Concept

You can choose what to read while keeping a way open for information that matters.

Issue

A rule to ignore something can take away optional reading, but it can also shut out a correction or a duty.

Solutions

Understand what your rule would leave out, then build a reversible ignore rule.

Say you open yet another promotional email digest about tools outside your current job. You don’t need it for anything you’re doing, but deleting it feels like admitting you might miss something.

You could stop reading that digest without deciding that what it says is false. You could also keep a way for a colleague to send you a particular item when it becomes relevant.

You’re answering three different questions. Is this information useful to you now? Can you trust where it comes from? Do you have a duty to read it or reply? A useful rule keeps your reasons clear.

This module is for working adults dealing with optional information that keeps arriving. Keep your duties, trustworthy corrections and information about harm to other people outside any rule that ignores a whole category.

What you’ll get from this module

In this module

By the end of this module, you’ll know how to choose what to skip while keeping important information within reach. We’ll look at research on checking sources, on choosing whether to watch something and on avoiding information about what happens to other people, alongside a way of thinking about ignoring with care. You’ll then choose a situation from daily life and write a rule with clear exceptions and reasons to think again.

What makes ignoring a considered choice?

Conceptual synthesis: different problems need different responses.

Anastasia Kozyreva and colleagues’ 2023 paper describes three ways to choose what deserves your attention. You can change what information you come across, check unfamiliar sources somewhere else, or stop engaging with people who are trying to provoke you. The authors call this wider approach critical ignoring.

They call the second way lateral reading. You leave an unfamiliar page to find out who made it and what other sources say about them. Staying on the page isn’t your only way to judge it.

Each way deals with a different problem. Skipping a video changes what you watch. Checking a publisher helps you judge whether to trust it. Ending an exchange changes who you keep engaging with. One choice doesn’t settle the other questions.

Why it matters: The paper offers a way of thinking about these choices. It also explains that spotting warning signs takes knowledge and effort. Calling something untrustworthy or irrelevant isn’t enough; you need a reason you can explain.

Read the framework for critical ignoring.

Research synthesis: source evaluation can be taught.

Marvin Fendt and colleagues’ 2025 review pulled together 64 controlled studies with 17,120 people taking part. They included children, teenagers and adults, taught in schools, universities and online.

On average, teaching helped people judge whether a source was credible, meaning whether it deserved their trust, compared with groups who weren’t taught. Fourteen studies were about lateral reading, and taken together they also favoured teaching. How much it helped varied a lot from study to study.

This gives you a skill to learn: checking a source, instead of relying entirely on how convincing its page looks. The studies measured how well people judged sources. Their good results support learning how to make that judgement.

Why it matters: The review included experiments that put people into groups by chance and studies that didn’t. It combined different learners, ways of teaching and tasks. A good result on average doesn’t mean every short reminder works equally well.

Read the synthesis of source-credibility instruction.

Online experiments: using a technique and reaching the right answer differ.

Folco Panizza and colleagues tested fact-checking tips in two online experiments in the UK, published in 2022. People judged posts about science. Some, picked by chance, saw a pop-up with tips on checking a source somewhere else and looking past the first search results.

In the first experiment, the pop-up made people say they used the techniques more, but it didn’t clearly improve how accurate they were overall. What people said they did was partly checked against whether they left the study page.

The second experiment used sources people didn’t know. In the main analysis, the tips improved scores that gave more credit for correct answers given with confidence. That gain fell just short of the usual statistical standard when another analysis allowed for differences between posts. The tips didn’t clearly improve the simpler measure of whether an answer was right.

Why it matters: The lesson is to keep doing a check apart from what the check shows. Opening another page or running a search is an action. What you learn from it is what can support your judgement. The experiments show why those two things need looking at separately.

Read the experiments on fact-checking tips.

What does skipping or checking really settle?

Randomized online experiment: a choice to skip before starting.

David J. Grüning and colleagues’ 2023 research included an online experiment with 500 people. They put people by chance into one of five groups while showing them popular videos.

