Imagine you get the same optional notification every morning. You usually open it, though you no longer know whether it helps. Today, you wonder whether to keep that routine.
That is a useful decision to look at. The aim is to understand what you want, and whether you can act on it. Keeping the notification could be a deliberate choice too.
A default is what happens when you make no new choice. Reviewing one means looking at the arrangement, your reason for keeping it, and any other option that would work.
This module is for working adults reviewing everyday defaults that matter to them, that they can change, and whose changes they can undo.
What you’ll get from this module
In this module
By the end of this module, you’ll be able to separate what you want from what you can actually change. You’ll look at a review of feeling in control, studies of signing up for plans, and health trials that offered people support. Then you’ll apply these ideas to daily life and review one default. You’ll finish with a reason to keep it, change it or find out what is missing.
Ask Jing
Become a Jingius.
What makes a choice yours?
Research review: feeling in control and having control.
James W. Moore’s 2016 review describes the sense of agency: the feeling that you control your actions and what they lead to. Sometimes that feeling sits in the background as you act. At other times, you stop and judge whether you or someone else caused a result. The review separates those two experiences.
The review explains that this feeling can be wrong. Feeling that you caused a result doesn’t, on its own, show what you could actually change.
This difference matters when you review an arrangement. You might like the idea of choosing and still have no other option that works. An option that is there may also feel unwelcome if someone pressures you to pick it.
Why it matters: For an everyday decision, keep two questions apart: is this what you want, and can you carry it out? You need an answer to each.
Read the review of the sense of agency.
Workplace natural experiment: making enrollment an explicit decision.
Gabriel D. Carroll and colleagues studied sign-ups to a retirement plan at a US financial-services company. Their 2008 manuscript compared two groups of new employees. Earlier hires got paper forms asking whether they wanted to join. Later hires could phone to join whenever they wished.
After three months, 69% of the group asked to decide had joined, compared with 41% of the group offered phone sign-up. These figures covered employees who stayed with the company. The groups were hired in different years, not assigned at random.
The way of signing up and other parts of the plan changed together. That makes it hard to separate the effect of asking for a decision from the other changes.
Still, the comparison shows why the moment a decision is asked for deserves attention. Asking someone to state a choice is a different situation from leaving sign-up open for later.
Why it matters: The result here was signing up. It tells us about behavior in that workplace, not how freely each person felt they had chosen.
Read the manuscript on defaults and active decisions.
Website field comparison: choosing automation can still involve pressure.
Punam Anand Keller and colleagues’ 2011 paper looked at sign-ups for automatic prescription refills on a CVS Caremark website. One format let users opt in. Another made them choose before they could move on, and asked again on every visit.
Sign-up was 21.9% when users had to choose, compared with 12.3% when they could simply opt in. The researchers called the first format enhanced active choice, because it favored the service. The study’s method didn’t say that users were put into the formats at random.
Over the three months watched, 15.2% of those who signed up through enhanced choice dropped out again. Among those who opted in, 10.2% dropped out. These dropout figures describe people who signed up, a different group from everyone who was offered it.
The study brings two ideas together. A deliberate choice can pick an automatic service. But making people choose, especially when the wording favors signing up, doesn’t show that they felt freer to decide for themselves.
Why it matters: More people signing up and more people freely choosing what they want are different results. That is why a personal review needs room to keep, change or put off a decision.
Read the paper on enhanced active choice.
Randomized clinical trial: choice accompanied by practical support.
Geoffrey C. Williams and colleagues’ 2006 trial involved adult smokers in Rochester. People were assigned at random to ordinary community care or an intensive support package. The package included counseling, help to feel able to quit, and access to medicine.
At the six-month check, 11.8% of the intensive-support group had not smoked in the past seven days, compared with 4.1% of those in community care. A test confirmed what people said. The analysis included everyone assigned to either group. The result describes the past week, not six months without smoking.
At one month, people getting intensive support felt their providers gave them more support to make their own choices. This is called autonomy support. But the same analysis didn’t find a statistically significant rise in their own personal reasons for quitting. Feeling supported to choose and personally wanting to quit were measured separately.
The package improved the seven-day smoking result. Because practical help and respect for choice came together, the trial couldn’t show that autonomy support alone caused the improvement.
