Say you want to get back in touch with an old friend. You start typing a message, then wonder whether calling would feel warmer. You picture an awkward silence and go back to the keyboard.
There are two different questions here. What do you expect the conversation to feel like? And what would let both of you take part comfortably? If you’re avoiding a call because you expect it to feel awkward, that guess is worth questioning. If either person needs a different way to communicate, or you can’t find a time that suits you both, the choice needs to make room for that.
This module is for personal conversations you choose to have, where both people can comfortably use the channel and agree on the time.
What you’ll get from this module
In this module
By the end of this module, you’ll know how to tell a nervous guess apart from a practical reason to choose writing. Experiments on getting back in touch, tone and support, and surveys about relationships and how people like to communicate, explain what different channels can offer. You’ll use this to pick an everyday situation and finish with a channel you agree on together, or a question you still need to ask.
Ask Jing
Become a Jingius.
What changes when you change the channel?
Field experiment: reconnecting with someone from your past.
Amit Kumar and Nicholas Epley’s 2021 paper included an experiment with University of Chicago students. Each student thought of someone they had once been close to but hadn’t contacted for at least a couple of years. They were randomly assigned to get back in touch by phone or by email during the next week.
The students already expected to feel more connected by phone. They also expected more awkwardness, and most preferred email. Among those who made contact and did the follow-up, people assigned to phone said they felt a stronger bond afterward than those assigned to email. The researchers found no difference in how awkward it actually felt.
Only 103 of the 200 students recruited finished the experiment. A second rating of connection also favored phone calls, but that difference didn’t reach the usual bar for statistical significance. In other words, the evidence on that second measure wasn’t clear enough to show a difference. The findings describe the experiences of those who followed through.
The useful surprise is about awkwardness. Students expected a call to feel more awkward than an email, yet the researchers didn’t find that difference in what they reported. The students had already expected calling to bring them closer. Worry about discomfort could still make email look more appealing.
Why it matters: The experiment didn’t show how the other person felt about the exchange, or what setting up a call cost either person. It gives you a reason to offer a call when getting back in touch, while still asking what works for the other person.
Read the experiment on reconnecting by phone or email.
Laboratory experiment: hearing a tone that writing leaves out.
Tone is another part of the choice. Justin Kruger, Nicholas Epley, Jason Parker and Zhi-Wen Ng’s 2005 research included a controlled task about sarcasm with Cornell students. Each student picked set statements and either typed them exactly or recorded themselves saying them. Their partners worked out whether each statement was sarcastic or serious.
Recorded speech got the intended tone across more accurately than email. The senders didn’t expect that difference. The spoken recording carried something that the exact written words didn’t get across as well in this task.
Because the voice was recorded, this comparison didn’t depend on a quick reply. It helps separate hearing how someone says something from simply talking at the same time. Everyday writing lets you explain and clear things up in a way this narrow task didn’t.
Why it matters: The practical point is about the message the other person actually gets. Hearing your intended tone in your own head doesn’t mean the words carry it clearly to someone else.
Read the experiments on communicating tone by email.
Relationship survey: text as part of a satisfying connection.
Getting back in touch once is different from an ongoing relationship. Susan Holtzman, Kostadin Kushlev, Alisha Wozny and Rebecca Godard’s 2021 study looked at reports from 647 university students in Canada. All were dating or in a relationship without being married. The study compared how partners communicated in long-distance relationships and in relationships where they lived nearby.
Among people in long-distance relationships, texting more often went with being more satisfied with the relationship. So did how responsive they thought their partner was when texting. For people whose partners lived nearby, more frequent voice calls went with greater satisfaction instead.
This was a survey at one point in time. A happy relationship could shape how partners communicate, so these links don’t show that sending more texts would improve a relationship.
Why it matters: These findings give writing a useful place in the discussion. Feeling closer after one catch-up and being happy with an ongoing relationship are different results. A channel that helps in one exchange needn’t become a rule for every relationship.
Read the survey of texting and relationship satisfaction.
