Concept

Messages, calls and online updates can bring different kinds of value to a relationship you already have.

Issue

Cutting back on a platform can mean giving up contact you want, while seeing someone’s updates can carry on after a relationship has ended.

Solutions

Understand what your contact makes possible, then review what to keep or reduce.

Say you’re tired of checking a feed, but it’s also where you see photos from family who live far away. You want to scroll less without losing that window into their lives.

The decision is about more than how often you use the platform. What does the contact give you, and what would really be there instead? A visit you can’t manage is different from a conversation you both want but keep putting off.

This module is about relationships you already have. It covers contact by message, call or online update that both of you want and can manage. It matters most when distance, disability, illness, moving country or caring for someone makes being together hard.

What you’ll get from this module

In this module

By the end of this module, you’ll have a clearer way to decide which contact to keep and what you might cut back. We’ll use research on useful replies, families living apart, disability, caring and platform use. You’ll pick a situation from daily life and finish with a decision about contact, or a clear question that still needs an answer.

What does the contact actually give you?

Study of existing posts: useful answers can come from less-close contacts.

Rebecca Gray and colleagues’ 2013 study looked at real questions people had posted on Facebook. The people were university staff who didn’t teach or do research. They brought their own posts to lab sessions and rated the replies. The researchers collected 71 usable questions and 420 ratings of replies.

In these chosen examples, replies from weaker ties were rated more useful than replies from closer ties. Here, weaker ties means people the person felt less close to. This gives a real example of value beyond simply having names on a contact list: people got answers they found useful.

Why it matters: Each example had to have at least two comments from two friends. So requests with no answer were left out. That means the result can’t tell you how likely a new request is to get help. The person who asked rated how useful each reply was. Nobody checked it was accurate, or that it would hold up in a crisis.

Read the study of Facebook questions and replies.

Interview study: close relationships can supply information too.

A separate 2021 study by Nicole C. Krämer, Vera Sauer and Nicole Ellison helps balance that picture. Researchers interviewed 41 students about chosen Facebook contacts and the support they remembered getting.

People remembered getting information from those they felt less close to, but more information from those they felt closer to. They also rated the support from closer contacts as more helpful. These were events people remembered, about contacts they chose. Nobody watched the help happen.

Why it matters: The two studies asked different questions of different groups. One rated replies to chosen posts. The other looked at support people remembered. Together, they give no reason to rank all acquaintances above close friends. Nor do they suggest acquaintances add nothing. The useful question is what a particular exchange gave.

Read the study of recalled support from weak and strong ties.

Study of family life: updates and conversation can work together.

Mirca Madianou’s 2016 paper drew on interviews and online observation. It followed 13 Filipino migrants in the UK whose families were still in the Philippines. The follow-up fieldwork ran from 2011 to 2014.

One woman, Donna, saw family life through photos and updates. She also kept up long Sunday video calls. Her earlier daily calls had become less frequent. Her children getting older, and the family’s long separation, also offered reasons for the change.

The account shows how updates and talking can sit side by side across distance. Knowing about ordinary family life was part of Donna’s contact. So were the chances to talk. The change in calls can’t show that the updates caused it.

Another woman in the same study, Judy, kept seeing her ex-partner’s updates after their relationship had ended. That’s a different situation from a quiet friend who hasn’t replied lately.

Why it matters: These cases split two questions. Are you still seeing someone’s updates? And do those updates serve a relationship you want? They are two examples from one study. They don’t tell us how often either pattern happens.

Read the ethnography of contact across family separation.

What does online contact really give you?

Interview report: contact has to fit the person using it.

A 2025 Department for Culture, Media and Sport report included interviews with 48 disabled young people aged 16–24. Some described keeping up existing friendships online when their disability or health condition made leaving home hard.

Other young people described trouble with messaging. Professionals in the report also said some people struggled to get the technology. So online contact could help one person take part and make things harder for another.

