Say you’re looking through photos on your phone. You find an ordinary picture you’d want your brother or sister to have after your death. Nearby are private conversations you wouldn’t want passed around.
You could leave a note saying what matters to you. But what would your sibling get, what would stay private, and who would do the work? Those are different questions from whether anyone could reach the material.
You don’t have to sort out everything you hold online to make a start. Begin with one piece of material and the person or purpose that gives the decision its meaning.
This module is for adults deciding and sharing their wishes for personal records, where lawful access and the right to act can be shown.
What you’ll get from this module
In this module
By the end of this module, you’ll know what to talk about and check before you ask someone to handle your personal records. You’ll choose one situation and write down your wishes, the role the person has agreed to and anything still open. We’ll draw on interviews with grieving people, a story from history, workshops, a planning study and Google’s own guidance.
Ask Jing
Become a Jingius.
What makes a personal record worth passing on?
Interview study: an ordinary photo can matter.
Lorenz Widmaier’s 2023 study looked at how digital photos are used in mourning and remembering. It included 32 interviews with grieving people and two interviews with experts, held in 2019–2022, mostly in Germany.
People talked about photos and other digital material during the interviews. One woman described a favourite photo of her partner on their terrace. The study calls her Ulrike rather than using her real name. The photo showed how he usually sat there and spent his time.
The photo mattered because it caught a familiar person in everyday life. That makes personal meaning a useful place to start when you think about what to leave someone. Material doesn’t need to record a public success to matter to the person who gets it.
Why it matters: The interviews looked at people’s experiences, mainly how photos helped them remember. The people interviewed weren’t a sample that stands for everyone. Valuing one photo doesn’t tell us that someone wants a whole collection.
Read the interview study on digital photographic legacies.
A story from history: different material can have different futures.
Keeping something is only one possible wish. The Emily Dickinson Museum’s undated accounts describe different decisions about the poet’s letters and poems.
Dickinson asked that, after her death, her sister Lavinia destroy the letters she had received. Lavinia found Emily’s handwritten poems while carrying out that request. The museum also reports that Emily left no instructions for the poems, which Lavinia set out to publish.
The instruction was about letters Dickinson had received, not her poems. Her wishes for those letters didn’t tell Lavinia what to do with the poems. A person’s wishes for one kind of material can’t simply be stretched to cover everything they left behind.
Why it matters: This account is about one writer’s papers; it doesn’t show what ordinary households usually do. It does show why keeping material, protecting privacy and getting rid of material can need separate decisions.
Read the museum account of Dickinson’s letters. Read the museum account of her poem manuscripts.
Early workshops: receiving something and looking after it are different jobs.
Jack Holt, James Nicholson, and Jan David Smeddinck’s 2021 paper looked at imagined plans for personal data after death. Each of the two workshops had seven people. All of them had links to computer science and used password managers.
The discussions raised questions about the work given to a steward: someone trusted to handle the material. Would that person agree to the job? Would they have to keep looking after it, and one day hand that job on to someone else?
These were concerns raised by a group chosen on purpose. The study didn’t measure what happened to grieving families. The discussions help us notice the work a plan asks someone to do. Agreeing to receive a photo and agreeing to look after someone’s accounts for ever are different promises.
Why it matters: A name in a plan says who you have in mind. It doesn’t tell you whether that person accepts the work or what they think the job includes.
Read the workshop paper on sharing, security and privacy after death.
Google’s account guidance: a request has limits and an order.
Even willing people need a way to carry out the plan. Google’s undated account-help page describes requests about the account of someone who has died.
Google says it can work with close family members and representatives to close accounts where that is appropriate. It may provide account content in some cases, after a review, but it doesn’t give out passwords or other login details.
The page also says closing an account stops anyone asking for its contents later. If a request for content is already under way, Google says to wait for it to finish before making any further requests.
