Concept

Your own device use is something you can change while you’re spending time with your child.

Issue

Your family’s screen habits and the attention you give your child right now are two different things to think about.

Solutions

Understand what the research can tell you, then choose a workable activity boundary.

Say your young child asks you to look at something while you’re halfway through a message. You want to finish the message and join in. You also wonder whether using your phone makes your child want more screen time.

Finishing the message affects whether you can join in right now. Your child’s wider screen habits are a different question. Keeping those questions apart helps you decide what you want to change.

This module is for parents of young children choosing a time that isn’t urgent and that they can really give their attention to.

What you’ll get from this module

In this module

By the end of this module, you’ll know how to choose a shared activity and decide which device use can wait. We’ll link a survey of families, two experiments in a lab, interviews with parents and carers, and a trial of a workshop for parents. You’ll see why joining in with your child and changing their overall screen habits are different goals. Then you’ll choose a situation and write a plan that fits your day.

What changes when your attention moves elsewhere?

A survey of families: similar habits don’t show the cause.

Russell Jago and colleagues’ 2014 study collected reports of screen viewing from 1,078 families around Bristol, with children aged five to six. The analysis with full information included 990 children. Parents reported their own viewing, and one parent also reported the child’s.

How much television parents and children watched was closely linked. Families where parents watched more also tended to have children who watched more. But the researchers looked at habits as they already were; they didn’t ask parents to change them.

Similar habits don’t always mean one person is copying the other. Things the family does together and the home’s circumstances could affect both. A parent who overestimates their own viewing might also overestimate their child’s. The authors noted that mistakes in the two estimates could be linked.

Why it matters: You can notice a family pattern without assuming that cutting your own screen time will make your child cut theirs. The survey shows that the habits are linked, but it can’t tell us who is influencing whom.

Read the family survey of television viewing.

An experiment in a lab: a break in teaching changed what was learned straight away.

Jessa Reed and colleagues’ 2017 experiment asked mothers to teach their two-year-olds two new action words. A phone call interrupted one teaching session; the other carried on without that interruption. The main analysis included 38 pairs of a mother and a child.

The researchers then measured where the children looked when they heard the words. On the usual test, children showed they had learned the word taught without interruption, but not the interrupted word. A stricter test asked children to look away from the right action and then back to it as the word changed. That pattern wasn’t shown even after teaching without interruption.

Why it matters: The experiment gives you a reason to notice whether a shared activity keeps going or gets interrupted. It measured learning straight after one particular teaching task, and the result depended on the test used. Total screen minutes alone don’t describe what happens during that activity.

Read the experiment on interrupted word teaching.

A comparison in a lab: paper could pull attention away too.

Souhir Chamam and colleagues’ 2024 study helps separate screen use from being distracted in general. Swiss parents first played with their toddlers, aged 12–36 months. They were then picked at random either to keep playing or to fill in a questionnaire on paper or on a tablet during the next part of the session.

There were 50 recordings that could be used, with scores for how the pair got on for 49 of them. While parents filled in the questionnaire, observers rated the time together as worse, and parents spoke less. Changes in the children’s words and gestures were too small to rule out chance.

The researchers found no clear difference between being distracted by paper and by a tablet. That doesn’t show the two are the same, but it challenges an explanation that looks only at the screen.

Why it matters: For your own shared activity, think about whether you can pay attention and respond. Putting a phone down while picking up another task that pulls you away may miss the point. The study was about short play sessions in a lab, so its results should stay tied to that setting.

Read the paper-versus-tablet distraction experiment.

What does your attention change?

Interviews with parents and carers: a device can bring demands and relief.

Jenny S. Radesky and colleagues’ 2016 study interviewed 35 parents and carers of children aged zero to eight. They described the strain of juggling work and children, along with device use that added stress and device use that eased it.

These were accounts of people’s experiences, not a test of a rule about phone use. They help explain why advice has to allow for what a parent needs the device for.

Why it matters: You still need to meet your responsibilities and have time for yourself. Choose one activity when optional device use can wait, while keeping the use you need within reach. The question is which shared moment can really fit around those needs.

Read the interviews about parenting while connected.

A small trial: a programme for parents didn’t show a drop in children’s screen time.

Samantha Marsh and colleagues’ 2020 trial in Auckland picked 54 parents or carers of children aged two to four at random, either for a programme or for a waiting list to compare with. The programme included a half-day workshop and six weeks of access to a website.

It covered several routines and parts of home life, including parents’ own screen use. Parents reported their children’s screen time. Changes in that result didn’t clearly differ between the groups at six or twelve weeks.