Preference survey: the channel must be usable by the person.
Philippa L. Howard and Felicity Sedgewick’s 2021 survey asked people who identified as autistic to rank ways of communicating in different situations, and to explain their choices. They included people with a clinical diagnosis and people who had diagnosed themselves.
Text and face-to-face contact both ranked highly for family and friends. People said writing gave them time to think, put a reply together and reread what had been said. Some described finding spoken information hard to take in, and phone conversations hard to keep up with.
These were reported preferences and experiences, not a trial showing that one channel improves every autistic person’s relationships. Hearing a voice or seeing a face doesn’t make a channel the right choice for everyone.
Why it matters: That is why it helps to ask what works for the person you’re contacting. Writing may give them the time or clarity they need to take part. What they prefer can be a practical need to respect.
Read the survey of communication preferences in the autism community.
Laboratory support experiment: a benefit from presence, and a benefit from text.
Susan Holtzman, Drew DeClerck, Kara Turcotte, Diana Lisi and Michael Woodworth’s 2017 research compared support after a stressful task in a laboratory. In its second experiment, young adults got support in person, support by text or no support. A trained person gave the support.
Support in person led to more positive feelings than support by text, and support by text led to more positive feelings than none. The researchers found no difference between the three groups in how stressed people said they felt. Feeling more positive and feeling less stressed gave different answers in this experiment.
The support followed a set structure, and the text exchanges had more time than the in-person ones. This was about recovering straight after a laboratory task, not a test of comfort after a death.
Why it matters: The comparison shows two things at once. Being there in person can offer something valuable, while written support people can use can also help. Not being able to visit needn’t stop you offering contact the person wants.
Read the experiments comparing text and in-person support.
What this means for you
Start with what you want the conversation to do, and what lets both people take part. A channel can offer something useful and still be a poor fit for this person or this moment.
Start with the purpose
Name what you want the exchange to do: get back in touch, clear up a message, share practical details or offer comfort. This tells you what the channel needs to carry.
For getting back in touch, hearing each other may be worth offering. For details someone needs to look at again, writing can give them a record. Choose the easiest option you both can use that still does the job.
Say you want to get back in touch, but your friend can only swap messages at different times. A call would need a time you both have free, and you don’t have one. Writing lets you do what you set out to do in a way you can both use.
Separate a prediction from a constraint
Ask what makes you hesitate about another channel. Expecting a silence to feel awkward is a guess. Needing privacy, time to choose your words or a way to receive them that you can actually use is a practical condition.
Check those conditions first. If a call works for both of you and you both want it, expecting awkwardness alone needn’t settle the choice. You can offer a conversation and agree on the time.
If you do have that conversation, compare what you expected with what happened. Ask whether the channel suited the other person too. Use what you noticed when you talk about a future exchange, without turning one experience into a rule.
Let access and preference change the answer
Ask which options work for the other person, instead of assuming the way you prefer works for them. If either person can’t comfortably hear or use speech, and writing works for both of you, choose writing. Another option you share, such as talking visually in sign language, may fit instead.
Wanting to hear someone’s voice doesn’t cancel their need to read and reply in writing. If preferences differ, you might prepare in writing, find a live time that suits you both or keep the exchange written. A person can turn down a call without having to prove their reason.
Clarify the meaning before changing the medium
When a message’s tone is unclear, say what you meant, or ask about the exact words you don’t understand. This deals with the missing meaning directly. Changing the channel only helps if it helps both people clear up that meaning.
You can offer a live exchange when hearing how something is said, and replying together, would help. Agree on the channel and time first. If writing is still the option that works, keep clearing things up in writing, rather than treating it as a failed conversation.
Offer support the person can receive
When someone has had a setback, ask whether writing, a call, a video call or a visit would help. Offer a visit when they want one and you can manage it. Keep a written option they can use open when you can’t.
The support experiment helps explain why these choices can sit side by side. An advantage for being there in person on positive feelings doesn’t make support by text worthless. The person’s needs, and the contact you can really offer, decide the next step.
