Say you’re renewing a service you use to make personal designs. You have copies of the finished pictures, but you also want to change them later. Would those copies let you carry on?
That question is more useful than deciding whether renting is good or bad. A finished picture might keep what you made, while editing it still depends on the original service. Buying another product would only help if it gave you the function you need.
You can value easy access and still protect particular work. The aim is to understand what would still work, what you could replace, and what would be hard to get back.
This module is for working adults deciding how to keep everyday abilities and material they have the right to keep.
What you’ll get from this module
In this module
By the end of this module, you’ll have a clearer way to decide what to keep using, what to save separately, and when owning something would help. We’ll use a study of what shoppers understand when they buy. We’ll also use notices from providers, research on services closing and car sharing, and official guidance on records and repair. You’ll link their lessons to one everyday situation and finish with a recovery choice or a clear gap to look into.
Ask Jing
Become a Jingius.
What would you keep if the arrangement changed?
Controlled web study: specific information can explain more than a purchase label.
Aaron Perzanowski and Chris Jay Hoofnagle’s 2017 paper reports a pretend shopping study using 1,299 completed surveys from US internet users in 2016. People saw different versions of a made-up store’s product pages.
For digital goods, the researchers compared a Buy Now button, a License Now button, and a short notice. The notice said what buyers could and couldn’t do. They measured how well people understood straight away. They used a Rights Score from 0 to 7 under the pretend terms. Higher scores meant more right answers.
The short-notice group averaged 3.00, against 2.45 for Buy Now and 2.27 for License Now. The difference between the two button labels was not statistically significant. The paper doesn’t show that people were put into these versions at random.
The useful difference is between a familiar label and information about particular uses. A label leaves you to guess what you can keep or do. The notice spelled those questions out, and people understood better in that comparison.
Why it matters: This was a result about understanding after seeing the page once. It supports paying attention to the exact permissions, without treating a store label as the full story of your rights.
Read the study of digital purchase understanding.
Provider announcement: money returned and continued use are different outcomes.
A service can also end, whatever you expected when you bought it. In September 2022, Phil Harrison announced Google’s decision to close the consumer Stadia game-streaming service.
The announcement kept access to game libraries until January 18, 2023. It promised refunds for Stadia hardware bought through the Google Store, and for games and add-ons bought through the Stadia Store.
Why it matters: Those were the terms announced, not a count of refunds actually paid. They separate two things you might care about: getting your money back and carrying on with an activity. A refund can cover what you paid without giving you the same playable service.
Read the Stadia closure announcement from Google.
Technical compatibility record: a service can remain while a workflow changes.
Adobe’s October 10, 2023 record describes changes to Pantone colour libraries after a change in licensing. The phase-out began with updates on August 16, 2022; the last three libraries were removed from Photoshop in October 2023.
The same record explains which files still work in which programs. Older Photoshop files with Pantone colour books show normally in Photoshop from November 2022 on. Spot channels hold extra printing colours. Photoshop files that use them can show grey or black in Illustrator or InDesign if their colour books are missing.
Why it matters: So the program and the way you work both matter. Still having access to an app doesn’t mean every earlier task still works. And a library change doesn’t mean every existing picture loses its colours.
Read the Pantone compatibility record from Adobe.
Qualitative research: recovering files can leave other things missing.
Sandy J. J. Gould and Sarah Wiseman’s 2022 study looked at experiences and expectations of digital services closing. An online questionnaire, shared through Reddit and Twitter, gave 55 complete answers they could use.
Of those people, 25 said a service had closed while they were using it. The authors kept those experiences apart from answers about closures people imagined might happen. These volunteers weren’t chosen to represent everyone. Their answers can’t tell us how often people lose services.
People described missing functions and context, beyond single files. One person who had lived through a closure set up a good replacement on their own server. In the end they gave it up, because they didn’t have time to look after it.
Why it matters: These accounts explain why finding an alternative and being able to keep it going are separate questions. A set of files may keep the content while losing the history or functions that made it useful. Even a replacement that does what you need still needs someone with the time and skill to keep it working.
Read the research on digital service closure.
Preservation guidance: a useful copy must remain usable.
The Library of Congress’s undated guidance on personal records says to choose important documents and keep several copies in different places. It also says to check that the files can still be read. Choosing matters, because it ties the effort of keeping things to material you value.
Its guide to digital formats, written for libraries, adds another question: what does a file need in order to work? It may need certain hardware, systems or software. It may also have locks that limit copying or use.
Why it matters: Together, these sources separate having a file from being able to use what’s in it. The personal guidance covers records; the format framework was written for library collections. For your own material, both questions matter: do you have a copy you can use, and do you have what you need to open or use it?
Read the personal digital records guidance. Read the digital format sustainability framework.
