Say a friend suggests someone from their hobby group. You also have an online profile waiting for a reply. You can decide whether either person interests you. But there’s an earlier question: how did these two people become your options?
In this example, your friend has told you what they had in mind. You’re still not sure how the online suggestion was picked. Either way, finding a possibility, narrowing a list and deciding to meet are different choices.
You can accept help with one part without handing over every part. The useful place to start is understanding what a route gives you, and which decisions you want to keep.
This module is for adults choosing how to look for a romantic partner.
What you’ll get from this module
In this module
By the end of this module, you’ll have a clearer way to compare how you meet possible partners without losing useful chances. US and Swiss surveys of couples show how people met, and which kinds of couples formed through different routes. A critical review of online dating explains why a claim about matching may leave important details unknown. You’ll use these ideas to map your own options, and decide what to keep, change or try next.
Ask Jing
Become a Jingius.
What introduction routes can change
Population survey analysis: where romantic introductions began.
Michael J. Rosenfeld, Reuben J. Thomas and Sonia Hausen’s 2019 study looked at US adults’ accounts of meeting their partners. It combined two surveys, from 2009 and 2017, with different people in each. People recalled how and when they had met their partners.
For heterosexual couples, the estimated share who met online rose from 2% in 1995 to 39% in 2017. Meeting through friends fell from 33% to 20%. To show the overall pattern, the researchers smoothed out the ups and downs from year to year. These estimates use 5,421 accounts of couples, not every adult interviewed in 2017.
The categories overlap: a friend might introduce you to someone online. The survey’s coding guide also lists several kinds of meeting online. So meeting online doesn’t always mean a computer system chose the person.
Why it matters: Knowing where two people met tells you part of their story. It doesn’t tell you who suggested them to each other, or which choices they made themselves. The study records a change in the ways people say they met, not proof that people lost control over their choices.
Read the study of changing US meeting routes. Read the survey’s meeting-story coding guide.
Survey and interview account: access outside an existing circle.
An earlier study by Michael J. Rosenfeld and Reuben J. Thomas, published in 2012, helps explain why meeting online might matter. It used the 2009 US survey, including adults with partners.
Among couples who got together in the previous ten years, 41% of same-sex couples had met online, compared with 17% of heterosexual couples. Those figures compare how the two groups met. They don’t measure how much any one person would gain by changing how they date.
An interview reported alongside the survey makes the question of access easier to see. The researchers described a lesbian woman in the South who had found the gay bar and gay church she knew disappointing. Local online personal ads helped her find another group of possible partners.
Why it matters: This is one person’s account of finding possible partners. It shows what could be lost by giving up a source of introductions: people your usual circle doesn’t help you meet. A familiar local circle isn’t always the more useful route for the relationship someone wants.
Read the study of online introductions and access.
Swiss survey analysis: wider reach has several meanings.
Being able to meet more people doesn’t tell you which new possibilities a route opens up. Gina Potarca’s 2020 study looked at 3,245 adults with partners in the 2018 Swiss Family and Generations Survey. Their relationships had begun within ten years; 104 had met through dating apps.
Compared with couples who met offline, the study found more pairings between a university graduate and someone without a degree among couples who met through apps. Information about the partner’s education was only collected when the partner was over 25. Treat the education finding with care: the paper gives conflicting figures about how certain that result is.
The study didn’t find a clear rise in pairings between Swiss-born people and migrants. It did find longer journeys to visit a partner among couples who met on apps than among those who met offline. That comparison covered people over 20 whose partners lived in another household.
These findings describe people who were already in relationships when they were surveyed. Only a small group had met through apps. People weren’t randomly assigned to different ways of meeting, so the differences don’t show what switching routes would do for you.
Why it matters: The lesson is to ask what kind of difference a route might make. Meeting someone with a different education, a different background or a home farther away are separate possibilities. A word like “diverse” doesn’t tell you which of those a route offers.
Read the Swiss study of couples who met through dating apps.
