Concept

Information can do different jobs for you: you can know it, you can find it again, or it can remind you to act.

Issue

Saving an explanation gives you something to look up, but you may still need to learn how to explain the idea yourself.

Solutions

Think about how you’ll use the information later, then choose what to learn, store or cue.

Say you save a useful explanation for work. Later, you need to explain the idea without opening the note. You know where the explanation is, but you’re not sure how to put it in your own words.

The note still does a job. It gives you somewhere to look. But your next task asks for something else: knowledge you can use without looking it up. And if you need to send the note tomorrow, that’s a third need. You have to remember to act.

This module is for working adults deciding how to handle information they may need again, when nothing about it is an emergency.

What you’ll get from this module

In this module

By the end of this module, you’ll have a clearer way to choose what to learn, what to keep as a reference and what needs a reminder. We’ll look at experiments on saving information, on learning when the answer is close at hand and on remembering to do things later. We’ll also look at important limits in the original research on the “Google effect.” Then you’ll use those findings to think through an everyday situation, make a choice and check it. Or you’ll find the question you still need to answer.

What changes when information is available elsewhere?

Experiments and repeat studies: the Google effect is really several different questions.

In 2011, Betsy Sparrow, Jenny Liu and Daniel M. Wegner published a paper with four experiments. In Experiment 2, people typed trivia statements into a computer. Some expected the computer to save them. Others expected it to erase them. The people who expected the statements to be erased remembered more of them afterward. So the finding was about what people remembered soon afterward when they thought the information would stay available. The task didn’t involve searching the live internet.

Another experiment compared two things: remembering the statements and remembering the folders they were saved in. People remembered the folder names better. But they got prompts to help them recall the folders, and no such help for the statements. There were also fewer folder names to remember. Those unequal tasks matter. This comparison can’t show that people generally remember where information is better than the information itself.

Later attempts to repeat the research tested a different question. The Social Sciences Replication Project, reported by Colin F. Camerer and colleagues in 2018, retested a result from Experiment 1. Guido Hesselmann’s 2020 study also focused on that experiment. Neither got the same result as the original. Their task measured how quickly people named the colors of computer-related words after answering trivia questions. Hesselmann used a changed version of the task, in German. Neither project directly repeated the saved-fact experiment or the folder experiment.

Why it matters: The useful difference is between expecting information to stay available and actually learning it. The original findings raise that difference. Later experiments help us look more directly at what it costs and what it gives you.

Read the original Google-effects experiments. Read the replication project’s supplementary account. Read the modified color-naming replication study.

Tablet experiments: getting a task done and learning from it are different goals.

Sandra Grinschgl, Frank Papenmeier and Hauke S. Meyerhoff studied this trade-off in three experiments published in 2021. They wrote down their plans before they collected any data. Each experiment looked at results from 172 people who copied arrangements of objects on tablets. After some other tasks, the people took memory tests.

In the first experiment, one group could look at the arrangement they were copying straight away. Another group had to wait before they could look. Looking straight away led to faster copying, but people remembered less of the objects later. The speed comparison didn’t count the time people were made to wait. So being able to check the arrangement at once helped people finish faster, but they remembered less of what they had copied.

Later experiments looked at what happened when people knew a memory test was coming. Knowing about the test didn’t remove every memory cost. In one version of the task, people had to rely on the arrangement on screen as much as they could. There, knowing about the test nearly removed the memory cost. Trying to learn mattered, but how much it helped depended on how the task worked.

Why it matters: This difference matters when you want to use what you learned later without looking it up. A finished task tells you what you got done with the reference open. On its own, it doesn’t tell you what you can do once the reference is gone.

Read the experiments on performance and later memory.

Does having it to hand mean you know it?

Online list-learning experiment: saving can also help you remember other things.

A 2023 study by Pei-Chun Tsai and colleagues looked at a possible benefit of saving. Its first experiment looked at results from 102 adults who studied two lists of words online. The researchers changed which list was saved and which list was tested first. People could study a saved list again before they were tested on it.

Saving the first list helped people remember the second list, compared with saving neither list, when the second list was tested first. When the first list was tested first, that benefit was not statistically significant. So the order of the tests changed the result.

Why it matters: In these particular conditions, saving helped people remember other things. That benefit belongs next to the memory costs found in other tasks. The practical question is what you need the information to do for you.

Read the study of saving and test order.

Controlled learning experiment: try the problem before you read the explanation.

A 2021 paper by Saskia Giebl and colleagues studied 240 UCLA undergraduates learning programming ideas. One group tried a problem for four minutes, then studied information about it for six minutes. The other group could study the information for ten minutes without trying first. The search was simulated, so people got set material instead of searching the web freely.

After ten minutes on another task, both groups took a multiple-choice test. Its questions asked them to use the programming ideas on new problems. The group that tried first did better. On average, they answered 56% of the questions correctly, against 50% for the group that looked things up straight away. This was a learning result after a short delay, in one subject.

Why it matters: Both groups got the information. The difference was whether they tried the problem first. That makes the finding useful when looking something up is part of learning, rather than just getting an answer you need right now. The first try and the information after it work together.

Read the experiment on attempting before looking up.

Learn from the help page, not only with it

Online experiments and a daily-life follow-up: remembering to act is a separate task.

Sam J. Gilbert’s 2015 paper looked at remembering to do something later. It used online tasks with circles on a screen. People had to remember to make particular moves later in the task. In two experiments, groups who were allowed to set reminders outside their heads made those moves more accurately than groups who weren’t. The tasks differed in how hard they were, and the size of the benefit differed too.

