Did the activity get harder to keep up? Did the information stop being useful? Or had the tool already answered the question that made it useful?

Why it matters: A tool can help you even if you stop using it in the end. Knowing why you stopped helps you decide whether to fix a problem, replace the tool or leave it behind.

Read the study of life after tracking.

What this means for you

Before you change a tool, decide what you want the change to help you do. You might need a clearer plan, an easier way to act, a well-timed reminder or a chance to stop an unwanted action.

Name the action before judging the tool

Describe something you can see happen. “Stay organized” leaves you guessing about whether you managed it. In the made-up meeting example, a clearer outcome is writing down the next action somewhere you’ll find it when you get back to work.

Now try that exact action on purpose, with your current setup. Use a known example and follow the instructions. Can you store it properly and find it again?

If you can’t, find what’s in the way. You may be missing a function, a permission or an instruction. If it turns out to be an access or capability problem, fix it when you find it. You don’t need to train a habit first.

If you can do the action on purpose but miss it during your routine, look at what happens at that moment. A missed cue is one possibility. Unclear priorities, too much work or information that hasn’t arrived may also explain the miss.

Having the same problem in several apps doesn’t settle its cause. They may all share the same limitation, or the situation around them may be the same each time. Keep your explanation open to what you observe.

Connect an action to a moment you can recognize

The recycling study shows why a plan and a convenient setup can both help. A plan tells you when and how to act. A nearby recycling box makes the action easier.

For the made-up meeting problem, you could write: “When the meeting ends, I write the next action in the place I’ll look.” That names a moment and a response you can check.

Then look at the route. If writing the action down breaks at a confusing step, walk through that step slowly and on purpose. Simplify it, or get the instruction you’re missing. If a function you need isn’t there, changing the tool may be the right fix.

If the moment rarely happens the way you expect, revise the plan. If you can’t act because information hasn’t arrived, work out who can provide it, or change what you’ve committed to. A sharper personal reminder can’t supply an input that’s missing.

A convenient path or a default is useful when it usually matches the action you want. Keep a clear exception for the times it doesn’t. Choose the smallest useful change you can judge.

Keep support that serves your goal

Decide what success means in this situation. If you want the next action written down reliably, a reminder that helps you do that may belong in the solution.

Put a reminder at a moment when you can act on it, and make clear what it asks you to do. Then watch whether the action happens. A notification going out is not the same as the task getting done.

The lunch-report study helps explain why a streak of completed actions isn’t proof that an action has become automatic. A reminder can support what you do while the action still feels deliberate.

If doing without the reminder matters to you, test that separately, somewhere low-stakes. Never remove essential safeguards, such as required checks at work, to prove you can manage without them. If independence isn’t your goal, useful support can stay.

Give an unwanted action a genuine exit

When you keep starting something you meant to avoid, think about a small pause with a clear alternative to carrying on. The online video experiment suggests paying attention to the choice you’re offered at the interruption.

Aim at the unwanted action. Check whether the extra step changes that behavior, whether you work around it, and whether it gets in the way of work you need to do.

The same app may serve both wanted and unwanted tasks. A barrier that blocks necessary work needs changing. You’re looking for a helpful change at the troublesome moment, not the largest possible number of obstacles.

Review the outcome and the reason for a miss

Keep a simple record of the relevant occasions. Note the moment, whether the intended action happened, what support you needed, and what got in the way when it didn’t.

In the meeting example, writing an action down and finding it later both matter. Counting entries alone would miss a problem with finding them. Record the result you actually wanted.

Choose a time to review what happened, after you’ve had several chances to try the action. Compare occasions where the task and the information or resources you needed were similar. If circumstances keep changing, note that difference before you judge the change. When the action still fails, go back to your explanation rather than adding another feature out of habit.

If the support works, keep it where it’s useful. If a tracker no longer helps you decide anything, ask whether you still need it. The accounts from former trackers show why stopping can mean several things. Look at what it means for you.