Why it matters: This keeps getting certain content apart from taking over an account. It also shows why the order of steps matters when you want material kept and an account closed. These are Google’s own process limits, not rules for everyone or a promise that a request will succeed.
Read the Google guidance on a deceased user’s account.
Planning study: begin with people and purpose.
Dylan Thomas Doyle and Jed R. Brubaker’s 2024 study compared two ways of helping people plan what should happen to their data after death.
A first group struggled when asked to start by listing everything they had. A later group got more hands-on help, starting with their relationships and their purpose. They made plans they felt were complete and workable.
The groups differed in age and background, so we can’t tell how much of the difference came from the approach itself. The study looked at making plans, not at whether they would work after death.
Why it matters: The finding is about planning with a lot of guidance. It doesn’t tell us that a short worksheet filled in alone will work as well, or that lists never help.
Read the study on relationship-based data planning.
The useful difference is between naming a purpose and listing everything you own. A person and an aim give the planning a direction: what should this material mean or do for someone?
A list of your records can describe what exists without answering that question. You can begin with one relationship and one decision. You don’t need to list everything you’ve ever saved before you start.
What this means for you
A useful plan says what should happen, who it’s for, who takes on the job and how they could do it. Say clearly when any of these is still not settled.
Choose an outcome for particular material
Start with something that might matter to a person or to a practical task. Ask the person you have in mind whether they want it. You may want material kept, shared with certain people, kept private or deleted.
Go back to the made-up photos and conversations. You might want your sibling to get some chosen photos while private messages stay private. Those wishes are about different material, so one instruction to keep everything would miss the difference.
If nobody wants a certain collection, that is an acceptable answer. You don’t have to keep it just because it exists. Write down what you want to happen, but leave any argument about rights unsettled.
Ask about the job as well as the material
A recipient is the person who would receive something. The person who does the work may be someone else. Ask whoever you have in mind whether they are willing, and explain what you’d want them to do.
For the made-up photos, getting a few chosen ones needn’t mean taking on every account or looking after the collection for ever. Say what the person may decide, what should stay private and where their job ends.
If they say no, leave the role empty or talk with another willing person. Don’t write them down as having agreed. Naming someone also doesn’t give them unlimited access to other people’s messages.
Separate wishes, access and authority
Access means being able to reach the material. Authority is about what someone has the right to do with it. Ownership is another question; being able to open something doesn’t settle who has rights in it.
Check how the service or organisation lets someone carry out what you want. It might mean a formal request or a person already named through its own process. Write down what proof or extra authority that process needs; don’t assume the same rules apply everywhere.
A written wish can’t create a right to access. If access, ownership or authority is unclear, mark that part as not settled. Get the organisation’s own guidance or qualified help when extra authority is needed or there is a dispute to sort out.
Before you ask for an account to be closed, check whether anything you want kept must be saved first. Google’s stated order of steps shows why this question belongs in the plan. Deleting material you control and asking an organisation to delete material are different actions; neither proves that every copy elsewhere is gone.
Communicate the decision and its limits
Put the agreed note where the person you have in mind can find it, and tell them it exists. Include where the material is, what you want to happen, the role they agreed to, how they can reach it and any question still open.
A part-finished note can be a useful place to stop. It might say that the person wants the material but you still need to check how they could get it. Name that missing step so they know what is still not settled.
Look at the note again when the people involved, your wishes or the arrangements change in a way that affects the plan. If the conversation is hard, you can pause. The aim here is one decision you’ve shared, not sorting out a lifetime of records in one sitting.
How about your daily life?
Which personal records bring this question close to home? You might think of family photos, private messages or records someone would need for a practical task.
Would someone want a certain item? Is there material you want kept private or removed? Have you assumed someone would handle it without talking about the job?
Write down possibilities. One useful idea is enough.
| Material or situation | What I would like to clarify |
|---|---|
| ____________________ | ____________________ |
| ____________________ | ____________________ |
My chosen situation: ____________________
Choose one situation to carry into the exercise. You can change your choice; naming material doesn’t give you permission to access it or get rid of it.
