You settle down with a book, then check how many pages you need to finish tonight. Maybe the target helps you start. Maybe you’re picking the quickest pages instead of the ones you want to read.
Those two lead to different choices. A record might help you start reading, yet pull your mind away from the story. To judge whether it helps, first ask what you want from reading.
This module is for working adults choosing optional tracking, rewards or streaks for free-time activities they enjoy or want to start. Medical monitoring you’ve been told to do, and assessments at work or in education, are outside this exercise.
What you’ll get from this module
In this module
By the end of this module, you’ll have a clearer way to choose whether to keep, limit or drop optional tracking. Experiments, research on rewards and a survey of cyclists show why taking part and enjoying it need separate judgements. You’ll link what they found to your own free time, pick one situation and write a practical decision about what counting adds.
Ask Jing
Become a Jingius.
What changes when an activity gets a score?
A reading experiment: optional feedback can affect enjoyment.
Jordan Etkin’s research, published in 2016, asked what happens when people can see how much they’ve done. In one experiment, 66 paid university students read book extracts for eight minutes. A random draw decided whether they could reveal a page count or had none.
Students who could see the count said they enjoyed it less: 4.68 against 5.37 on a scale from one to seven. Fewer also chose to keep reading, though that choice was noted, not acted on.
So making the counter optional didn’t stop it having an effect in this task. The result helps explain why choosing to measure something and enjoying it are separate questions. You can want the information and still find that having it changes the experience.
Why it matters: This was a short reading session the students were given. It doesn’t tell us how one reader’s long-running hobby will change over the years.
Read the study of personal quantification.
Contrasting research reviews: the reward arrangement matters.
A page count is different from a promised prize. Edward L. Deci, Richard Koestner and Richard M. Ryan’s 1999 review pooled 128 studies of outside rewards and motivation. They compared people who got rewards with people who didn’t. They looked separately at what people chose to do once the rewards stopped, and at how interested people said they were.
For interesting tasks, promised money or other solid rewards came at a cost. Rewards for taking part, finishing or doing well made people less likely to go back to the activity freely once the rewards stopped.
Praise and positive feedback, though, raised later free choice and reported interest on average. The benefits varied with age, and with whether the feedback helped people see how they were doing or put them under pressure.
Judy Cameron, Katherine M. Banko and W. David Pierce’s 2001 analysis challenged the idea that rewards do harm across the board. It still found harm in some cases where people expected solid rewards for interesting tasks. But it came to different conclusions about rewards tied to how well someone did.
The reviews draw on many of the same studies but group and analyse them differently. Their disagreement leaves no simple rule that every reward harms enjoyment, or that rewarding good work always suits.
Why it matters: What matters is what the reward asks of you. Feedback on progress, a promised prize for taking part and a visible count are different things to add to an activity. The reviews covered many kinds of lab tasks, with children and college students among others. They were not one test of adult hobbies.
Read the review of external rewards and motivation. Read the contrasting reward analysis.
A game experiment: the record can become a separate goal.
Jackie Silverman and Alixandra Barasch’s research, published in the 2023 journal issue, looked at how logged streaks affect choices. One experiment changed which games counted towards a streak, while keeping the games people had already played the same.
A broad rule counted both kinds of game. A narrow rule counted only the kind picked at the start. So playing a different kind kept one record going but broke the other.
Of 805 adults who signed up, 452 reached that comparison and were analysed. People whose log was unbroken were more likely to choose to keep playing than those whose log was broken. They had played the same games. What changed was whether the log counted them as an unbroken streak.
Why it matters: That matters, because a broken record doesn’t have to mean you stopped the wider activity. The way a log counts what you do can sway whether you choose to carry on. This experiment measured a choice made on the spot, not lasting enjoyment of a hobby.
Read the study of intact and broken streaks.
Two field experiments: incentives can help people get started.
Sometimes the hard part is starting. Gary Charness and Uri Gneezy’s 2009 gym experiments tested paying university students to go to campus gyms they could already use.