Where the problem depends on workload or rules outside your control, bring in the person responsible, or change what you’ve committed to. A clear, unresolved constraint is a useful result too.

What keeps going wrong?

How about your daily life?

Where do you keep meaning to do something, only to lose the action somewhere between intending and doing?

You might choose writing up a meeting follow-up, finding a note you saved, or starting an app visit you meant to avoid. You could also think about a tracker you stopped using, and whether the original need is still there.

Write down a situation you’d like to handle differently. One good idea is enough. Add others if they help you choose.

A situation in my daily lifeWhat I would like to improve
________________________________________
________________________________________

Which situation would be most useful to explore now?

My chosen situation: ____________________

Choose a work problem that keeps coming back, where mistakes have limited consequences and you can influence what happens. You can change your choice. Carry this situation into the exercise below. Choosing it doesn’t yet tell you what needs changing.

Choose a targeted change

Start with your chosen situation. If you came straight here, pick one work problem that keeps coming back, where mistakes have limited consequences and you can influence what happens. Writing down and finding a meeting action is one example.

Keep required controls in place. Never remove essential safeguards, such as required checks at work, to test whether you can manage without them. This exercise is about ordinary work routines, not medical assessment.

  1. Describe the successful action and its occasion. Write what you want to happen and when a relevant chance comes up. Make the result something you can see: an action written down and found again, for example, rather than “be more organized.”
    Action, occasion and observable result: ____________________
  2. Check whether you can do it deliberately. Try the exact action with a known example and the right instructions. If it fails, work out what’s missing: a permission, a function, some knowledge or an input.
    If it turns out to be an access or capability problem, fix it now. If you can’t fix it, name the information or help you need before going further. If the action works, look at what stops it during your routine.
    What worked, what failed and what remains unknown: ____________________
  3. Choose a targeted response and support. Tie a moment you can recognize to an action you can manage. For a confusing step, simplify the route or get the missing instruction. For a missed action, think about a reminder you can act on, at a moment when you can act.
    Use a default only when it usually matches the action you want and a clear exception remains. For an unwanted action, think about a pause with a genuine exit, and check that the work you need to do is still possible.
    If workload, missing inputs or shared rules stop the action, bring in the person responsible or change what you’ve committed to. Treat your explanation as provisional, and choose the smallest useful change you can judge.
    Occasion, response and chosen support or help: ____________________
  4. Observe relevant opportunities. Record what happened, not just whether the tool was open or a notification arrived. Note the support you used and the reasons for any miss, so you can tell what needs attention.
OccasionDid the intended action happen?Support usedFailure reason or unknown
________________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________________
  1. Choose a review point and a next decision. Review after enough similar occasions to learn something about this routine. If the action still fails, go back to your proposed cause. If conditions differed, note that before you draw a conclusion.
    Keep useful support where it serves the goal. Test doing without it separately, and only if that matters and the setting is low-stakes. Keep essential safeguards in place. If a tracker no longer serves a useful decision, think again about its place.
    Review point: ____________________
    Keep, revise, repair or seek help—and why: ____________________

Ask Jing

Become a Jingius.

Choose one change and watch what it does

Loading interactive tool…

Your next step

You have a useful result when you can name the action, what may be getting in its way, and your next change or question. After watching the routine for a while, use what you recorded to decide what to keep or revise.

A note on the evidence

The studies look at different actions and outcomes. Workplace printing and recycling are closer to work routines than the assigned reporting task or the online video experiment. Each one belongs to its own setting.

In the reporting study, dropout differed between groups, and everyone got weekly summaries. In the smartphone study, people volunteered, and the analysis covered only six-week users, which limits the field comparison. The tracker accounts describe people’s reasons for stopping, not how common stopping is.

Use these differences to choose what to watch in your own situation: whether the action got done, the support it needed, and the reason for a miss.

How we prepared this module

This module brings together studies of defaults, planning, reminders and digital friction with first-hand accounts of leaving tracking tools behind. A made-up meeting example shows how similar-looking failures can lead to different choices. The written exercise helps you look at one ordinary work routine.

Sources