Concept

Effort is worth keeping when it helps you learn or get something done. Effort for its own sake is not.

Issue

A task can get easier while quietly changing what you learn from doing it.

Solutions

Look at what your help takes away and what it makes possible, then assess one convenience.

Say you’ve followed directions to a place you’ve never been. You get there with no trouble. But afterwards you couldn’t explain the route to anyone. Did the directions let you down, or did they do exactly what you needed?

That depends on the task. Getting there and learning the route are two different results. If you needed both, arriving safely only tells you half the story.

The same question works for other conveniences too. Making something easier might mean you learn less. It might take away a burden. It might let you do more than you could alone. Often it does some of each.

This module is for working adults looking at one convenience in a low-stakes part of life. Start with something you already know you need to be able to do there.

What you’ll get from this module

In this module

By the end of this module, you’ll have a clearer way to judge the help you use. We’ll look at research on learning difficulty, memory, finding your way, calculator lessons and household water supply. You’ll learn to tell effort that helps you learn from a burden you can safely drop. Then you’ll choose an everyday situation and decide whether to keep the convenience, change how it helps, or leave the question open for now.

What changes when effort disappears?

Research chapter: difficulty only helps when it serves learning.

In a 2011 chapter, Elizabeth Ligon Bjork and Robert A. Bjork explain why some difficulties help you learn while others just get in the way. They call the helpful ones “desirable difficulties”: challenges that help you take in information and recall it later.

The word “desirable” matters. The challenge has to help you learn. And you need enough background knowledge or skill to meet it. Without that starting point, making an activity harder can get in the way of learning.

So don’t stop at whether an activity feels easy or hard. Trying to recall something you need to learn serves a purpose. Waiting through a delay with no learning purpose is a different kind of effort. Removing one need not have the same effect as removing the other.

Why it matters: The chapter pulls together learning research. It isn’t a trial of everyday conveniences. What it gives you is a useful question: what, if anything, does this effort help you learn?

Read the chapter on desirable difficulties.

Which effort is worth keeping?

Laboratory experiments: finishing a task and remembering it are different results.

In 2021, Sandra Grinschgl, Frank Papenmeier and Hauke S. Meyerhoff published three experiments in which students copied patterns on tablets. Each experiment’s final group had 172 students.

Participants could keep looking at the pattern on screen instead of holding it in memory. Researchers call this cognitive offloading: using something outside your head to cut down on mental work.

In the first experiment, the researchers made the pattern harder to look at. Participants then relied on it less. They copied the patterns less efficiently, but they remembered the material better on a later test they weren’t expecting.

The third experiment showed another possibility. Some participants had to rely heavily on the on-screen pattern. Those who were told about the coming memory test remembered more than those who weren’t. Knowing about the test made up for much of the memory cost of leaning on the display. Under those conditions, participants could use the help and still learn.

Simply meaning to learn wasn’t enough in every condition the experiments tested. And the experiments measured memory for new material. They didn’t show that participants had lost a skill they already had.

Why it matters: The useful distinction is between completing a task and learning from it. If you need both, a finished task doesn’t tell you whether you learned what you needed.

Read the experiments on offloading and memory.

Walking experiment: help can point you toward what you need to learn.

Could the help itself make useful information easier to notice? In 2021, Anna Wunderlich and Klaus Gramann compared standard navigation directions with directions that mentioned landmarks.

In their third experiment, participants walked a route through Berlin while listening to spoken directions. Each was randomly given standard instructions or one of two versions with landmark cues. A researcher followed nearby. The final analysis covered 35 of the 41 participants recorded.

Two weeks later, participants were shown landmarks and asked which way the route went at each one. On average, they got the direction right 30.2% of the time with standard instructions, 42.9% with short landmark cues and 46.6% with long landmark cues.

Both landmark groups did better than the standard group. The short and long versions didn’t differ by a meaningful amount. So more detailed guidance wasn’t shown to be necessary for that gain.

Everyone received help finding the way. The difference was whether the instructions linked a turn to a landmark. The landmark groups could follow the directions and learn something about the route at the same time. That’s why the form of the help matters when learning is part of the task.

Why it matters: The groups were small, and the study measured knowledge of landmarks along one route. It didn’t show that people built a flexible mental map of the area. Its useful lesson is that changing how help is given can make a difference to learning.