Why it matters: The report doesn’t tell us how common these experiences are among all working adults. It helps explain why access matters: what kind of contact can the person actually manage? Swapping a manageable exchange for something harder could remove the very chance you wanted to keep.

Read the report on disabled young people’s experiences of connection.

Caregiver study: connection and practical assistance are different needs.

Alycia A. Bristol and colleagues’ 2021 study looked at how carers stayed in touch with others during pandemic restrictions. It used surveys from 82 unpaid adult carers, and later interviews with 27 of them.

People described keeping in touch on purpose by phone, letter, email and video. They also described losing services, support groups and practical arrangements, while their caring duties grew. These were reported experiences from a chosen group during unusual restrictions.

Why it matters: The difference matters: staying connected and having practical help are separate questions. A conversation can stay valuable while a care need goes unmet. And being able to reach someone doesn’t mean that person can give the help that’s needed.

Read the study of caregivers’ social connections.

Randomized field experiment: reducing a platform can release some offline time.

Hunt Allcott and colleagues paid people to switch off Facebook for four weeks during the 2018 US election period. Everyone in the study was willing to switch off. Their 2019 revised paper compared those who did with a control group. They could still use Messenger.

Switching off led to a small rise in reported time in person with friends and family, compared with the control group. At the end, people were asked about their free time compared with usual. They picked one of five answers. The result was a shift in those reports, not a measured number of minutes won back.

Why it matters: This suggests Facebook use took the place of some time offline in that setting. It also matters that people could still message each other directly. The study tested cutting out Facebook while leaving Messenger available. It didn’t test removing every way of reaching people.

Read the revised paper on Facebook deactivation.

Study using repeated daily reports: check whether browsing replaces conversation.

Jeffrey A. Hall, Michael W. Kearney and Chong Xing’s study gives a useful counterpoint. Their paper appeared online in 2018. In its second study, 116 people from the community and from undergraduate classes got up to five prompts a day over five days.

Using social media didn’t predict less face-to-face contact a little later. Nor did it predict less contact with people close to them. The researchers watched how people used social media rather than deciding who would use it. They didn’t count direct chat as social-media use.

Why it matters: This doesn’t cancel the switching-off experiment. The studies looked at different changes over different timescales. Together, they suggest looking into a particular missed meeting or call, rather than assuming every moment of scrolling replaces one. A possible alternative only matters if the people involved want it and can manage it.

Read the study testing social displacement.

Check what the scrolling is really replacing

What this means for you

Start with the relationship you want to keep, then look at the activity around it. Useful information, company, ordinary chat and a shared sense of each other’s lives can each matter. A relationship doesn’t need to give all of them.

Preserve the route that carries something you value

Before you cut back, name what the contact gives you. Perhaps it lets you share ordinary family life across distance, swap information, or enjoy someone’s company within the energy you have.

Then ask what would be left if you removed that route. Is there another route you can use that could carry the same contact? If not, keep the one that works, and look at the rest of your use instead.

Say you and a distant friend can manage a short message, but not a visit. Dropping the message for a visit that can’t happen would lose a real chance for one that isn’t there. Keep the contact that fits your life; a harder exchange isn’t needed to prove the relationship matters.

Separate a wanted relationship from unwanted visibility

Judy’s case shows updates that kept coming after a clear ending. You may decide to see less of what serves no relationship you want, without making a judgment about every quiet contact.

Go by what you actually know about the relationship. Slow replies may come from access, illness or tiredness. Don’t treat silence as proof that a relationship is over, set a reply deadline, or make up a request for help to test someone.

If you’re not sure what seeing someone’s updates means to you, leave the relationship undecided. You can admit you’re unsure without calling the person unimportant, or feeling you must keep every update.

Look for an interaction you are actually postponing

Keeping up with updates may sometimes take the place of contact you both want and can manage. Name the actual meeting or call before you decide scrolling has replaced it.

