You reach yet another request to share information. You want to get on with what you came to do, but you don’t feel comfortable with the choice.
Perhaps you accept because the service matters to you. Perhaps you doubt that saying no would change anything. Those reasons can lead to the same click while coming from different judgements.
Digital resignation means caring about control while feeling you have little of it. Seeing that difference gives you a better place to start than judging yourself by whether you clicked accept.
This module is for working adults weighing one privacy choice, where you can name the information involved, the options you have and what it costs you.
What you’ll get from this module
In this module
By the end of this module, you’ll have a clearer way to judge whether a privacy choice is worth your effort. We’ll link a survey from some years ago, tests of tools that block tracking and services that remove your details, and a study of writing on a social network. You’ll learn what their different results mean, choose a situation from daily life, and write a comparison of the result, the evidence and the cost. You may end with an action, a choice to accept on purpose or a clear note of what you don’t know.
Ask Jing
Become a Jingius.
What can a privacy choice actually change?
A survey report: wanting control while feeling unable to get it.
Joseph Turow, Michael Hennessy and Nora Draper’s 2015 report looked at a phone survey of 1,506 adult internet users in mainland United States. It asked whether people wanted control over what marketers knew about them, and whether they accepted that little control was on offer.
The researchers counted 58% as resigned, because they agreed with both statements. In this survey from some years ago, concern and a sense of powerlessness sat side by side.
Being counted as resigned did not, on its own, clearly link to accepting the report’s supermarket discount examples. So it doesn’t explain every decision to share information. Nor does this older sample show how common resignation is today.
Why it matters: The useful difference is between wanting a result and believing you can get it. Seeing someone share information doesn’t tell you which of those beliefs shaped the decision.
Read the report on privacy trade-offs and resignation.
A technical study: information can be stopped on its way to one destination.
Georg Merzdovnik and colleagues’ 2017 study used automated browsers to visit websites and compare tools that block trackers. In their tests, uBlock blocked every request they saw going to Google Analytics. This covered both HTTP and HTTPS, the two kinds of web connection tested. Requests could still reach other tracking services.
Those requests were stopped, even though other routes stayed open. That difference matters: a tool can change one part of what happens to your information without solving every privacy concern.
Why it matters: The finding applies to the setup tested at the time; it doesn’t show how a product works today. It gives a real example of what a limited success can look like.
Read the technical study of tracker-blocking tools.
A website audit: stating a preference and having it respected are different.
Zengrui Liu, Umar Iqbal and Nitesh Saxena’s 2024 study used automated browsers set up with different interests to test the consent pop-ups on real websites. They browsed from Germany and California, testing sites that used four consent systems.
After the test browsers opted out, services still swapped tracking identifiers: codes used to recognise a browser. Bids for showing ads also suggested that data was still being used or shared. That conclusion came from the bids, which other things outside the researchers’ control could affect.
Results differed between systems and places. On those sites, stating a preference didn’t always bring the result it was meant to. That doesn’t mean every opt-out fails.
Why it matters: Together, the two studies show why the result matters. One showed requests being stopped; the other showed why picking an option doesn’t, on its own, tell you what happened next.
Read the audit of tracking after opt-out.
A study with users: a removal status needs careful reading.
Jiahui He and colleagues’ 2025 study followed four services that remove your details over 30 days, with usable data from 71 U.S. adults, most of them students. It looked at services that try to get records that identify people taken down.
Across users, on average 48.2% of the records the services found were reported as removed or not found. Some records had been matched to the wrong person. The researchers did not check for themselves whether people’s records had really been removed.
To understand the percentage, look at what was counted. It was about the records the services found, not all information about a person. And a report that a record was removed is different from a check that it is gone.
Why it matters: So three questions matter: which records the service covers, whether they belong to the right person, and whether the removal has been checked. The study did not show whether removal would last.
Read the study of personal-information removal services.
A study of a social network: what you share isn’t the only information out there.
James P. Bagrow, Xipei Liu and Lewis Mitchell’s 2019 study looked at public Twitter posts by users and the people they were connected to. They estimated how well, in principle, the words a user would write could be predicted.
They found useful clues in their contacts’ writing, even when the user’s own writing was left out. These were limits worked out from a model, not accuracy measured after people deleted their accounts.
Sharing less yourself and stopping others drawing conclusions about you are different results. Information from the people you’re connected to may still help them, even when you change what you share.
Why it matters: This helps explain why a useful choice can leave part of your concern unsolved. Judge what the choice can change, and stay clear about what it leaves open.
Read the analysis of predictive information in social connections.
What this means for you
Begin with the change you want, rather than trying to solve privacy as a whole. A specific result gives you something concrete to compare with the choice on offer.
Separate your concern from your judgment about the choice
You can care about privacy while deciding that one action on offer isn’t worth it. You might also feel that nothing can help before you’ve looked at what a particular action changes.
Describe those thoughts separately. What matters to you about the information? What do you believe the action on offer would do? What would it cost you?
This keeps apart what you care about, what you expect an action to do, and whether you think it’s worth the effort. Feeling resigned and making a sensible trade can overlap.
Name the outcome at the right scale
Stopping information going to one place, removing a record and changing who you deal with are different aims. Name the one that matters in your situation.