The study also included a separate follow-up in daily life. People could go back to a unique web link after 2, 5 and 7 days to claim $0.25 bonuses. About half of the people whose results were analyzed claimed none, even though they had said they meant to claim all three. That doesn’t tell us that all of them forgot. Lost links, connection problems, low motivation and other things to do could also explain why people didn’t go back.

Why it matters: The screen experiments show that reminders can help when you need to do something later. The follow-up shows why an unfinished action needs a closer look. Meaning to act is different from having the chance and the information to do it. Knowing where information is stored and having a cue to use it meet different needs.

Read the research on external reminders and delayed intentions.

What this means for you

Start with how you’ll use the information later. You may need to understand an idea, find an exact detail or do something later. One situation can involve all three.

Learn the part you need to use without looking it up

Ask what you’ll need to explain, think through or do when the reference isn’t open. Spend time learning that part, and keep the reference too. This fits what the tablet experiments found: getting a task done with help is different from remembering it later.

Say you’re learning the difference between revenue and profit. The ideas belong in what you learn, because you want to think with them. The monthly figures change, so they can stay in records you look up. You don’t have to make the same choice for an idea and every detail that comes with it.

When a problem is low-stakes and you want to learn it, try an answer before you look at the correct information. Then compare your try with the source and fix what you missed. Your try gives you something concrete to compare: what you could explain on your own, and what you needed to correct it. If you can’t find out the correct answer, leave the question open. Don’t treat your guess as something you’ve learned.

When the goal is to use the material on your own, check whether you can do that without the reference. If you still need it for an important part, that shows you what to work on. Keep the source close so you can correct yourself. If you need the reference urgently, look it up straight away. Don’t hold up the task to practice.

Store details with a route back to them

A detail you need rarely, need exactly or expect to change can be a good thing to keep in a record. The useful question is whether you can find it when you need it. The saving study is a reason to keep the benefits of storing in view. Its test-order result is a warning not to assume that saving always helps you learn.

Say you need an order number now and then. Keeping it with its receipt gives the detail a place you can find. For this to work, you need to be able to reach that record when you need the number.

Learning the relevant part may still be worth it, for several reasons. You might need to use it smoothly, find looking it up again and again distracting, or expect the reference to be out of reach. If any of these fits, learn that part and keep a backup you can reach. For example, you might learn the order of an everyday presentation while carrying detailed notes. Choose what to learn from how you expect to use it, rather than trying to memorize every detail that goes with it.

Add a cue when the need is an action

A receipt stored in a folder tells you where the receipt is. It doesn’t tell you how you’ll remember to send it later. For something you need to do later, set up a cue you expect to come across when you’re able to act. Include what to do and where to find the information you’ll need.

In the receipt example, a reminder to send it can say where the receipt is. The record holds the detail. The reminder brings the action back to your attention. You can keep both without trying to memorize the receipt itself.

If the action still doesn’t happen, look at what got in the way. Did you see the cue? Could you get to the record? Was the action possible then? The daily-life follow-up is a reason to check these first, before you assume the problem was forgetting. A missing link or a clash with something else calls for a different fix than a reminder you didn’t notice.

What do you need this information to do?

How about your daily life?

Where do you keep looking up something you want to understand? Which exact details do you only need now and then? Is there a saved document you need to act on later?

You could think about an idea from work, a presentation, a receipt or another situation that isn’t an emergency. Write down the ones that matter to you. One good idea is enough.

A situation in my daily lifeWhat I need the information for
________________________________________
________________________________________

My chosen situation: ____________________

Choose one situation to take into the exercise below. You can change your choice as it becomes clearer how you’ll use the information.

Choose what to learn, store or cue

Start with the situation you chose. If you came straight here, choose some information you may need again for everyday work or life, where nothing is an emergency. If you need a reference urgently, look it up straight away. Save the try-first practice for low-stakes learning.

  1. Describe the future use. Write what you’ll need to understand, find or do. Split up the parts that have different purposes.
    My future use: ____________________
  2. Choose what needs learning and what can stay in a record. Learn the part you need to think with, use smoothly or use without looking it up. Keep a reference too. Store details you need rarely, need exactly or expect to change, with a clear route back to them. If the record might be out of reach when you need it, learn the relevant part and keep a backup you can reach. If you don’t know how the information will be used, write that question down before you decide.
    Part to learn, detail to store and reason: ____________________
  3. Check the choice in the way that fits it. For low-stakes learning, try the problem, look at the correct information and fix your answer. When using it on your own matters, check what you can do without the reference, then use the source to fill the gaps. For stored details, check that you can find the record by the route you chose. If the answer or the access is still uncertain, write down what you still need to sort out.
    What I checked and what remains unresolved: ____________________
  4. Add a future-action cue if needed. Write the action, the information it needs and a cue you expect to come across when you can act. If the action doesn’t happen later, look at access, other things competing for your time and the cue itself, rather than assuming you forgot. If nothing needs doing later, leave this part out.
    Action, cue and information location: ____________________

Ask Jing

Become a Jingius.

Give each part of the information its job

Loading interactive tool…

Your next step

Finish with a choice for each part of your situation that matters, and one next step or open question. You now have a reason to learn some information, keep other details where you can reach them and make a future action easy to see.

A note on the evidence

These studies tested different things: remembering facts, finishing a task, learning from an answer and remembering to act. What helped and what it cost depended on the task and how it was tested. Use the differences explained above to decide which finding fits your situation.

How we prepared this module

This module brings together experimental research on storing information, learning and reminders, along with the limits found when the research was repeated. Made-up everyday examples show how learning, keeping a reference and setting a cue can serve different parts of one situation. The written exercise helps you make those choices and check them.

Sources