Critical review: what a matching explanation leaves unknown.
Whom a route helps you meet is one question. How it picks those people is another. Eli J. Finkel and colleagues’ 2012 review looked at online dating through the lens of psychological science.
The matching services it discussed kept the key details of how they picked people private. So researchers didn’t have the information they needed to check those methods for themselves. A service might say it matched people by personality without explaining which traits counted most.
This finding is about the services reviewed in 2012, not every service today. It shows why hearing a reason for a match may still leave important questions open.
Why it matters: Knowing that a shared interest counted doesn’t tell you how much it mattered next to other qualities. Keep that gap in mind when you decide how much choosing you want someone else to do.
Read the critical review of online dating.
What this means for you
Compare ways of meeting people by two things: whom they help you reach, and which choices they make for you. Include chances your existing circle may never offer.
Keep access in the comparison
Start with the relationship you want to look for and the routes open to you. Include friends or family, shared activities, online services, searching on your own and mixes of these.
Then ask what each route actually reaches. Does it introduce people beyond your existing circle? Does it keep coming back to the same group? Which people are still hard to find?
Keep a route that gives you useful access, even when some of the ways it picks people are unclear. If your family or local community rejects the relationship you want, put wider access first in the comparison.
That route still can’t promise acceptance, privacy or safety. But reaching people you couldn’t otherwise meet is a reason to value it, alongside any open questions about how it picks them.
Separate what was said from what you inferred
Keep apart what you’ve been told, what you’ve noticed, what you’re guessing and what you don’t know. A likely guess about why someone was suggested is still a guess.
Go back to the made-up friend who suggests people from a hobby group. Say the friend tells you they chose someone because you share that interest. That is a reason they gave. Noticing that their suggestions all come from that group is something you’ve seen.
You might guess that shared interests matter most to them. Unless they say so, that is still your reading. You may still not know whom they thought about and left out.
| Information in the fictional example | What it lets you say | What remains open |
|---|---|---|
| Your friend names a shared hobby | The hobby was a reason they gave for this suggestion. | How much other things mattered. |
| Suggestions come from the same group | That is the pattern you’ve seen. | Whether they thought about other introductions. |
| You think shared interests are their main priority | That is your reading. | Whether it matches your friend’s own thinking. |
If you want suggestions from beyond that group, ask whether your friend can introduce someone from elsewhere. If another open question matters to your choice, ask about it where you can. If no answer is available, leave the gap in view. A friend may not know their own reasons, and a system’s explanation may be incomplete.
You can still choose what help to accept. An open question doesn’t mean you have to invent a motive or give up useful access.
Choose the part you want to delegate
Someone can help you find possible partners, narrow the list or set up an introduction. Those are different kinds of help. Decide which you want to accept, while keeping your own choice about whether you want to meet.
For example, you might welcome suggestions from your friend, while asking to decide for yourself which introductions to follow up. Or you might use an online route to find possibilities beyond the people your friends know.
This matters because getting a suggestion doesn’t settle whether you want to meet. If the possibilities on offer don’t fit, you can ask for a different introduction or use another route that works for you. An explanation, or a reply, may still not be available.
Change a route only for a reason you can name
If your current route gives you useful chances, keeping it can be the right next choice. If it misses people you want to reach, think about adding another workable way to meet them, while keeping what already helps.
Be clear about what the extra route could add. Another route that reaches the same group may only repeat your current options. A route that reaches different people may also bring travel, time or checking that you need to weigh.
After a change, write down what useful introductions happen and what is still missing. You can change how much of the picking you hand over without replacing the whole route. If no workable alternative exists, naming that limit is a useful result.
How about your daily life?
Think about one part of looking for a romantic partner that you’d like to understand better. Are a friend’s suggestions too narrow for what you’re looking for? Does an online route reach people your local circle doesn’t?
You might instead want to understand what shaped a shortlist, or decide whether a second route would add anything different.