In the first study, one group was paid for a first visit, then offered more money for eight more visits over four weeks. Other groups were paid for a single visit or got nothing.
The group offered money for repeat visits went 0.60 times a week on average before the payments and 1.24 times after. The group that got nothing went 0.59 times before and 0.56 after. Researchers kept tracking visits for seven weeks after the payments stopped.
Across the two experiments, the lasting gains were mostly among people who hadn’t gone regularly before. So help getting started can be useful: people may keep going after the payment ends.
Why it matters: Going to the gym more often doesn’t tell us whether someone enjoys exercise more. Applying these findings to free time also takes judgement. Being paid, having a campus gym and exercising for health are different from choosing a reminder to read.
Read the gym attendance experiments.
A survey of cyclists: tracking and enjoyment can coexist.
Stephen Flora and Kristopher Brown’s 2021 survey looked at people already keen on cycling for fun. They surveyed 16 cyclists at a cycling camp or holiday in Mallorca, and 18 members of a triathlon club in north-east Ohio.
Most used bike computers, and both groups said they enjoyed cycling a lot. They also described ways that measuring helped them. These cyclists could enjoy riding while using numbers to track it.
Why it matters: This small survey only included people still cycling, and relied on what they said. It can’t show that tracking caused their enjoyment, or speak for people who had already given up cycling or tracking. But it does show why telling everyone to drop tracking would miss something some cyclists value.
Read the survey of recreational cyclists.
What this means for you
Name what you want from the activity before you decide what to count. Pleasure, curiosity or company can already be reason enough to do it. If a count adds nothing useful, you can say no to it.
Start with the experience you want
If starting is the problem, a reminder, a record or a promise to yourself may be worth taking on. As the gym research shows, help to take part can be worth having on its own. Keep a second question open: are you also enjoying it?
Say you pick a shorter book only because it’s easier to finish before a target resets. If you read to explore stories, that choice may work against what you wanted. If you just want to make time for reading, a record of what you finish may still help.
A page count can’t tell you which reason matters more. Ask what it helps you do, and what it pulls you away from. Then decide whether that trade suits you.
Be clear about what you’re adding
Write down what you’re adding: a private record, a visible count, feedback on a skill, a promised prize or a streak. Research on one of these doesn’t tell you what another will do.
Take special care before promising yourself a solid reward just for doing something you already enjoy. A reward for doing something well needs thought too. The reviews disagree about those set-ups, so the label alone can’t tell you whether it will help.
If feedback helps you practise a skill you care about, keep that reason in mind when you judge it. If you enjoy looking at the numbers, that enjoyment counts too. You don’t need to drop useful information just because someone else prefers an activity with no counting.
Let yourself return after a break
The game study shows how the rule that defines a streak can change what the record says about the very same activity. Ask whether your rule counts the kind of taking part you value.
Don’t make an unbroken record the price of coming back. If you want a streak, let yourself pick it up again after a missed day. If a variation you enjoy doesn’t count towards the streak, you can still choose it.
Picking only what counts, avoiding a variation you’d like, or dreading a missed day gives you something to think about. Those feelings don’t show what caused a change in your enjoyment. Tiredness, other demands or interest that was already fading may matter too.
Decide what is worth keeping
Keep optional tracking when the help or enjoyment it gives you is worth what it asks of you. Limit it or drop it when what it asks outweighs what you get.
If you’re not sure, try an ordinary session with the optional count hidden or switched off. Keep the activity as close to normal as you can. Afterwards, think about how much you enjoyed it, whether you want to go back and what you chose to do.
You may enjoy it more, do less or notice no change. Other things can affect the comparison, so use it to guide a choice without treating it as proof of cause. Removing a count also doesn’t promise that earlier enjoyment will come back.
Pick a time to think about it again that fits your life. The aim is to help you choose, without turning enjoyment into one more score to keep up.
How about your daily life?
Where do you notice a count in your free time? Think about reading targets, records of a hobby or an activity you’d like help starting.
