Concept

Keep doing a useful part of a task yourself, while tools stay close to check and finish the work.

Issue

Doing something by hand can mean remembering, working out a sum, drawing or finding your way. These activities don’t all bring the same benefits.

Solutions

Understand what doing part of the task yourself gives you, then plan one manageable attempt.

Say you reach for a calculator before you think about the total. You could work it out yourself, but the calculator is quicker. Does keeping your own arithmetic going mean giving up that convenience?

You can start with a smaller choice. Guess roughly how large the answer should be, then let the calculator find the exact result. Your guess keeps you involved in the sum. Checking it against the calculator gives you an exact answer to use.

That difference matters beyond arithmetic. Remembering an explanation, taking notes in a lecture and finding your way all use different kinds of thinking. A benefit in one task doesn’t prove the same benefit in another.

This module is for working adults who want to keep using a skill they’ve already chosen, in situations where little is at stake, with good tools nearby for checking and support.

What you’ll get from this module

In this module

By the end of this module, you’ll have a clearer way to keep using a skill you’ve chosen, with useful support still close by. We’ll look at classroom experiments on remembering, reviews of calculators and note-taking, and research on finding your way. You’ll link what they found to everyday choices, pick one situation, and plan an attempt you can manage. You’ll decide how to check your work and when to change your approach.

What matters about doing part of it yourself?

Classroom experiments: trying to remember can help you learn.

In research published in 2011, Henry L. Roediger III and colleagues studied how sixth-grade students learned social studies. Some course facts were given repeated quizzes with feedback. Others were read again and again. The rest got no extra attention. Each student had facts in every group, and which fact went where was decided at random.

Repeated quizzing led to better scores on chapter tests than repeated reading. Students tried to remember an answer, then were shown the correct one. The finding is about learning the course material. It is not about keeping memory in good shape in general.

Why it matters: This shows an important difference. Looking at information again and trying to remember it are two different ways of working with it. The attempt can help you learn, and the feedback keeps your answer tied to what is correct.

Read the classroom quizzing experiments.

An adult who tries to remember a recently learned explanation before looking it up is using the same idea in another setting. The classroom result gives you a reason to try remembering what you’ve learned. It doesn’t tell adults how often to practise to keep a skill.

A review of many studies: calculators can belong in learning.

Aimee J. Ellington’s 2003 review combined 54 studies of school mathematics before college. Students did better at basic maths and at solving problems when calculators were used both in lessons and in tests. When students took tests without calculators, the results were mixed.

You don’t have to give up calculators to learn maths. Students could build their maths skills while using tools, and the results depended on how those tools were used in teaching and testing.

Why it matters: The review didn’t have enough evidence about remembering the skills later or using them in other situations. It helps explain how students learn. It leaves open how adults keep those skills over the years.

Read the calculator-learning meta-analysis.

For everyday sums, you can keep the calculator close and choose one part of the thinking to do yourself.

Reviews of research: no way of taking notes wins every time.

Abraham E. Flanigan and colleagues’ 2024 review of studies on college lectures found a small average advantage in test scores for handwritten notes. Typing produced more notes. Whether students went back over their notes before the test mattered, and the studies looked at single lectures.

Read the college-lecture meta-analysis.

Other reviews found less reason to prefer handwriting. Heather L. Urry and colleagues’ 2021 analysis combined lecture-note studies that were set up in very similar ways. These looked at learning when students did not go back over their notes before the test. The overall difference in quiz scores was small and could have been chance: the analysis did not clearly show an advantage for either way.

Read the close-replication synthesis.

Daniel Voyer and colleagues’ 2022 review combined a wider set of studies that kept the way of taking notes apart from distraction. It also found no clear overall advantage.

Why it matters: These reviews included some of the same studies, but chose and analysed them differently. Treating each review as a separate vote would count some of the same evidence twice.

Read the broader note-taking meta-analysis.

How you take notes changes what you can easily capture and explain. A layout that suits drawing links between ideas does a different job from a detailed written record. A quick sketch may help you think an idea through. Faster typing may help you keep detail you would otherwise miss. The research gives you reasons to think about what you need to capture and how you will use the notes, rather than always choosing the same way.

What does doing it yourself give you?

An observational study: GPS use and remembering your way.

Louisa Dahmani and Véronique D. Bohbot’s 2020 study compared how much young adult drivers had used GPS with how well they did on navigation tasks on a computer. People who had used GPS more tended to do worse at remembering places and how they were laid out. A small follow-up tested 13 of the people again about three years later.

Why it matters: People weren’t randomly assigned to use GPS. Other differences between people could explain the results, including the chance that weaker navigators lean on guidance more. The findings don’t show that GPS caused the differences. The study does not show that practising a route now and then brings lasting improvement.

Read the GPS and spatial-memory study.

GPS directions can do the work of finding a route for you. Thinking through a route you know lets you do that part yourself.

Practise a route you already know

What this means for you

Start with a skill you’ve already decided to keep using. Choose one part of a task to do yourself, and keep a reliable way to check it. The attempt should suit the task, your time and the support you need.