Read the walking study of landmark-based guidance.

What does the landmark change?

Research review: learning with a tool can help you perform without it.

The walking experiment compared different kinds of help. Calculator research gives another reason to doubt the idea that using help must weaken learning.

In her 2003 review, Aimee J. Ellington looked at calculator use in school maths lessons. One comparison combined 15 studies in which students used calculators during lessons but took the relevant tests without them.

On tests of operational skills, students taught with calculators did better on average than students taught without them. These tests covered both doing the calculation and understanding the idea behind it. The studies varied a lot, so the average doesn’t describe every classroom or every skill.

The calculator was part of the lessons, but students couldn’t use it to get their test answers. So their better average result shows what they could do without the calculator after learning with it.

Why it matters: Learning with a tool need not weaken what you can do without it. That doesn’t tell us what happens when an adult hands every sum to a calculator. To understand the result, keep both parts in view: how the tool was used during learning, and what the test measured.

Read the review of calculators in mathematics instruction.

Randomized encouragement study: less burden can be a worthwhile result in itself.

Learning isn’t the only reason to value a convenience. In 2012, Florencia Devoto and colleagues studied household water connections in Tangiers, Morocco. The households already got water from public taps or from neighbours.

The researchers randomly chose groups of nearby households to receive information and help with the paperwork for a home connection on credit. A comparison group got no such help. The connections still cost money.

The offer of help led more households to get connected. It cut the burden of collecting water and improved how people said they felt about their lives. The time saved went on leisure and socialising.

At the short follow-up, the researchers found no rise in paid work, income or schooling. The income figures were imprecise, so later economic gains can’t be ruled out.

This case separates two judgments that are easy to mix up. Time can become free without turning into more paid work. The relief can still matter to the people who get it.

Why it matters: The finding is about water access in that setting. For an everyday convenience, it suggests a useful question: what does the saved effort actually give you? More work isn’t the only answer worth counting.

Read the study of household water access in Tangiers.

What this means for you

Start with the task you already need to get done. Then look at what the help changes: what gets easier, what you learn, and what you can now do.

Name what you no longer have to do

“It does my thinking for me” is too vague to help you decide. Name the part of the task the help removes: noticing a landmark, coming up with an answer, checking a result, carrying something or waiting.

Now ask how that part helps you do what the task requires. Does it help you learn something you need, make a judgment or spot a wrong answer? Or is it just a burden you have no reason to keep?

The difficulty chapter explains why this matters. Effort is worth keeping when it helps you learn, not just because it feels hard. If you don’t know what the removed part contributes, write “unknown.”

Writing “unknown” stops a guess from deciding whether you change the help. It also makes clear what you still need to find out.

Ask, too, whether you know enough to learn from the challenge. As the Bjorks explain, struggling without the knowledge or skill to cope can get in the way of learning.

Make room for learning while the help continues

If you need to finish a task and learn from it, write down both needs. The pattern-copying experiments show why they are separate. Finishing efficiently doesn’t, by itself, show what you’ll remember afterwards.

Next, ask whether the help can keep you involved in the part you need to learn. In the landmark experiment, the directions linked each turn to a feature of the route. People could use the guidance and learn from that link.

For a made-up comparison, imagine you’re sitting down and looking at ways to get directions for a route you don’t know. You need both to reach the destination and to understand the route.

Directions that only tell you where to turn might get you there without showing whether you’ve learned the route. Directions that mention landmarks could be worth considering. They tie each turn to something you want to recognise and remember.

If all you need is to arrive, getting there with help may be enough. The choice changes because what you need from the task has changed.

Make this comparison on paper while you’re sitting down or standing still. Never add attention or memory tasks while driving, cycling or walking through traffic. The research involved walking with a researcher nearby. It isn’t a reason to add demands while you travel.

Keep any accessibility aids you need in place. Look for ways to learn while you receive the help you need. Don’t remove support that makes the activity possible.

Count the benefits of the help

Put the benefits next to any learning you might miss. The help may let you take part, finish the task, ease a burden, save time or do more than you could without it.

The calculator review shows why using a tool doesn’t automatically mean learning less. The water study shows why learning isn’t the only benefit worth counting.

You may value rest, or a day with less to carry. Those benefits don’t have to be relabelled as extra productivity to count in your decision.