Say you’re thinking about a service because you want one listing of your details removed. The result you want is that listing gone. A message saying the service handled a request tells you it took a step. It leaves open whether the listing disappeared.
If your concern is what others can work out by putting together information from several places, removing one listing deals with only part of it. Keep that remaining concern apart from the result the service claims.
This is also how you avoid brushing off a limited success. A result can be worth having on its own scale while leaving another concern unsolved.
Match the evidence to the promised result
Ask what was seen, who reported it and what information it covers. Telling a service what you want, getting a status message and checking the result are different kinds of evidence.
For the made-up listing example, tell apart a reported removal from a check of the named record. Also tell that record apart from information held elsewhere. If the evidence doesn’t show the result you need, leave it as unknown.
A percentage can hide these differences. Before you rely on one, find out what was counted and what was left out. A result about the records a service found can otherwise sound like a result about everything known about you.
Older research can explain these differences without telling you which product to choose today. A specific recommendation needs up-to-date evidence about how the product actually behaves, and your own circumstances.
Compare the specific benefit with your real cost
Once you’ve named the result and its evidence, weigh it against the time, money or hassle it takes. Include information you’d have to give another party and any effort you’d need to repeat.
Use the options you really have. A service you need for work or something essential may leave you less freedom than an optional one. Saying no is only an option where it’s possible.
If you have good reason to expect a result that matters enough to be worth its cost, take the choice on offer. If not, you can accept the trade on purpose or leave the service where you can.
An unknown benefit doesn’t become a known one because you spent effort on it. Write down what’s still unknown and whether that changes your decision. A clear limit is a useful conclusion too.
How about your daily life?
Where have you lately accepted a request for your data without feeling happy about it? Is there a listing you want removed, information you want to stop being sent, or a service you’d like to think again about?
Write down a situation and what you would like to understand. One suitable idea is enough.
| Situation | Outcome I want to understand |
|---|---|
| ____________________ | ____________________ |
| ____________________ | ____________________ |
My chosen situation: ____________________
Choose one privacy trade where you can name the information, the options and what it costs you. You can change your choice. Carry it into the exercise below.
Weigh one privacy trade
Start with your chosen situation. If you came straight here, choose one privacy decision where you can name the information involved, your options and what they cost.
- Name the outcome. Describe where you want information to stop being sent, which record you want removed, or which service you want to change how you deal with. Keep wider concerns apart: information kept elsewhere, conclusions others might draw, or later uses.
Desired outcome and remaining concern: ____________________ - State what the evidence establishes. Have you stated a preference, had a report, or checked the result? Say what information your evidence covers and what is still unknown. Use up-to-date evidence for a decision about a specific product.
Evidence, coverage and unknowns: ____________________ - Describe the available choice and its cost. Include time, money, hassle, information you must give and any effort you’d need to repeat. Think about whether leaving or choosing another provider is really possible.
Available choice and personal cost: ____________________ - Decide about this specific trade. Take a choice you have good reason to trust if its result is worth its cost to you. If not, accept the trade on purpose or leave the service if you can. Keep an unknown result marked as unknown.
Decision, reason and unresolved limit: ____________________
Ask Jing
Become a Jingius.
Your next step
Finish with a reason for your decision and a clear note of what it can and can’t solve. You don’t have to turn every privacy concern into another task.
A note on the evidence
These sources look at different things: past attitudes, requests sent between services, reported removals and possible predictions from writing. Their results can’t be added up into one percentage of privacy gained. They help tell results apart without explaining every person’s decision.
How we prepared this module
This module links a survey, tests of tracking tools and removal services, and a study of writing on a social network with a written decision exercise. A made-up listing example explains the difference between a process, a reported result and the result you want.
Sources
- Turow, J., Hennessy, M., and Draper, N. (2015-06). The Tradeoff Fallacy: How Marketers Are Misrepresenting American Consumers and Opening Them Up to Exploitation. Annenberg School for Communication, University of Pennsylvania. Original research report; methods, printed p.10; resignation measure and scenarios, printed pp.14–15.
- Merzdovnik, G., Huber, M., Buhov, D., Nikiforakis, N., Neuner, S., Schmiedecker, M., and Weippl, E. (2017). Block Me If You Can: A Large-Scale Study of Tracker-Blocking Tools. IEEE European Symposium on Security and Privacy, 319–333. Authors’ PDF; §5.3, p.8.
- Liu, Z., Iqbal, U., and Saxena, N. (2024). Opted Out, Yet Tracked: Are Regulations Enough to Protect Your Privacy?. Proceedings on Privacy Enhancing Technologies, 2024(1), 280–299. Published PDF; §3.2, p.284; §5.1 and §5.4, pp.286–292.
- He, J., Snyder, P., Haddadi, H., Bustamante, F. E., and Tyson, G. (2025). Measuring the Accuracy and Effectiveness of PII Removal Services. Proceedings on Privacy Enhancing Technologies, 2025(4), 166–182. Published PDF; §3.4, p.170; §6 and §7.1, pp.175–177.
- Bagrow, J. P., Liu, X., and Mitchell, L. (2019). Information flow reveals prediction limits in online social activity. Nature Human Behaviour, 3, 122–128. Author manuscript, arXiv 1708.04575v2; Results, paragraph beginning “This may have distinct implications for privacy”; Methods, “Data collection and filtering”.