Why it matters: This gives a useful difference for everyday decisions: wanting another option and having the support to carry it out are separate parts of the situation. A question about what you prefer can’t supply help that is missing.
Read the clinical trial of autonomy and competence support.
Cluster randomized trial: added support must change the actual experience.
Joan L. Duda and colleagues’ 2014 study looked at programmes for people referred for help with exercise. It recruited 347 people across 13 UK leisure centres. The centres were assigned at random to the usual service or to an approach meant to give people more support to choose for themselves.
At six months, the researchers found no statistically significant difference in the physical activity people reported. Ratings at the end of the programme also showed no significant difference in how much people felt their advisors supported their choices.
Problems with training meant the planned support may not have been fully given. The study also recruited fewer people than planned, which made differences harder to detect. Ratings of advisors’ support were already near the top of the scale, leaving little room to show a gain. These limits matter when you read the result.
The trial didn’t show an added benefit for physical activity, or for how supported people felt in choosing. Giving a programme a new approach doesn’t guarantee that people get different help. The useful questions are: did the person get different support, and did the result that matters change?
Why it matters: Together, these studies suggest a grounded way to look at a choice. Ask what someone can change, what they want, what help they have, and what actually happens.
Read the exercise-referral trial.
What this means for you
Review a default because what it leads to matters to you. The useful result may be a change, a reason to keep it, or a clear account of what stands in the way.
Find the decision inside the routine
Write down what happens if you do nothing, and what usually sets it off. Then name the result you want. Comparing these answers makes the decision concrete.
In the made-up notification example, the routine is opening an optional message each morning. The result you want might be getting information you still find useful. If the message does that job, keeping it can make sense.
If it no longer does that job, find another option before you assume a change is possible. Rejecting every automatic arrangement would miss the value of keeping one that fits your needs.
Check who can actually change it
List the other options you could carry out, who controls the arrangement, and any costs or limits. Wanting something different isn’t enough: you also need access and permission to make the change.
For the made-up notification, imagine you can change the setting yourself and change it back. That makes a small trial possible. If an organization controls it, the next step may be asking the person in charge about your options.
Don’t count an option you can’t use as a failure of willpower. Write down what stands in the way and who can help. Put the decision off if you need information or permission.
Never use this exercise to casually change routines that keep people safe, treatment plans, money commitments you are bound to, or decisions that need other people’s consent. Start only with an arrangement you have the right to change and can undo.
Give keeping and deferring a real place
A clear decision should let you keep a useful arrangement. The refill study shows people actively choosing automation, while also showing why pressure and sign-up rates deserve separate attention.
Ask whether the current default does what you want, and whether the other option is worth its costs. Keep it when it fits. Change it when another option you can use fits better. Put it off when an important fact or permission is missing.
Write your reason in everyday words. When you come back to the decision, you can see whether your reason still fits your life. A setting you haven’t changed needn’t mean you have ignored it.
Put a feasible choice where the routine happens
If you want to try another option, use a simple reminder at the moment the routine usually starts. Get the other option, and any help you need, ready first. The reminder should point to a decision you can carry out.
Choose a short, convenient period for the trial and a time to look back at it. Stop if the extra effort outweighs what it gives you. You don’t need to turn every routine into another task.
Check the result without combining different answers
Write down what you decided and what happened. Could you make the change? Was it what you wanted? What effort did it add? Keep those answers apart.
For example, you might manage to change the made-up notification, but find the new arrangement awkward. You have learned that the change was possible, and that you prefer the old arrangement.
Or you might prefer a change that is still not available. A stronger feeling of choice wouldn’t remove that practical limit. Finding the right person to ask, or the permission you lack, may be the useful result.
Keep a helpful default, fix a mismatch, or stop a trial that isn’t helping. Look at the arrangement again when its purpose or effects change, and pick a light review schedule that fits your life.
How about your daily life?
Where does something carry on because you haven’t made a new decision? Think about an optional notification, a habit of checking some information, or a personal routine whose arrangement you control.
Which one still does what you want? Which one deserves a closer look? List situations you would like to understand. One good idea is enough.
| A default in my daily life | What I want it to help me do |
|---|---|
| ____________________ | ____________________ |
| ____________________ | ____________________ |
My chosen situation: ____________________
Choose an everyday arrangement that matters to you, and that you can change and undo. Carry it into the exercise below. You can change your choice if who is in charge, or what it affects, is unclear.
