Concept

Spend your checking effort on claims that could change a decision or what you pass on.

Issue

A claim you’re unsure of can pull you into a long rebuttal before you know whether settling it would help anyone.

Solutions

Understand where your effort could matter, then choose your next response.

Say you open a group message and find a claim you doubt. You start writing a reply, then open another tab to look for evidence. Before long, you’re digging into something you hadn’t planned to use or share.

The question isn’t only whether the claim is true. It’s also what settling it would change. Someone may be about to rely on it, or you may just feel pulled into an argument.

You can save your attention for claims that matter while keeping useful corrections to hand. Leaving something unendorsed means you haven’t accepted it as fact. It doesn’t mean you have to call it false.

This module is for everyday adults deciding whether to act on or pass on a factual claim they’re unsure of. It doesn’t replace a work duty to look into or correct something.

What you’ll get from this module

In this module

By the end of this module, you’ll have a clearer way to choose which claims deserve attention and what to do when an important claim stays unsettled. We’ll link research on corrections and on reminders to think about accuracy with accounts from fact-checkers of how they choose and finish checks. You’ll pick a situation from daily life and finish with a response to follow up, put off or leave open.

What makes checking worth the effort?

An interview study: checking can mean waiting for an expert.

Victoria Moreno-Gil, Xavier Ramon-Vegas and Marcel Mauri-Ríos (2022) interviewed the people in charge at four fact-checking organisations in Spain, France, Portugal and Italy. They looked at how those organisations worked and the problems they faced.

Les Surligneurs said checks were usually published within 48 hours at most. Another person interviewed said complex checks sometimes took as long as a week while they waited for experts or colleagues.

Why it matters: Those times include waiting for answers. They don’t tell us how many hours people spent actually checking. Sometimes, finishing a check depends on hearing from someone with the right expertise. You can put in effort and still have a question with no answer.

Read the interview study of professional fact-checking.

An account from a newsroom: choose claims and reuse earlier work.

When checks take time, choosing which claims to look into matters too. In an April 2025 account, Nasim Asl explains that Full Fact doesn’t have the staff to write about every wrong claim it sees. The team weighs how prominent a claim is and how far it reaches, whether it keeps coming back, and the harm it could do.

Asl also describes how earlier checking can make some repeated corrections easier. The same question doesn’t always mean starting from scratch. Earlier work can still be useful when the claim comes back.

Why it matters: This is Full Fact’s own account of how it works. It shows how a team chooses claims and reuses earlier checks; it doesn’t measure how much time you would save. The team can’t cover everything, but it can still offer useful corrections. Having to choose which claims to check doesn’t make those corrections pointless.

Read the newsroom account of choosing what to check.

A review of many studies: a correction can help without undoing every effect.

Man-pui Sally Chan and colleagues (2017) combined results from studies of messages that corrected false information. This kind of combined analysis is called a meta-analysis. The studies included 6,878 people across many kinds of tasks. Corrections helped, even though the original false information could still sway people.

There are two questions here. Did people do better after a correction than after seeing the false information with no correction? And did the false information still sway them compared with people who never saw it? A correction can help people move away from a false claim without taking them all the way back to where they would have been without it.

Briony Swire-Thompson, Joseph DeGutis and David Lazer (2020) reviewed research on corrections that backfire by making people believe false information more. They concluded that corrections usually work and that backfiring is not the rule.

Why it matters: Their practical advice is to link the false claim clearly to its correction, while not repeating it more than needed. Together, these accounts support keeping correction to hand as a useful response, without expecting every trace of a false claim to vanish.

Read the correction meta-analysis. Read the review of correction backfire.

Online experiments: can a correction make a false claim more believable?

Ullrich K. H. Ecker, Stephan Lewandowsky and Matthew Chadwick (2020) tested corrections of unfamiliar claims, styled like social media posts, with US adults recruited online. They compared belief and reasoning after different kinds of exposure, including corrections and no exposure at all.

In the first experiment, people who saw only a correction reasoned slightly more in line with the false claim than people who hadn’t seen it. That small effect didn’t come back when the researchers ran the test again with more people, or in a closely related test. Overall, the evidence pointed to no such backfire from making a false claim more familiar through a correction.

Some of the benefit faded after a week. Even then, corrections still helped compared with seeing the claim alone. Losing some benefit over time is different from making a false belief stronger. The experiments measured belief and reasoning, not how far posts spread.

Why it matters: For you, the difference matters when you’re thinking about a useful correction. Mentioning a false claim while clearly correcting it shouldn’t be treated as making people believe it more.

Read the experiments on corrections of unfamiliar claims.

When is checking worth it?

A review of one group’s experiments: a reminder to think about accuracy can change what people plan to share.

Gordon Pennycook and David G. Rand (2022) combined 20 US online experiments their research group ran during 2017–2020. The studies included 26,863 people. People were given either an accuracy prompt—a reminder to think about whether things are true—or a comparison condition with no prompt. They then said whether they would share true and false headlines.

Across the studies, accuracy prompts cut people’s plans to share false headlines by 10% compared with the comparison group. That means a change compared with how much the comparison group planned to share, not a drop of ten percentage points. It wasn’t a measured drop in real shares.

Why it matters: The prompts drew attention to accuracy before people decided what they might share. They didn’t give evidence settling each headline. That difference matters: remembering to think about accuracy can change how you approach sharing, while the claim itself may still need checking.

Read the meta-analysis of accuracy prompts.

Pause before you pass it on

What this means for you

You don’t have to answer every claim for correction to be worthwhile. Start by asking what someone might do with the claim. That helps you decide whether to look for evidence, share a correction that already exists, get help or leave it unendorsed.