Keep these results separate when you decide. Remembering less would matter if you needed to remember, but it wouldn’t wipe out every benefit of the help. Finishing quickly wouldn’t show that you’d learned what you needed, either.

Separate what you hope will happen from what happens

If you use the convenience because it frees time or attention for something else, name what happens next. “I’ll use the time to learn” describes an intention. It doesn’t show that the learning happened.

If learning is the reason you want to free up time or attention, explain how you’ll keep working with the material you need to learn. Removing effort doesn’t answer that question. The pattern-copying experiments show that how the task is set up matters, even when help is available.

You can also plan to rest. Record rest honestly as the purpose of the saved time, instead of inventing another achievement to justify it.

Decide what to keep, change or leave open

Keep the convenience when it helps with the task and you have no clear reason to change it. Change how it helps when it removes something you need to do in order to learn.

Leave the question open when you don’t know something important. Say what you still need to find out. Not knowing doesn’t show that the convenience helps or harms your learning.

In the made-up route comparison, directions that get you there can be worth keeping when arriving is all you need. If you also need to learn the route, look at what the directions help you notice. If you don’t know whether they support that learning, record the gap.

These choices follow from the task and the evidence you have. None of them means making an activity harder just to put the effort back.

What does your help take off your hands?

How about your daily life?

Where does help take over something you used to do yourself? Think about following directions, coming up with an answer, checking work or getting rid of a repetitive chore.

Choose a low-stakes situation where you already know what you need to get done or understand. You might want to tell finishing a task apart from learning how it works. Or you might want to spot a burden you’re happy to drop.

Write down one or more possibilities. One suitable idea is enough.

A situation in my daily lifeWhat I already need to do or understand
________________________________________
________________________________________

Which situation would be most useful to look at now?

My chosen situation: ____________________

Carry it into the exercise below. You can change your choice. Choosing a situation doesn’t mean its convenience needs changing.

Assess one convenience

Start with your chosen situation. If you’re starting here, choose one low-stakes activity and a convenience you use in it. Before you judge the help, write down what you already need to be able to do.

Activity, convenience and existing requirement: ____________________

Keep any accessibility aids you need in place. For any navigation example, make a written comparison while sitting down or standing still. Never add attention or memory tasks while driving, cycling or walking through traffic.

  1. Name what the help removes. Pick out one specific part of the task, such as noticing a cue, coming up with an answer or checking a result. “Thinking” is too broad. You can also name a burden, such as waiting or carrying.
    Operation or burden removed: ____________________
  2. Connect it to what you need. How does that part help you learn, or make the judgments the task calls for? If you don’t know, write that down. Difficulty on its own doesn’t show that it helps.
    How it helps with the task, or what is unknown: ____________________
  3. Record what the help makes possible. Include finishing the task, taking part, easing a burden, saving time and what you can do with help. Keep these benefits separate from what you need to learn or do without it.
    Benefits and any learning trade-off: ____________________
  4. Describe how you use the time or effort saved. Say what you do, or plan to do, including rest. Make clear which has already happened and which is still a plan. If you expect to learn, explain how you’ll keep working with the material while you use the help.
    Actual use or plan, and how learning stays part of the task: ____________________

Use your answers to make a decision for now. Keep a convenience that helps with the task. If it removes something you need in order to learn, consider changing how it helps. Say which part you want to keep doing yourself.

If an important answer is unknown, leave the trade-off open and name the information you need. Don’t take away an aid you need just to force a decision.

Retain, adapt or unresolved—and why: ____________________

Ask Jing

Become a Jingius.

Assess one convenience

Loading interactive tool…

Your next step

You’ve finished when you can say what the help removes, what it makes possible and why you’ve chosen your response. Knowing exactly what you still need to find out is a useful result too.

A note on the evidence

These sources look at different results: how learning works, memory for new material, knowledge of a route, maths performance and household well-being. Their findings don’t add up to one measure of overall ability.

The learning results depend on the tasks and conditions studied. For your own task, ask what you need to get done or learn, and how the help changes what you do.

How we prepared this module

This module brings together a chapter on learning research, experiments on memory and finding your way, a review of calculator lessons and a study of water access. A made-up route comparison works through the decision, and the written exercise helps you look at one everyday convenience.

Sources