Both conditions matter. The people involved must want it. It must also be possible, given distance, energy, access and other duties.

If it is wanted and possible, and updates seem to be replacing it, think about cutting those updates or making room for it. If the alternative isn’t practical, or the updates add to your connection, keep the useful contact. Leave the cause open when you can’t tell what is going on.

Keep companionship and practical support separate

When you need information, ask for it because the need is real. Learn from the exchanges that happen naturally to understand what help a contact can offer. A useful answer is one thing a friendship can give, not something every friendship has to give.

In the same way, name practical help on its own when you need it. A big contact list is not a care plan. A friend you enjoy talking to may not be able to give hands-on help. You can value the conversation while seeing a need that isn’t met.

These judgments can overlap. A relationship may be worth keeping while some of what you see is unwanted, or while a particular practical need is still unmet. Your decision is about your own use and circumstances, not a score for another person.

Which contact would you like to keep?

How about your daily life?

Where would you like to use a platform less without losing contact you value? Think about family updates across distance, a friendship that fits limited energy, or contact around caring for someone.

You could also look at updates you’d rather not see, or a conversation you both want but keep putting off. Choose a relationship you already have, rather than inventing a request to see whether someone replies.

Write down situations you’d like to understand better. One good idea is enough.

A situation in my daily lifeWhat I would like to understand or change
________________________________________
________________________________________

My chosen situation: ____________________

Carry this situation into the exercise below. Choosing it doesn’t mean you need to cut back on contact; you can change your choice.

Review what to keep or reduce

Start with your chosen situation. If you came straight here, choose a relationship you already have and a message, call or update route you want to look at. Take distance, disability, illness, moving country, caring, energy and access into account where they matter.

Look at your own use, without testing the other person. Never make up a request for help or set a reply deadline for this exercise. Quiet contact and company can matter without leading to practical help.

  1. Name the value and protect a feasible route. Write down what you want to keep: company, a shared sense of each other’s lives, ordinary chat, information or support. The relationship needn’t give everything. Before you remove a route, find another one you can use, or keep the one that works.
    What I value and the route to preserve: ____________________
  2. Identify any unwanted visibility. Ask whether the updates serve a relationship you want. A clear ending can answer that; slow replies or no replies alone can’t. See less of what you don’t want, if you wish. If you’re not sure, leave the relationship undecided.
    Unwanted exposure, or what remains unclear: ____________________
  3. Ask what the updates might be replacing. Name a meeting or call that updates seem to be replacing. First find out whether both of you want it. Then think about whether both of you can manage it. If either answer is no or unknown, don’t assume cutting updates would make it happen.
    If both conditions hold, think about seeing less, or making room for that meeting or call. Keep contact that adds to the relationship, or that is still the option that works.
    Interaction, willingness and feasibility: ____________________
  4. Record one decision or unresolved question. You might keep contact, see less of what you don’t want, or make room for a meeting or call you both want and can manage. These choices can overlap. If practical help is needed, write that need down separately; a big contact list doesn’t show that help is there.
    My decision and reason, or question still to resolve: ____________________

Ask Jing

Become a Jingius.

Decide what contact to keep

Loading interactive tool…

Your next step

You have finished when you can explain what you want to keep and why you would change something, or why the decision is still open. Treat the judgment as something you can change as your life and your contact change.

A note on the evidence

These studies look at useful replies, feeling connected, access and how people spent their time. Each was in a different setting. They don’t show which particular relationships would fade without easy contact. The interview-based accounts make possibilities and limits clearer; they don’t tell us how common each experience is.

The switching-off experiment and the study using daily reports give us reason to look at what happens in a particular situation. Keep what is wanted and workable while you look at the particular contact you think is being lost.

How we prepared this module

This module brings together studies of online replies and remembered support, a study of family life across distance, accounts from disabled people and carers, and research on platform use. The made-up examples explain the choices. The written exercise helps you apply these ideas to a relationship you already have.

Sources