Name what settling the claim would change

Ask what you or someone else might do differently if the claim were true or false. Put it first if it could affect an action or a decision, or if you’re about to repeat it as fact.

Say you come across an odd claim about a calendar and a claim that could change an important work decision. If you won’t use or repeat the calendar claim, it can stay unendorsed. The work claim deserves attention because relying on a wrong answer could change what you do.

This choice depends on what the claim would be used for and what could go wrong. A claim doesn’t deserve more attention just because it’s easy to check or annoying. Among several claims, think about how much being wrong would matter and how far your own repeating could carry it.

Your answer can change. If someone later plans to rely on the calendar claim, there’s a new reason to look at it again. Putting off a rebuttal keeps that option open.

Bring accuracy into your own decision to share

Before you pass a claim on as fact, ask whether you have enough support to stand behind it. The research on accuracy prompts makes this a useful question to ask at the moment of sharing. Asking yourself is an everyday use of it; in the experiments, the prompts came from the researchers.

A pause can’t supply missing evidence or expertise. If the claim is still uncertain, don’t turn that doubt into a confident message. You can hold back from endorsing it while you decide whether what it’s for calls for more checking.

Use a relevant correction when it could help

If someone has already checked the claim and their evidence fits your question, use that work rather than assuming you must write a new rebuttal. The important question is whether it deals with the claim someone may rely on. A correction to a different claim doesn’t settle yours.

When a correction with good support exists and someone you know may act on the false claim, think about sharing it clearly with them. Keep the false claim clearly linked to the correction, and don’t repeat it more than needed.

Choose who gets it with that purpose in mind. Don’t spread an obscure rumour just to put on a show of rebutting it. This saves attention for people who may need the correction, without assuming silence is always best.

Keep an important unanswered question visible

Finding a claim hard to check doesn’t make it false. Nor does the time you’ve already spent make it reliable. If an unsettled claim could affect an important decision, hold off relying on it or repeating it where you can. Get the right expertise when the decision needs it.

If you can’t put off a serious decision, this exercise doesn’t give you the go-ahead to act on the unsettled claim. Work out the help or professional process the decision needs. A useful next step may be to say what you still don’t know and find someone who can help.

Leave a claim unendorsed when no important use depends on it

If you can’t see an important decision or action depending on the claim, and you won’t repeat it as fact, you can put off a new rebuttal. That leaves the claim unendorsed: you haven’t accepted it as true or shown it to be false. You’re choosing where to put your checking effort next.

Look at that choice again if what the claim is used for, or what could follow from it, changes. Follow any work duty to look into or correct something; a personal choice about attention doesn’t replace that responsibility.

Does this claim deserve your checking time?

How about your daily life?

Think of a message you might forward, something you might repeat at work, or a claim someone may use for a decision. Which situation would gain from a clearer choice about checking?

Write one or more possibilities. You only need one suitable situation to carry on.

A situation in my daily lifeWhat settling the claim could change
________________________________________
________________________________________

My chosen situation: ____________________

Carry this situation into the exercise. Choosing it names something to look into; it doesn’t yet show that you should act on the claim.

Choose your next response

Start with your chosen situation. If you came straight here, choose a factual claim you’re unsure of that you might act on or pass on. This exercise helps you choose where to put your checking effort. It doesn’t check whether the claim is true for you.

Follow any work duty to look into or correct something. Don’t use an unsettled claim as the basis for a serious action, because this exercise can’t settle it.

  1. Name the claim and intended use. Write the claim briefly and say what action, decision or message to someone else could depend on it.
    Claim and possible use: ____________________
  2. Decide whether it deserves attention now. Think about what would follow if it’s wrong and how far your own repeating would likely carry it. If no important decision, action or message depends on it, leave it unendorsed and put off a new rebuttal.
    Priority or reason to defer: ____________________
  3. Choose the response that fits the available support. For a claim that matters, look for checking already done on the same claim that offers relevant evidence. If a correction with good support could help someone who may rely on the false claim, think about sharing it clearly with them.
    Keep the claim and the correction clearly linked; don’t repeat it more than needed. Don’t spread an obscure rumour just to rebut it.
    Existing verification or useful correction and intended audience: ____________________
  4. State any unresolved gap. If an important claim is still unsettled, hold off relying on it or repeating it where you can. Get the right expertise when the decision needs it. Finding it hard to check doesn’t show it’s false, and a pause alone doesn’t show it’s true.
    What remains unknown and the help or information needed: ____________________
  5. Record one next response and a reason to revisit it. You might follow up a relevant check, share a correction that exists, get help or put off a rebuttal. Open a question you put off again if what it’s used for or what could follow changes.
    My next response: ____________________
    What would make me revisit it: ____________________

Ask Jing

Become a Jingius.

Decide what one claim needs from you

Loading interactive tool…

Your next step

You’ve finished when you can explain why this claim deserves attention now or can stay unendorsed. If it matters and is still unsettled, write down what you still need to know and where you can get help. A finished worksheet isn’t evidence that the claim is true.

A note on the evidence

The fact-checkers’ accounts describe how they say they work and the limits they face. The research on corrections looks at belief and reasoning under the conditions studied, while the result on accuracy prompts is about what people planned to share. That last one combines one research group’s experiments, and the combined analysis wasn’t registered in advance.

These differences matter when you choose a response. A useful correction needn’t wipe out every trace of a false claim, and an important claim that’s still unsettled still needs the right attention.

How we prepared this module

This module brings together interviews with fact-checkers, a newsroom’s account, research on corrections and experiments on accuracy prompts. Made-up everyday comparisons show the choices. The written exercise helps you apply those differences to one claim.

Sources