Choose the part you want to do yourself

If you want to keep using arithmetic, a rough guess lets you judge about how large the answer should be. It doesn’t mean every sum has to become a long exercise done by hand.

Say you’re buying three items at 19 each. Rounding each price to 20 gives a guess of 60. The exact total is 57: three times 19. Your guess sets the rough size; the exact sum gives you the amount to use.

The same idea helps with remembering. Pick a fact you need or an explanation you’ve just learned, try it from memory, then look at a reliable source. Fix the difference straight away. If the attempt turns into a long stretch of guessing, use the source and finish the task.

Keep the checks your work requires for sums. Never swap a required medical, money or other safety-critical check for this practice. Even when little is at stake, check your answer before you rely on it.

Choose notes you can actually use

For an idea that suits a sketch or a short handwritten explanation, paper may help. If handwriting loses detail you need, or makes things harder to access, keep typing or another aid that works for you.

After the lesson or talk, use what you captured. Explain the idea, then compare your explanation with the source and your notes. That gives the way you took notes a purpose beyond filling a page.

You can also enjoy handwriting without claiming it helps you learn. Enjoying something, seeing it as part of who you are and getting better at it are different reasons to keep going. Be clear about which reason matters to you.

Keep route practice comfortable and supported

For finding your way, use a walk you know, in comfortable conditions. Think through the route before you set out, and notice useful landmarks as you walk as usual. Stop somewhere suitable before you check a map or do a deliberate remembering exercise.

Never do an attention or remembering exercise while driving or moving. If you’re unsure, rushed or uncomfortable, turn the directions back on. Don’t make yourself get lost just to practise.

The useful part is paying attention to the route you want to know. You don’t need to treat a familiar walk as proof that your memory in general has improved.

Attach a manageable attempt to an existing occasion

An ordinary moment can give you the chance: a sum where little is at stake, a time when you are learning something, or a route you know. Decide which part you will try and what source or tool will check it.

If a natural chance doesn’t come up, set up a suitable time to learn. If it comes up often, you don’t need to do it by hand every time. Choose chances you can manage without building a checklist that keeps growing.

Afterwards, check whether the attempt helped you take part without getting in the way of finishing the task. Did it fit the time you had, keep the detail you needed and let you finish the work correctly? If not, make it simpler, change how you take notes or bring back support. Skills for your job need approved training and feedback, not a home-made everyday exercise.

Which part could you keep doing yourself?

How about your daily life?

Where could you use a skill you’ve already chosen to keep practising? You might remember an explanation you learned recently, make a rough guess at a routine total, sketch an idea or think through a route you know.

Write one or more possibilities. One suitable situation is enough.

SituationPart I want to do myself
________________________________________
________________________________________

Which situation would be useful to work through now?

My chosen situation: ____________________

Carry it into the exercise below. You can change your choice if checking, time or the right conditions are missing.

Plan one manageable attempt

Start with your chosen situation. If you came straight here, choose an occasion where little is at stake and that uses a skill you’ve already decided to keep using. Keep any access aids you need and useful tools close by.

Never swap a required medical, money or safety-critical check for this exercise. Never practise tasks from your job outside approved training and procedures. Never do attention or remembering exercises while driving or moving; stop somewhere suitable first.

  1. Name the occasion and the part you will do. Write when the chance usually comes up and what you will try: remembering, a rough guess, an explanation, a sketch or planning a route you know.
    Occasion and part I will attempt: ____________________
  2. Identify the check before attempting. Name the reliable source, calculator, map or feedback you will use. If you don’t have a suitable check, write down that gap and get support before you rely on the result.
    Check or missing support: ____________________
  3. Make a manageable attempt, then check and finish. Fix mistakes straight away. Stop long guessing, turn the directions back on when you’re unsure or rushed, and change how you take notes if you’re missing detail or it’s hard to access.
    What I attempted and corrected: ____________________
  4. Decide what to keep or adjust. Write whether the attempt fits your time and circumstances. Keep the useful part, make it simpler or bring back more support. If the occasion never comes up, choose a suitable time to learn.
    What I will keep, change or resolve: ____________________

Ask Jing

Become a Jingius.

Plan one attempt you can manage

Loading interactive tool…

Your next step

You have finished when you’ve named the part you will try, how you will check it and a next occasion you can manage—or written down the missing support that stops a suitable attempt.

A note on the evidence

Learning certain material, building a new skill and keeping a skill you already have are different results. The classroom and calculator findings are about learning under the conditions studied. Note-taking findings vary with how each study and review was set up. The navigation study observed differences between people; it did not assign them to use GPS. Keep these differences in mind when you decide what you hope to gain.

How we prepared this module

This module links classroom experiments, reviews of research and an observational study of finding your way to everyday choices. A made-up purchase shows the difference between a rough guess and an exact answer. The written exercise helps you plan taking part, checking and adjusting in one situation.

Sources