The groups tested a message, a short wait, an option to skip before a video played, all three together, or nothing added. Everyone could skip a video once it was playing. The added option let people say no before it started. People given the extra skip option, on its own or with the other features, skipped more videos than the group with nothing added. The group that only got a message didn’t clearly skip more.

The added choice let people decide whether to start watching at all. That’s what the result helps explain: a chance to say no before you begin. Whether a video is useful or trustworthy is a separate question.

Why it matters: The experiment was a short online task with videos. Applying its idea to reading that keeps arriving means deciding what you want to skip, and what must still reach you.

Read the study of consumption choices.

Experimental research synthesis: ignorance can affect other people.

Linh Vu and colleagues’ 2023 review looked at choices that affect someone else. In tasks run in labs and online, people made choices that decided rewards for themselves and for another person. They were either given information about what their choice meant for the other person, or could choose whether to see it.

When people could choose, 40% avoided easy-to-get information about what their choice meant for the other person. The researchers looked at choices where gaining for yourself came at someone else’s expense. People made choices that favoured the other person 15.6 percentage points less often when the information could stay hidden than when they were given it.

Why it matters: These were decisions inside experiments. They show why choosing not to know matters when someone else could pay the price. Skipping an optional promotional digest and shutting out information about harm are different decisions.

Read the synthesis of willful-ignorance experiments.

Skip it, but keep a way in

What this means for you

Start with one optional source, or kind of information, that keeps reaching you. Name what you want to skip, why, and what would make you think again. Then you can judge the rule by what happens when you use it.

Separate relevance from truth

Ask what this information helps you do now. If an optional digest does nothing for you right now, you can turn it down for that reason. You don’t have to declare the publisher unreliable.

Go back to the made-up digest about tools outside your job. Its subject is the reason to skip it. If your job changes, the same subject may become relevant, even though nothing about the publisher has changed.

Judging whether to trust something needs different support. For an unfamiliar source, find out who makes it and what trustworthy outside sources say about them. Then look at the evidence for the particular claim that matters to you.

A respected source can still make a mistake. If you don’t know enough to judge a specialist claim, mark the answer as unknown and find someone qualified to judge it, before you make a lasting judgement about the source.

Keep those judgements apart. Information can be irrelevant to what you’re doing now and still be true. A claim you do need might be backed by evidence, or still unsettled. If you don’t know, keep checking or get help.

Make declining an actual option

Choose an action you can undo: skip an item, unsubscribe from a digest, or put optional reading aside for now. Say when that choice applies.

For the made-up digest, you might unsubscribe while its subject stays outside your job. A colleague’s clear, relevant request would sit outside that rule. You’re naming a category, not turning down everything that arrives through a similar route.

The video experiment shows what an added chance to skip can change: how many videos people skip. The research on checking sources is about a different decision: what deserves trust. Your reason for skipping a digest doesn’t have to be a judgement that it’s false.

Protect disagreement and responsibility

Write down what your rule must let through: replies you’re required to give, trustworthy corrections and information about relevant harm. Decide how those things can still reach you.

In the made-up example, a colleague could send you a particular item and explain why it matters to you. That gives the exception a way to work. “I’ll hear about anything important somehow” doesn’t say how.

Before you accept your rule, ask whether you’d apply it to an equally trustworthy source that agreed with you. Ask who might pay the price if you stayed uninformed. Then name the evidence that would make you change the rule.

If the rule mostly helps you avoid disagreement or a duty, keep a way for the relevant evidence to reach you. Narrow what you skip, so you can cut optional reading without shutting out that evidence.

Decline provocation without discarding a correction

For an exchange that keeps happening, describe behaviour you can actually see: repeated insults, provoking you again and again, or refusing to deal with the evidence. That gives your decision a clear basis beyond simply disagreeing.

You can stop taking part in that exchange while keeping another way to receive a correction that deals with the claim. Threats, replies you’re required to give and reports of harm stay exceptions to any rule that ignores a whole category.

You’re deciding whether to keep taking part in the exchange. That doesn’t make every claim made there false. Keep the person’s behaviour apart from the evidence, so you can stop the exchange without throwing away a useful correction.