How about your daily life?
Is there someone you want to get back in touch with? A message whose tone you want to clear up? Someone you want to support without assuming they want a call?
Write down situations where choosing the channel on purpose could help. One good idea is enough.
| A situation in my daily life | What I want the exchange to accomplish |
|---|---|
| ____________________ | ____________________ |
| ____________________ | ____________________ |
Which situation would be most useful to look at now?
My chosen situation: ____________________
Choose a personal conversation you want to have. You can change your choice. Carry it into the exercise below.
Choose a channel together
Start with your chosen situation. If you came straight here, choose a personal conversation you want to have. Both people must be able to comfortably use the channel and agree on the time.
- Name the purpose. Write down what you want to get across or understand: getting back in touch, clearing something up, practical details or comfort.
Purpose: ____________________ - Check what each person needs. Think about access, privacy, time to prepare, a written record, timing and preference. Ask about anything you don’t know. If speech that has to be heard won’t work and writing works for both of you, choose writing or another option you can both use.
Known needs and questions still to ask: ____________________ - Examine expected awkwardness. Describe what you expect to feel uncomfortable. Keep that guess apart from the practical conditions above. It can be a reason to think again about an option, but never a reason to overrule the other person.
Prediction, if relevant: ____________________ - Offer a workable choice. Choose the easiest channel you both can use that still does the job. Offer a call for getting back in touch when it works for both of you, clear up unclear wording, or ask what kind of support would help. Agree before you switch to a live exchange. If no live time works, keep writing open. If someone says no, respect that choice.
Agreed channel and time, or unresolved question: ____________________ - Review the experience if the exchange happens. Compare what you expected with what happened, and ask whether the channel suited the other person. Use that when you talk about future contact.
What I noticed and what they preferred: ____________________
Ask Jing
Become a Jingius.
Your next step
You have finished when you have an option you agree on, or a clear question that has to be settled first. An invitation with no reply is still waiting; it isn’t agreement.
A note on the evidence
Feeling connected after an exchange, understanding someone’s tone, preferring a channel and being happy with a relationship are different results. Many people didn’t finish the reconnection experiment, and the surveys describe particular groups. Use these findings to inform a choice you make together, while keeping each person’s real circumstances at the centre.
How we prepared this module
This module links experiments on getting back in touch, tone and support with surveys about relationships and how people like to communicate. The opening and examples are made up to explain the choices. The written exercise helps you apply these ideas to one personal conversation.
Sources
- Amit Kumar and Nicholas Epley. (2021). It’s Surprisingly Nice to Hear You: Misunderstanding the Impact of Communication Media Can Lead to Suboptimal Choices of How to Connect With Others. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 150(3), 595–607. Online-first manuscript, September 10, 2020; Experiment 1, Materials and Method and Results, manuscript pp.4–5.
- Justin Kruger, Nicholas Epley, Jason Parker and Zhi-Wen Ng. (2005). Egocentrism Over E-Mail: Can We Communicate as Well as We Think?. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 89(6), 925–936. Published article; Study 2, Method and Results, p.928.
- Susan Holtzman, Kostadin Kushlev, Alisha Wozny and Rebecca Godard. (2021). Long-distance texting: Text messaging is linked with higher relationship satisfaction in long-distance relationships. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 38(12), 3543–3565. Published article; Procedure and participants, pp.3547–3548; Aim 3 Results, pp.3551–3553.
- Philippa L. Howard and Felicity Sedgewick. (2021). ‘Anything but the phone!’: Communication mode preferences in the autism community. Autism, 25(8), 2265–2278. Published article; Method; Results: Family, Friends, Not the phone, Written communication.
- Susan Holtzman, Drew DeClerck, Kara Turcotte, Diana Lisi and Michael Woodworth. (2017). Emotional support during times of stress: Can text messaging compete with in-person interactions?. Computers in Human Behavior, 71, 130–139. Published article; Experiment 2, §§3.1–3.3 and §3.5.3, p.135; General discussion §4.1.