Write one clear record of your wishes
Start with your chosen situation. If you came straight here, choose one personal record or small collection and a possible person or purpose. You can pause if the subject feels hard.
Work only where lawful access and the right to act can be shown. This note shares your wishes; it doesn’t create rights or replace extra authority an organisation or a dispute may need. Mark missing access or disputed ownership as not settled and get the right guidance before acting.
- Name the material, person and intended outcome. Write down where it is. Ask the person you have in mind whether they want it. Say whether it should be kept, shared, kept private or deleted, with the limits for each person.
Material/location, recipient and outcome: ____________________
Privacy and disposal limits: ____________________ - Agree who will handle the work. Ask the person whether they accept this exact job. Say what they may decide, what stays private and where their part ends. If they say no, write down that the role is empty rather than assuming they agreed.
Willing person, agreed role and limits: ____________________ - Check the route and required authority. Find the process that lets the person reach the material or carry out your wishes, and write down the proof it needs. Write down missing access, unclear ownership or disputed authority. A wish alone isn’t enough; get the organisation’s guidance or qualified help where needed.
Check that anything to be kept is saved before an account is closed for good. For Google’s process, wait for a content request already under way to finish before making further requests. Closing that account stops anyone asking for its contents later. Deleting something doesn’t prove that copies elsewhere are gone.
Route, required proof, action order and unresolved questions: ____________________ - Communicate the note. Keep it where the person you have in mind can find it and tell them it exists. Write down when you told them. Look at it again when the people involved, your wishes or the arrangements change in a way that affects the plan.
Note location and date communicated: ____________________
Ask Jing
Become a Jingius.
Your next step
Finish with one decision you’ve shared and its limits, or a part-finished note naming the missing agreement or route. Keep that open part plain to see instead of promising an outcome you can’t be sure of.
A note on the evidence
The sources answer different questions: personal meaning, decisions made in history, the jobs people expect, planning and companies’ own processes. They don’t show whether most families want a large collection. The planning finding is about work done with a lot of guidance. Google’s example describes a process whose terms can change.
How we prepared this module
This module brings together interviews, workshop research, a story from history, a planning study and a company’s own guidance. A made-up example of photos and messages explains the choices. The exercise helps you share one decision and name what still needs sorting out.
Sources
- Lorenz Widmaier. (27 February 2023). Digital photographic legacies, mourning, and remembrance: looking through the eyes of the deceased. photographies, 16(1), 19–48. Published article, republished with minor changes stated not to affect academic content. Printed pp21–24: Methods and research sample; Transferability and limitations; Snapshots — remembering everyday life.
- Emily Dickinson Museum. (Undated). Emily Dickinson’s Letters. Institutional historical account. Paragraph describing Lavinia destroying received letters.
- Emily Dickinson Museum. (Undated). The Posthumous Discovery of Dickinson’s Poems. Institutional historical account. Opening paragraph and Lavinia publication account.
- Jack Holt, James Nicholson, and Jan David Smeddinck. (April 2021). From Personal Data to Digital Legacy: Exploring Conflicts in the Sharing, Security and Privacy of Post-mortem Data. The Web Conference 2021 (WWW ’21), ACM, 2745–2756. Author preprint. Sections 3.1–3.2 and 4.8, PDF pp3–4 and p9.
- Google. (Undated live policy). Submit a request regarding a deceased user’s account. Google Account Help. Make a request for a deceased person’s account; Account Closure Requests. Accessed 12 November 2026.
- Dylan Thomas Doyle and Jed R. Brubaker. (May 2024). “I Am So Overwhelmed I Don’t Know Where to Begin!” Towards Developing Relationship-Based and Values-Based End-of-Life Data Planning Approaches. CHI ’24, ACM, Article 219, 14 pages. Published article. Sections 4–8: methods, planning outcomes, facilitation and comparison limits.
