Your child wants to try something online. You can see something worthwhile in it, but you’re unsure what could happen or how much help they would need.
Saying yes may feel like choosing learning over safety. Saying no may feel like choosing safety over learning. Yet those two answers leave another question open: what guidance, or narrower permission, would fit this particular activity?
You don’t have to settle your whole approach to technology before you answer. Start with what your child wants to do and what the decision would mean for them.
This module is for parents choosing everyday online activities with children aged 6–17. Exploitation, abuse and situations that need specialist care are outside this exercise.
What you’ll get from this module
In this module
By the end of this module, you’ll have a clearer way to choose guidance and limits for one online activity. European surveys of parents and children show why chances to learn online, the skills children report, upsetting encounters and distress need separate attention. We’ll use those differences to explain practical choices, find a situation in your daily life and write down one decision about an activity.
Ask Jing
Become a Jingius.
What the research tells us about guidance and limits
A survey of parents: why the choice can look like a trade-off.
Livingstone and colleagues’ 2017 study looked at answers from 6,400 parents of children aged 6–14 in eight European countries. The survey took place in 2015. Parents described their children’s skills, activities and the online encounters they knew about.
The researchers grouped several things under enabling mediation: talking, safety advice, technical controls, monitoring and support the child asked for. So enabling mediation meant a mix of practices, not just talking with a child.
The analysis linked high enabling and low restriction with more chances online and more encounters with risk. It linked low enabling and high restriction with fewer of both. This pattern helps explain the apparent trade-off: fewer limits went with more chances, but also more encounters with risk.
But the researchers collected answers at one point in time. They didn’t watch children gaining skills after their parents changed approach. One analysis instead asked how the skills children were said to have related to their parents’ approaches.
Why it matters: A more capable child may be given different permission or guidance. So the pattern can’t tell you how much your child’s skills would change if you relaxed a limit.
Read the study of opportunities, risks and parental mediation.
A survey of children: an encounter and its effects are different questions.
Livingstone and colleagues’ 2011 report presents the 2010 EU Kids Online survey of internet users aged 9–16 in 25 European countries. Children answered questions about their experiences online and whether those experiences bothered them.
The report kept apart seeing sexual images from feeling uncomfortable or upset after seeing them. It also looked at how upset affected children felt and how long that feeling lasted.
Younger children reported seeing these images less than older teenagers did. But among those who had seen them, younger children more often said they were bothered. The groups differed in age and experience; this pattern doesn’t show that seeing such images taught older children to cope.
These differences change what a report of a problem online means. Knowing that an encounter happened doesn’t tell you how serious its effects were or how long they lasted. And a child saying they weren’t upset doesn’t show there were no other effects.
Why it matters: The findings describe how children said they felt at that time. They help separate the questions you need to ask; they don’t tell you how likely harm is for your child today.
Read the report on European children’s online risks and safety.
A study of the same survey: guidance need not mean more risk.
Duerager and Livingstone’s 2012 report looked at what parents did in that same 2010 survey. Active mediation of use included talking, staying nearby, encouraging children to explore and doing activities together.
This involvement went with more online activities and skills, and with fewer encounters with risk. Among children aged 9–12, active mediation also went with fewer reports of being bothered. That link wasn’t found among those aged 13–16.
The researchers compared what parents already did with what children reported. They didn’t test whether adding more talking caused these results. Their idea of active mediation was also narrower than the mix called enabling mediation in the 2017 study.
Why it matters: This finding challenges the idea that more skills must always come with more encounters with risk. In these reports, more skills and fewer encounters went together. You can take guidance seriously while still judging the risks of the activity and how much support your child needs.
Read the report on how parents can support internet safety.
An Irish survey of parents and children: guidance and limits can work together.
Sciacca and colleagues’ 2022 study looked at 461 pairs of a parent and a child surveyed in Ireland during the 2020 lockdown. Children were aged 10–17 and rated their own digital skills. Parents described what they did compared with before lockdown.
Active mediation included talking, doing things together and helping with problems online. Restrictive mediation included rules and limits.
Where parents set many limits, more active guidance went with children rating their digital skills higher. The link between guidance and the skills children rated themselves on changed with how many limits there were, but only a little.
This was a survey at one point in time. It didn’t show that children gained skills because their parents combined the two approaches.
The finding still makes the choice less rigid. Setting limits and explaining online activities fit together. A limit can say what is allowed while guidance helps the child understand the activity that is allowed.
Why it matters: The lockdown setting and the measures used matter when you apply this result. It offers evidence against treating guidance and limits as opposing sides, without naming a perfect mix for every family.
Read the Irish study of parental mediation and digital skills.
What this means for you
Choose permission and guidance together for one activity. The studies give you reasons to look past a parenting label. Parents can mix approaches, and the skills a child reports don’t answer every question about an activity.
Start with the opportunity you want to preserve
Describe what your child wants to do and what would make it worthwhile. Learning something, making something or joining in gives you a real benefit to weigh.
Then work out what taking part would involve. A plain yes or no may hide a narrower option that keeps the benefit while avoiding the part that worries you.
Say your child wants to use an online learning activity that also has a discussion area. In this made-up example, learning from the material is the benefit, while joining the discussion is a separate choice.
You could allow the material first, with guidance, and leave the discussion for later. That choice only makes sense if the narrower activity really keeps the benefit and fits your concerns. If the benefit is still unclear, waiting is a fair decision.
Separate what could happen from why it would matter
Name something your child could come across, then explain what worries you about its possible effects. Include how serious it could be, whether your child could get out of the situation and whether help would be there.
This keeps the event apart from its effect. An unpleasant encounter, strong distress and distress that lasts are different concerns, even when they start from the same event.
Include less likely but serious results in your judgement. An average from the past can’t settle whether a particular possible result is acceptable for your child.