Official evidence review: ownership can still leave repair dependencies.
The Federal Trade Commission’s May 2021 report looked at limits on repair. It drew on a workshop, written comments and other evidence. It found barriers in design, parts, manuals, testing tools, software locks and licence terms.
The report describes kinds of limits, rather than measuring how repairable every owned product is. Its point is practical: owning a device doesn’t, on its own, give you the means to keep it working.
Why it matters: So an option to own something needs more than a price comparison. The way to repair it, and the software it needs, help decide whether it gives you the lasting function you want.
Read the report on repair restrictions.
Research team policy brief: occasional access can provide valuable capability.
Access also deserves a fair comparison. Julene Paul, Miriam Pinski, Madeline Brozen and Evelyn Blumenberg wrote a 2024 brief on BlueLA, a car-sharing service. It reports interviews with 37 members in central Los Angeles, some paying full price and some helped with the cost.
Members said it saved them money, and that using a car now and then fitted alongside public transport, walking and cycling. For these users, access could meet a need without buying a car.
How easy it was to get a car changed how useful the arrangement was. A shortage of cars affected when members could use the service, and it worked poorly for getting to work. Many members still preferred to own a car when they could afford to.
Why it matters: These are interview findings from that setting. The research team didn’t judge whether the service could pay its way, and future subsidy funding was uncertain. Useful access now and then and reliable access every day are different needs; the same arrangement may suit one better than the other.
Read the BlueLA car-sharing research brief.
What this means for you
Judge the arrangement by the function you need and what you could get back after a change. That keeps the benefits of access in view, while giving important material and activities the attention they need.
Name the function before choosing a product
Start with what you need to do: look at finished work, carry on editing it, reach a record, or use a particular feature of a device. Then describe what a break in service would stop.
In the made-up design example, seeing the finished picture and changing parts of it are different needs. A copy that meets the first may not meet the second. Decide which matters before you compare alternatives.
Also describe how long you could manage without that function. What you need to get done decides how long you can wait. Something you do now and then, with a workable substitute, may justify keeping access; an essential function with no quick substitute deserves a closer look.
Separate the ways control can change
Think about three different questions. What stops if the service ends completely? What could change while the service is still there? What might stop you repairing it, keeping a copy you can use or moving to another system?
Each answer points to a different response. A replacement might deal with a service closing. A check on what still works together might make sense of a change in how you work. A copy you can use elsewhere might keep a record, while leaving the original service’s other functions behind.
Look for clear information about carrying on using it, exporting and repair. If the answer is missing, write down that gap instead of treating a purchase or licence label as the answer.
Check what a permitted copy actually preserves
Choose important material you have the right to keep. Keep the originals you’re allowed to, and where needed, a separate version you can use outside the original service. Open or use a sample there and note what survives.
Go back to the made-up picture. If you only need to see the finished design, a copy you can open may be enough. If you’ll need to change it later, check whether the separate version keeps that ability.
Also look for context you need, such as the history that makes a record make sense. A download that works tells you that you got a file. Your check should answer whether it keeps the particular thing you need.
Never get round rights or restrictions to make a copy. Restricted work records and operations that people’s safety depends on have their own rules; use the responsible organization’s procedure rather than this personal exercise.
Compare recovery effort with the benefits of access
Ask what another route would take: time to move, material you can use, the equipment you have and ongoing upkeep. If you can’t keep the replacement working, finding it hasn’t solved the problem.
For keeping access, count what it lets you do and the upkeep you avoid. Then weigh those benefits against a break you could realistically manage. BlueLA’s benefits for occasional users show why access can be worth it, even when owning would be more reliable.
If you’re thinking about owning, ask what it would let you do without the current service. Check that it works without the service you might lose. Then check what you’re allowed to do with it, the software it needs, how to repair it and its upkeep. Paying more for an option that still needs the same missing service wouldn’t solve that problem.
There may be no owned alternative you can use, or its cost and upkeep may be more than you can manage. Write down that limit and choose a modest fallback that works. You don’t need to invent something to buy.
Choose the response that fits the gap
Keep access when it helps you do something useful and you could replace it before a break becomes a problem. Add a separate copy when the service is still useful but particular records would be hard to recreate.
Think about owning when losing a function you need would cause a break you can’t manage, and an option you could own lets you keep doing what you need. Check that it removes the reliance that worries you, and that you can keep it working.
These choices can go together. You might keep renting an editor while keeping checked copies of important work. Look at the decision again after a real change in the service, the formats or your needs.
How about your daily life?
Where do you value access, but care about what you could keep or carry on doing? Think about personal creative work, records kept in a service, or something you use now and then.