Review one everyday default
Start with your chosen situation. If you came straight here, choose one everyday default that matters to you, that you have the right to change, and whose changes you can undo.
Never use this exercise to casually change routines that keep people safe, treatment plans, money commitments you are bound to, or decisions that need other people’s consent. If who is in charge or what it affects is unclear, write down the question and get the right information or help before you act.
- Describe what happens automatically. Write down what usually sets it off, and what happens if you make no new choice.
Trigger and default: ____________________ - Check your real options. List the other options you have, who can change the arrangement, and any costs, limits or help needed. Test a change only when it is safe, allowed and can be undone.
Options, authority and constraints: ____________________ - State your purpose and decision. What result do you want? Does the current default give it? Choose keep, change or put off, and explain why. If something important is unknown, name the information or help you need.
Purpose, decision and reason: ____________________ - Try the choice where appropriate. For a change you can make, get the other option ready, with a simple reminder at the moment the routine starts. Choose a short, convenient trial and a time to look back. Keeping the default is also a fair decision.
Action or unresolved question; review time: ____________________ - Review separate observations. What happened? Did the change work? Was it what you wanted? What effort did it add? Stop the exercise if it costs more than it gives.
Action, workable option, preference and effort: ____________________ - Keep, revise or finish. Keep a useful arrangement, fix a mismatch, or write down what still stands in the way and a next step you can take. Pick a light review schedule, and look again sooner when the purpose or effects change.
Result, next step and reason to review: ____________________
Ask Jing
Become a Jingius.
Your next step
You have finished when you have a reasoned decision, and either a result you saw or a clear open question. Keeping something useful can be the result.
A note on the evidence
The sign-up studies measured behavior in particular places, while the health studies looked at particular support packages and results. The exercise trial also shows why the way something is carried out matters. These results don’t show that practising one choice makes you more in charge across unrelated parts of life.
Use these ideas to understand the arrangement in front of you. Keep what you could change, what you wanted, and what happened apart.
How we prepared this module
This module brings together a research review, comparisons of sign-ups at a workplace and on a website, and two health trials. A made-up notification example shows the decisions. The written exercise helps you look at one default and write down what is still open.
Sources
- James W. Moore. (29 August 2016). What Is the Sense of Agency and Why Does it Matter?. Frontiers in Psychology, 7:1272. DOI. Published narrative review. “What is the sense of agency?”, “Background” and “Measures”, pp.1–3.
- Gabriel D. Carroll, James J. Choi, David Laibson, Brigitte C. Madrian, Andrew Metrick. (1 November 2009). Optimal Defaults and Active Decisions. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 124(4), 1639–1674. DOI. Harvard DASH manuscript dated 11 November 2008, attached to 2009 publication record; not the typeset published article. Manuscript sections 1–3.1, PDF7–11; Table II, PDF37.
- Punam Anand Keller, Bari Harlam, George Loewenstein, Kevin G. Volpp. (Online 22 July 2011; October 2011 issue). Enhanced active choice: A new method to motivate behavior change. Journal of Consumer Psychology, 21(4), 376–383. DOI. Published article with author-copy cover. Study 4 Method and Results, p.381.
- Geoffrey C. Williams, Holly A. McGregor, Daryl Sharp, Chantal Levesque, Ruth W. Kouides, Richard M. Ryan, Edward L. Deci. (January 2006). Testing a Self-Determination Theory Intervention for Motivating Tobacco Cessation: Supporting Autonomy and Competence in a Clinical Trial. Health Psychology, 25(1), 91–101. DOI. Published article. Method and intention-to-treat results, pp.92–96; Table 3, p.97.
- Joan L. Duda, Geoffrey C. Williams, Nikos Ntoumanis, Amanda Daley, Frank F. Eves, Nanette Mutrie, Peter C. Rouse, Rekha Lodhia, Ruth V. Blamey, Kate Jolly. (29 January 2014). Effects of a standard provision versus an autonomy supportive exercise referral programme on physical activity, quality of life and well-being indicators: a cluster randomised controlled trial. International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity, 11:10. DOI. Published article with repository cover. Methods, pp.4–6; Table 2, p.9; Discussion and limitations, pp.13–14 (PDF pp.5–7, 10, 14–15).