Which information do you enjoy using? Which rule makes you avoid something you’d otherwise choose? Write down one or more situations worth exploring.
| A situation in my leisure | What I want to understand |
|---|---|
| ____________________ | ____________________ |
| ____________________ | ____________________ |
My chosen situation: ____________________
Take that situation into the exercise. You can change your choice; picking it doesn’t mean the tracking has to go.
Make one leisure decision
Begin with the situation you picked. If you started here, choose an activity you enjoy or want to start. Pick one optional way of tracking it, rewarding yourself or keeping a streak.
This exercise leaves out medical monitoring you’ve been told to do, and assessments at work or in education. Don’t use it to stop those.
- Name your purpose. Write what you want from the activity: enjoyment, curiosity, company, getting started or a practice goal you’ve chosen.
My activity and purpose: ____________________ - Identify the addition. Describe the private record, visible count, skill feedback, promised reward or streak. Say what it asks you to do, and what useful information or support it gives.
What I’m adding, what it asks and how it helps: ____________________ - Compare its value with the experience. Think about whether it serves your purpose, and whether what it asks crowds out choices you value. Take care with promised solid rewards just for taking part in something you already enjoy.
What helps, what costs and what remains unclear: ____________________ - Choose to keep, limit or decline it. Keep it when what you get is worth what it asks of you. Limit or drop an optional count, reward or streak when what it asks outweighs its value. If you want a streak, let yourself start again after a miss.
My decision and reason: ____________________ - Note what you’re still unsure about. If you’re not sure, compare an ordinary session that’s otherwise the same, with the optional count hidden or switched off. Think about it afterwards without making another score you have to keep. Differences may come from tiredness, company or other things; they don’t prove cause or promise that enjoyment will come back.
What I want to notice, or what I still need to understand: ____________________
A suitable point to reconsider: ____________________
Ask Jing
Become a Jingius.
Your next step
Finish with one decision and its reason, or a clear open question and a comparison you want to try. The record should help you choose how to spend your free time — including choosing to come back after a break.
A note on the evidence
The research separates reported enjoyment, choices made on the spot and later taking part. Short tasks set by researchers give controlled comparisons; the cycling survey describes keen riders chosen for it. The reward reviews disagree about some set-ups. Use these differences when you judge what a result means for your own activity.
How we prepared this module
This module connects reviews of rewards, experiments on measuring and streaks, gym field experiments and a survey of cyclists. A made-up reading choice shows how a target can fit one purpose and clash with another. The written exercise brings those differences into one optional free-time decision.
Sources
- Edward L. Deci; Richard Koestner; Richard M. Ryan. (1999). A Meta-Analytic Review of Experiments Examining the Effects of Extrinsic Rewards on Intrinsic Motivation. Psychological Bulletin, 125(6), 627–668. Published scan; methods pp.634–635, reward results pp.638–644, feedback delivery p.652.
- Judy Cameron; Katherine M. Banko; W. David Pierce. (Spring 2001). Pervasive Negative Effects of Rewards on Intrinsic Motivation: The Myth Continues. The Behavior Analyst, 24, 1–44. Published article; methods pp.9–11, contrasting reward results pp.17–18, summary pp.21–23.
- Jordan Etkin. (19 April 2016). The Hidden Cost of Personal Quantification. Journal of Consumer Research, 42(6), 967–984. Author manuscript; Experiment 6, pp.34–35.
- Jackie Silverman; Alixandra Barasch. (Advance Access 30 June 2022; issue 2023). On or Off Track: How (Broken) Streaks Affect Consumer Decisions. Journal of Consumer Research, 49(6), 1095–1117. Published Advance Access version; Study 5, pp.13–14.
- Gary Charness; Uri Gneezy. (May 2009). Incentives to Exercise. Econometrica, 77(3), 909–931. Published article; design p.913, results pp.916–920.
- Stephen Flora; Kristopher Brown. (13 March 2021). Hidden in Plain Sight: The Psychological Benefits of Personal Quantification. International Journal of Psychology & Behavior Analysis, 7, article 174. Published article; methods/results pp.2–3, limitations p.5.