Give the rule a way to change

Choose a date to review the rule, and write down reasons to reopen it sooner. These might include a change in your duties, a trustworthy challenge or a useful item you missed.

As you try the rule, note what you skip, the unwanted reading that’s left and how much effort it takes. Also note useful information you miss and anything that happens because of it. Use what you notice to decide whether to keep the rule, narrow it or drop it. If an important result is unclear, look into it before you decide.

If your job changes, you might start reading the made-up digest again. If you miss a useful item, you might narrow what you leave out, or change how relevant items reach you. Feeling sure about the rule doesn’t tell you whether either change is needed; what you notice does.

What would you like to stop paying attention to?

How about your daily life?

Where does optional information keep arriving with no clear purpose for you right now? Think of promotional digests, videos you keep watching, or exchanges that repeat the same provocation.

Which situation could you change while keeping your duties and your access to corrections in place? One good idea is enough. Add others if they help you choose.

A situation in my daily lifeWhat I would like to change
________________________________________
________________________________________

My chosen situation: ____________________

Take this situation into the exercise below. Choosing it doesn’t yet mean a rule to ignore it is right. You can change your choice as you check the exceptions.

Build a reversible ignore rule

Start with your chosen situation. If you came straight here, choose one optional source, or category of information that keeps arriving, that you can name clearly.

Keep your duties, trustworthy corrections and information about harm to others outside any rule that ignores a whole category. If those things can’t still reach you, choose a narrower category and keep access to the relevant evidence.

  1. Name the category and purpose. Write down what you would turn down, and why it isn’t useful for what you’re doing now. Keep “not relevant” apart from a judgement that something is false.
    Category and present purpose: ____________________
  2. Check any credibility judgment. Check an unfamiliar producer using trustworthy outside sources, then think about the evidence for the claim that matters. Write down what you checked and what’s still unknown. Find someone qualified to judge it if you don’t know enough to make a lasting judgement about the source.
    Checked reason, evidence and unknowns: ____________________
  3. Set the boundary and action. Choose an action you can undo, such as skipping, unsubscribing or putting optional reading aside. Say when the rule applies. For an exchange, go by behaviour you can see, not just disagreement.
    Action and conditions: ____________________
  4. Protect what must get through. List your duties, replies you’re required to give, trustworthy corrections, threats and relevant information about harm as exceptions. Name a way that works for relevant disagreement to reach you.
    Would you use the same test for an equally trustworthy source that agreed with you? Who could pay the price if you stayed uninformed? What evidence would change your mind?
    If the rule mostly excuses you from a duty or helps you avoid disagreement, keep access to the relevant evidence. Narrow what you leave out before you try the rule.
    Exceptions, route and reversal evidence: ____________________
  5. Choose when to review. Write a date that fits your situation. Reopen the rule sooner if your duties change, trustworthy evidence challenges it or you miss relevant information.
    Review date and earlier triggers: ____________________
  6. Observe and decide. Note what you skip, the unwanted reading that’s left and how much effort it takes. Include useful information you miss and anything that happens because of it. Use what you notice to keep the rule, narrow it or drop it. Look into any important result that’s unclear, instead of assuming the rule worked.
    Observations and review decision: ____________________

Ask Jing

Become a Jingius.

Write a rule you can undo

Loading interactive tool…

Your next step

Your plan is ready when it says what you’ll skip, why, what must still reach you, how it will reach you and when you’ll think again. If a check you need is still unsettled, write down that gap and the next information or help you need.

A note on the evidence

The studies measured different things: judgements about sources and science posts, watching videos, and choices that affect others. The results of teaching varied. The experiments with tips also show why doing a check and getting to an accurate answer need looking at separately.

The findings about harm come from tasks in labs and online where people shared out rewards. They’re here to explain why what happens to other people belongs among your exceptions, not to estimate how often working adults avoid their duties.

How we prepared this module

This module brings together a way of thinking about ignoring, reviews of research and online experiments to explain different reasons for choosing information. A made-up example about a promotional digest shows how a boundary and its exceptions can work together. The written exercise helps you plan a rule and name what’s still unsettled.

Sources