Write down situations you’d like to understand better. One good idea is enough.
| A situation in my daily life | What I want to keep doing or preserve |
|---|---|
| ____________________ | ____________________ |
| ____________________ | ____________________ |
Which situation would be most useful to look at now?
My chosen situation: ____________________
Choose everyday material or an activity you control and can fairly judge. Carry that choice into the exercise below; choosing it doesn’t yet mean you should change providers or buy anything.
Make a recovery decision
Start with your chosen situation. If you came straight here, choose one everyday ability or piece of material you control and have the right to keep.
Never get round rights or restrictions. Restricted work records and operations that people’s safety depends on need their own rules and the right people’s procedures, rather than this personal exercise.
- Name what needs to remain possible. Write down the function or material you need, what a break would stop, and how long you could manage without it.
Need and tolerable interruption: ____________________ - Separate the possible losses. Describe what a complete shutdown would stop, what a service that carries on could change, and what might limit repair, keeping copies or moving elsewhere. Mark unknown answers as questions.
Losses or missing information: ____________________ - Inspect a permitted sample. Name important material you have the right to keep. Keep the originals you’re allowed to, and a separate version you can use where needed. Try opening or using a sample outside the original service.
Note whether you can read it, do the function you need and understand its context. If no material needs keeping, write that down and go on to the way you’d replace the function.
What survives and what is missing: ____________________ - Assess another route and its upkeep. Name what could give you the function, how long the change would take, and what keeping it going would need. Check permissions, what it needs to run and repair options where they matter.
If you can’t check a condition you need, name the information or the right person to help. If no workable alternative exists, write down that limit and a modest fallback you can really use.
Recovery route, upkeep or unresolved gap: ____________________ - Choose a proportionate response. Keep access if its benefits justify a break you can manage. Add a separate copy when useful access sits alongside records that would be hard to replace.
Think about owning when an option you could get removes a reliance that matters to you, and you can keep it working. Leave the decision open if an answer you need is missing.
Choice and reason: ____________________
Next action or information needed: ____________________
Material change that would prompt another look: ____________________
Ask Jing
Become a Jingius.
Your next step
You’re finished when you have a reasoned choice or a clearly named gap, with the next step you can take. Keep in mind the difference between what your copy keeps and what your recovery route can actually do.
A note on the evidence
The provider records describe particular changes; they don’t show how common such losses are. The shopping study measured understanding straight away. The findings on services closing and on car sharing describe particular groups of users and what happened to them.
The guidance on keeping records and the evidence on repair explain dependencies worth looking at. Apply those ideas to your real needs and the alternatives open to you, including the effort it takes to keep an alternative working.
How we prepared this module
This module brings together a study of what shoppers understand, records from providers, research based on interviews and questionnaires, and official guidance on keeping records and on repair. A made-up design example explains the difference between keeping a finished result and keeping the ability to edit it. The exercise helps you make that distinction in one everyday situation.
Sources
- Aaron Perzanowski and Chris Jay Hoofnagle. (2017). What We Buy When We ‘Buy Now’. University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 165(2), 315–378. Final journal version; Methods, pp.330–332; Rights Score, pp.353–355, Figure 16.
- Phil Harrison (Google). (September 29, 2022). A message about Stadia and our long term streaming strategy. Provider announcement; paragraph beginning “We’re grateful”.
- Adobe. (October 10, 2023). Pantone Color books | Photoshop. Technical record; opening phase-out paragraphs and “Use of Pantone Color books in Photoshop” bullets.
- Sandy J. J. Gould and Sarah Wiseman. (November 2022). Dealing with digital service closure. Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction, 6, CSCW2, Article 504, 25 pages. Author HTML preprint; Method/Participants, Results, “Loss of capability,” “Time and effort,” and “Facilitating return of data.”
- Library of Congress. (Undated). Keeping Personal Digital Records. National Digital Information Infrastructure and Preservation Program. “Decide which documents have long-term value” and “Make copies and manage them in different places.”
- Library of Congress. (Undated). Sustainability of Digital Formats: Planning for Library of Congress Collections — Sustainability Factors. Institutional framework; “External dependencies” and “Technical protection mechanisms.”
- Federal Trade Commission. (May 2021). Nixing the Fix: An FTC Report to Congress on Repair Restrictions. Official report; Executive summary, printed pp.3 and 6; section IV restriction categories.
- Julene Paul, Miriam Pinski, Madeline Brozen and Evelyn Blumenberg. (January 17, 2024). Subsidized Electric Carsharing: Can BlueLA Meet the Needs of Low-Income Travelers in Los Angeles. UCLA Lewis Center policy brief; “Study Approach,” “Key Findings,” “Affordability,” “Difficulty Securing a BlueLA Vehicle,” and “Conclusion,” printed pp.1–2.