If distress that is ongoing or severe is already there, stop and think again. Exploitation, abuse and situations that need specialist care need expert help beyond this exercise.
Look at readiness and the help you can actually provide
Ask your child to explain an ordinary task in the activity. Using harmless practice material, ask them to show when they would stop and how they would ask for help.
Never set up harmful encounters to test whether they’re ready or to toughen them up. An ordinary explanation or demonstration shows what your child understands about this task. It doesn’t prove they can handle every problem.
Notice what’s still unclear. If your child can’t explain when they would need to stop, work out what guidance or information is missing before you change what’s allowed.
Judge how available you are, too. If the activity needs support you can’t give, think about a narrower activity or waiting. The help that’s really there is part of deciding what works now.
For a younger child, choose a small set of activities and join in the practice. As your child grows, involve them more in explaining the benefit, the concern and the reasons for a limit.
Age helps frame the conversation, but the real task, how your child responds and the support available should guide the choice. A birthday on its own doesn’t answer those questions.
Choose what to allow and explain why
Think about guided use when your child’s understanding and the help available are enough to deal with the concern. When a narrower activity keeps the benefit you want, set that limit and explain what is still allowed.
If the possible harm is more than your child and the support available can handle, wait or say no. Keep talking about it whichever choice you make.
If an important answer is missing, work out what you need to find out before you give that permission.
A limit then has a reason you can come back to. If that reason changes, look again at the task and the help available. Being allowed to do something doesn’t prove a child is ready.
After a problem, ask separately what happened, how your child felt, how long it lasted and what else followed. Use those answers to think again about the activity, the guidance or the limit.
How about your daily life?
Is your child asking to try something new online? Is a limit you already have still tied to a clear concern? Has the help available to your child changed?
You might look at a learning activity, a creative task or a request for more independence. Choose an ordinary activity within this module’s scope.
Write down situations where you would like a clearer decision. One suitable idea is enough.
| A situation in my daily life | What I would like to clarify |
|---|---|
| ____________________ | ____________________ |
| ____________________ | ____________________ |
Which would be most useful to explore now?
My chosen situation: ____________________
You can change your choice. Carry this situation into the exercise below.
Plan one activity decision
Start with your chosen situation. If you came straight here, choose one everyday online activity your child aged 6–17 wants to try or carry on with.
Keep exploitation, abuse and situations that need specialist care outside this exercise. Stop and think again if distress that is ongoing or severe is there.
Never set up harmful encounters as practice. Use harmless material for an ordinary task, a decision to stop and asking for help.
- Name the activity and benefit. Write what your child wants to do and why it’s worthwhile. If the benefit is unclear, write down what needs making clear, or put the choice off.
Activity and benefit: ____________________ - Describe the concern. Keep a likely encounter apart from its possible effects. Describe how serious the effects could be and how long they might last. Include less likely but serious results, whether your child could get out of it and whether help would be there.
Encounter, possible consequences and help: ____________________ - Check readiness and support. Ask your child to explain or show an ordinary task, when to stop and how to ask for help. Use harmless material only. Write down what’s unclear and what help you can really give.
What is understood, missing or available: ____________________ - Choose permission and guidance. Think about guided use if your child’s understanding and the help available are enough to deal with the concern. Choose a narrower activity if it keeps the benefit. Wait or say no if the possible harm is more than the child and the support available can handle.
If an important answer is missing, write down what you need to find out before you give that permission. Explain the reason for your choice and keep talking about it.
Decision, reason and guidance: ____________________ - Name a reason to review. Come back to the decision when readiness, concerns or support change. After a problem, keep apart what happened, how your child felt, how long it lasted and anything else that followed. Use those answers to think again about the arrangement.
Review trigger and next action: ____________________
Ask Jing
Become a Jingius.
Your next step
You have finished when you can explain the activity’s benefit, your concern, the permission and guidance you chose, and what would make you look at them again. A question still open, or waiting, can be the useful result.
A note on the evidence
The surveys define what parents do in different ways and ask about different results. The two EU Kids Online reports use the same survey answers; they are not two separate surveys backing each other up. Their findings help tell choices apart without predicting how one child will fare.
How we prepared this module
We used research on how parents guide children online, the digital skills children report and children’s experiences online to build an exercise for deciding about one activity. The made-up learning example shows a choice between wider and narrower use.
Sources
- Livingstone, Sonia; Kjartan Ólafsson; Ellen J. Helsper; Francisco Lupiáñez-Villanueva; Giuseppe A. Veltri; Frans Folkvord. (2017). Maximizing Opportunities and Minimizing Risks for Children Online: The Role of Digital Skills in Emerging Strategies of Parental Mediation. Journal of Communication, 67(1), 82–105. Accepted author manuscript; Methods pp.5–6, RQ1–RQ3, Tables 4 and 6.
- Livingstone, Sonia; Leslie Haddon; Anke Görzig; Kjartan Ólafsson, with members of the EU Kids Online network. (13 January 2011). Risks and safety on the internet: The perspective of European children. Full findings and policy implications from the EU Kids Online survey of 9–16 year olds and their parents in 25 countries. London: LSE, EU Kids Online. Final report; p.6 and pp.57–58, Figures 37–39.
- Duerager, Andrea; Sonia Livingstone. (February 2012). How can parents support children’s internet safety? London: LSE, EU Kids Online. Original report; pp.1,3–5.
- Sciacca, Beatrice; Derek A. Laffan; James O’Higgins Norman; Tijana Milosevic. (February 2022). Parental mediation in pandemic: Predictors and relationship with children’s digital skills and time spent online in Ireland. Computers in Human Behavior, 127, 107081. Published article; §§2.1–2.4,3.4,4.1,4.5, Table 6 and Figure 1.