The trial was too small to settle whether the programme works. Because it combined several changes, it also couldn’t single out the effect of parents’ own use. A programme given to parents isn’t always a test of changing only what they do.

Why it matters: That difference keeps the practical goal clear. You can notice how involved you are in an activity you chose without assuming it will change your child’s total screen use.

Read the parent-workshop pilot trial.

Plan one moment of attention

What this means for you

Choose an activity you want to share with your child, and let optional device use wait until it ends. The goal is to join in while leaving room for your other responsibilities.

Choose an activity you can realistically protect

Start with shared play or a conversation your child begins at a time that isn’t urgent. Ask whether work and other arrangements usually let you join in then. If they don’t, choose another moment.

Choosing an activity makes the limit clear: optional device use waits until the play or conversation ends. You’re deciding when you want to join in, without setting a target for screen minutes across your whole day.

Say you want to join your child’s play, but you’re waiting for a message you need about the day’s plans. Put that responsibility in your plan. You might deal with it first, or choose another shared moment when you can give your attention.

Separate optional use from necessary use

Work out what can wait until the activity ends. In the opening example, an optional message could wait while you join in. If the message is about work or arrangements you need to deal with, deal with that.

A quick explanation to your child may help as a courtesy. Then go back to the activity, or set up another moment that works. The explanation isn’t the goal; making room to join in is.

Keep separate times to rest and have time for yourself. A limit around one activity should fit alongside rest and responsibilities. If it makes those too hard, change the limit or stop using it.

Notice participation, not just an absent phone

The paper-and-tablet study gives you a reason to look beyond the phone. Another task may still pull your attention away from the activity. Ask whether you could respond to your child and stay involved. That’s what you’re trying to make room for.

Afterwards, ask whether the arrangement worked for you too. Could optional use wait without making other responsibilities hard? Would a different time or a clearer ending help?

If the activity was easier to keep going and the limit worked, you can choose it again. If something you had to deal with kept interrupting, choose another moment. If the limit added too much strain, change it or stop.

These things are about the time together you chose. They aren’t a score for your parenting or a measure of whether your child’s wider screen habits changed.

Which moment could you give your attention?

How about your daily life?

When would you like to give a shared activity more attention? Think about play you want to join or a conversation you want to hear all the way through. Which moments usually leave room for that attention?

Write down situations worth looking at. One suitable idea is enough.

A shared situationWhat I would like to make easier
________________________________________
________________________________________

Which situation would be most useful to work through now?

My chosen situation: ____________________

Choose a time with your young child that isn’t urgent and that you can really protect. You can change your choice. Carry it into the exercise below.

Choose a workable activity boundary

Start with your chosen situation. If you came straight here, choose a shared activity with your young child that isn’t urgent, such as play or a conversation, at a time when your responsibilities usually let you pay attention.

Keep the work and arrangements you need within reach, and leave separate time for rest and for yourself. If there’s no suitable moment, write that down and stop for now.

  1. Name the activity and its ending. Describe what you want to join in with. Let the limit last until that activity ends.
    Activity and ending: ____________________
  2. Identify what can wait. Name the optional device use you’ll put off. Name any work or arrangements you need that may still need attention.
    Optional use that can wait: ____________________
    Necessary use to accommodate: ____________________
  3. Decide how to handle an interruption. If something you need comes up, deal with it. Explain briefly if that helps, then go back or set up another moment that works.
    How I can return or choose another moment: ____________________
  4. Try the boundary and notice your participation. Afterwards, write down whether you could respond and stay involved. Also write down whether the arrangement left room for your responsibilities, rest and time for yourself.
    How involved I was, and whether the arrangement worked: ____________________
  5. Choose what follows. Keep a limit that works if you want to use it again. Change the time or the activity if things you had to deal with made it hard. Change or stop a limit that adds too much strain.
    Keep, change or stop, and why: ____________________

Ask Jing

Become a Jingius.

Plan one moment with your child

Loading interactive tool…

Your next step

You now have a plan for one shared activity and a choice about what to do next, or a reason it doesn’t fit right now. Judge whether you could join in and whether the plan worked for you. This doesn’t prove that your child’s total screen use will change.

A note on the evidence

The survey describes family patterns as they already were, while the experiments look at tasks with young children straight away. The interviews show competing needs through what parents and carers said. The small workshop trial tested several changes together and left the effect on children’s use unclear.

Together, they support paying attention to what one time together needs while keeping expectations specific. The findings here don’t show that cutting your own daily use will cut your child’s total use.

How we prepared this module

This module links a survey of families, experiments in a lab, interviews with parents and carers, and a small trial. The made-up message and play situations show the choices; the written exercise helps you work through one time together in your own circumstances.

Sources