Write down situations that matter to you. One good idea is enough.
| A situation in my daily life | What I would like to understand or improve |
|---|---|
| ____________________ | ____________________ |
| ____________________ | ____________________ |
Which situation would be most useful to look at now?
My chosen situation: ____________________
You can change your choice. Carry this situation into the exercise below.
Map your introduction routes
Start with your chosen situation. If you came straight here, choose a question about how you look for a romantic partner. You’ll make a written map of the routes open to you and decide what help you want from them.
- Name the relationship and routes. Include personal introductions, shared settings, online services, searching on your own and mixed routes that apply. A route can involve more than one person or system.
Relationship sought and available routes: ____________________ - Record what you know for each route. Name who supplies the possibilities. Keep apart the reasons given, patterns you’ve seen, priorities you’re guessing at and what is unknown. Don’t fill a gap with a motive you’ve assumed.
Route / stated criteria / observed pattern / inference / unknown: ____________________ - Check access. Note whom each route reaches and whom it misses. Keep useful access beyond a narrow or excluding local circle, even when some of how it picks people is unclear. Wider access doesn’t promise acceptance, privacy or safety.
If you don’t know whether a route adds useful access, write that question down before you treat it as an improvement.
Access gained, missing or still unknown: ____________________ - Choose what to delegate. Decide whether the route should supply possibilities, narrow a list or set up an introduction. Keep the decision about whether you want to meet. Ask for an explanation or a different introduction where you can; an answer, or a reply, may not be available.
Help I want / choice I retain / unanswered question: ____________________ - Choose one useful next move. Keep the route, change what it picks for you or try a workable route that reaches different people. Think about overlap, travel, time and checking. If no change is workable or useful, say why.
Write down useful introductions that happen, and what is still missing after any change.
Keep, adjust or add / reason / what to observe: ____________________
Ask Jing
Become a Jingius.
Your next step
You’ve finished when you can name the access worth keeping, the help you want and your next choice or open question. Your map can include open questions. You don’t have to invent an answer to finish it.
A note on the evidence
The US studies share some survey data; they aren’t separate repeats of each other. They describe how people say they were introduced, while the Swiss study looks at established couples in several ways. The review’s findings about what services disclosed are about services discussed in 2012.
Use those differences to frame your own comparison. How popular a route is, whom it reaches and how it picks people answer different questions.
How we prepared this module
This module brings together research on how couples meet, access, the make-up of couples and what matching services disclose. A made-up example of a friend’s introduction explains the difference between reasons given and assumptions. The written exercise helps you compare routes and choose what to hand over.
Sources
- Michael J. Rosenfeld, Reuben J. Thomas and Sonia Hausen. (2019-08-20 online; 2019-09-03 issue). Disintermediating your friends: How online dating in the United States displaces other ways of meeting. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 116(36), 17753–17758. Final journal article; Table 1, Results, and Data and Methods.
- HCMST investigators. (Version 1.0, 2009-09-25; includes 2017 updates). How the Open Text Question 24 was coded.. Stanford University Libraries. Official coding documentation; pp.1–2 notes and p.4 internet definitions.
- Michael J. Rosenfeld and Reuben J. Thomas. (2012-06-13 online; August 2012 issue). Searching for a Mate: The Rise of the Internet as a Social Intermediary. American Sociological Review, 77(4), 523–547. Published article; Data, Table 5 and notes, and Discussion’s supplemental interview account.
- Gina Potarca. (2020-12-30). The demography of swiping right. An overview of couples who met through dating apps in Switzerland. PLOS ONE, 15(12), e0243733. Final journal article; Materials and methods: Data and Measurements; Results: Assortative mating; Table 3; Discussion; linked S1 File, Tables S3.3 and S6.3.
- Eli J. Finkel, Paul W. Eastwick, Benjamin R. Karney, Harry T. Reis and Susan Sprecher. (2012). Online Dating: A Critical Analysis From the Perspective of Psychological Science. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 13(1), 3–66. Final journal article; pp.25–26, including “The impossibility of independent replication”.
