Concept

Getting somewhere with directions and remembering how you got there are two different things.

Issue

You can follow every turn and still not know how the route fits together.

Solutions

Learn what different kinds of help leave for you to learn, then check one familiar route.

Say you’ve just arrived somewhere familiar. The directions worked. But you couldn’t describe the route without opening the map again. Have you forgotten something? Or have you simply never needed to remember it?

What can you remember about the route? Why are some parts unclear? Those are two different questions. One trip may show a gap in your memory. It can’t tell you what caused the gap.

You can keep the help that works for you and still choose what you want to remember yourself. Start with something that matters to you, such as remembering a familiar route. That gives you a reason to learn, without making GPS the enemy.

This module is for adults who want to keep finding their own way on familiar, low-risk routes, and who can safely choose how much help to use.

What you’ll get from this module

In this module

By the end of this module, you’ll see how getting somewhere differs from remembering the way there. That gives you a clearer choice about what you want to learn and which help to keep. You’ll pick a situation from daily life, check one familiar route, and find what you remember and what you still need to check. We’ll draw on studies of GPS habits, turn-by-turn directions, navigation training and trainee taxi drivers in London.

What navigation research can tell you

Observational study: GPS habits and memory for places.

Louisa Dahmani and Véronique D. Bohbot (2020) studied 50 people in Montreal who drove regularly. Each person described how much they had used GPS over the years. Then they did navigation tasks in a virtual world. People who said they had used GPS more over their lives tended to do worse on several tests of memory for places and layouts. One test asked them to draw a map of a virtual place.

Only 13 people came back for a follow-up about three years later, which had not been planned. Those who had used GPS more between the two visits tended to show bigger drops on some of the memory tests. So the follow-up tracked GPS use and memory over time. But it was small, and it only observed people. It does not show that GPS caused the changes.

People with weaker navigation skills may simply use more help. Other differences between people may matter too. The researchers checked how people rated their own sense of direction, but that can’t rule out these other explanations.

Why it matters: The study links GPS habits with memory. It can’t tell you why you struggled on one particular trip. A useful question to take from it: which parts of finding your way do you still practise when you get help?

Read the study of GPS habits and spatial memory.

Observational study: a different navigation task gives a different result.

Emre Yavuz and colleagues (2024) studied adults in the US using a navigation game called Sea Hero Quest. Players studied a map, then found their way to checkpoints without it. Overall, the study found no statistically clear link between how much people said they relied on GPS and how well they did on this task.

This result challenges the idea that relying on GPS goes with worse results on every kind of navigation test. It doesn’t cancel out the Montreal findings. Learning a map before you set off and remembering a virtual maze are different tasks.

The paper gives conflicting numbers of people taking part, and some conflicting statistics. But its main finding, no clear link overall, is the same throughout, so that is the result used here. And not finding a clear link on this task doesn’t prove there is no link in other settings.

Why it matters: Taken together, the studies make a broad label like “sense of direction” less useful than a specific question. Remembering a turn, drawing a layout and reaching a place don’t have to tell the same story.

Read the study of GPS reliance and game-based wayfinding.

What can one result tell you about finding your way?

Walking experiment: directions that point out landmarks.

Anna Wunderlich and Klaus Gramann (2021) tested whether directions could help people learn a route while guiding them along it. In their Berlin experiment, people on foot were given one of three kinds of directions, by chance: standard directions, short directions that named landmarks, or longer directions that named landmarks. After some people were left out, 35 were included in the results.

After 13 to 17 days, people saw pictures of landmarks at junctions and said which way the route had turned there. On average, 30.2% of answers were right with standard directions. With short landmark directions it was 42.9%, and with longer ones 46.6%.

Both landmark groups remembered the directions more accurately than the standard group. The short and long versions did not differ in a clear way on this task. These figures are right answers about directions. They are not gains in overall navigation skill.

The groups were small, and they differed in how they rated their own sense of direction. The benefit was mainly for the landmarks named in the directions, not for everything around them.

Why it matters: Even with those limits, the design points to a useful option. Help can tell you where to go and also link each instruction to something you can see. You don’t have to choose between getting directions and learning nothing at all.

Read the experiment on landmark-based navigation instructions.

Keep the directions and learn the way

Training experiment: practice helps with particular tasks.

Toru Ishikawa and Yiren Zhou (2020) studied 40 adults who said their sense of direction was poor. Over six weekly sessions, they learned routes through a residential area of eastern Tokyo. By chance, each person got either feedback alone, or feedback plus practice in keeping track of where they were and which way they were facing.

Across the sessions, the group with the extra training judged directions more accurately. On average, their guesses were off by 39.57°, against 52.32° for the feedback-only group. These are averages for two different groups. They are not one person’s change from before to after.

The main test found no clear change in how accurate people’s direction guesses were across the sessions. It also found no clear difference in how the two groups changed. A separate test, looking for a steady trend, did find a clear improvement over the sessions.

Both groups got better at judging distances and drawing sketch maps as the sessions went on. The extra training added no clear benefit on those tests.

Both groups had feedback and walked the routes again and again. So the study can’t tell us how much of the improvement came from the feedback and how much from the repeated experience. It also didn’t test recovery from any loss caused by GPS.

Why it matters: These mixed results are a reason to name what you want to learn. Judging direction better and drawing a better sketch map are different goals. Practice can help without improving every part of navigation at once.

Read the study of route-learning practice and feedback.

Long-term study: learning London and changes in the brain.

Katherine Woollett and Eleanor A. Maguire (2011) followed male trainee taxi drivers in London for three to four years, and compared them with a group of people who were not training. Trainees who qualified showed more grey matter in the back part of the hippocampus, a part of the brain involved in memory.

Of those who came back for the follow-up, trainees who qualified and those who didn’t were both better than the comparison group at judging where London landmarks were. Yet the qualified trainees did worse than the comparison group at remembering a complicated drawing after a delay. So their brain changes came alongside different results on different memory tasks.

This was intense professional learning. People were not put into training at random, and some trainees missed the follow-up. It was not a study of giving up GPS.

Why it matters: This helps explain why “better brain” says too little. A brain scan measures something different from a memory test. And even the memory test results changed with what people were asked to remember.

Read the study of London taxi training and brain changes.

What this means for you

You don’t need to work out the cause of every forgotten turn before you decide what to remember. Choose one specific thing you’d like to do yourself, and keep the help you need for the trip.

Choose what you want to do before using less help

Ask what finding your own way would let you do. Maybe you want to remember the route to a shop you visit often, or explain how its turns connect. “Have a better brain” gives you nothing you can check. Remembering that route does.

Keep two things apart: finishing a trip and learning the route. When you need directions to travel safely, use them. Needing help is not a failure. Finding your own way is a personal choice, not a duty.

If you want to test what you know about a route, pick a familiar, low-risk one where you can safely change how much help you use. Keep backup directions to hand, and use them when you’re unsure. Never turn driving, or moving through traffic, into a memory or attention exercise.

Connect a turn with a place

The Berlin study suggests a useful way to think about help. Does it link the direction with something you can recognise? Directions that name landmarks still help you, and they build route information into the instruction.

When you go over a route while you’re not moving, try linking a turn you remember with a landmark. Say you remember turning beside a bakery. Check that memory against a map before you treat it as reliable route knowledge.

That check tells you something specific. Remembering the bakery but not the direction leaves one gap. Remembering neither leaves another. Just repeating “turn left” tells you less about which place the instruction belongs to.

Use a check to find a gap, not to diagnose damage

While you’re not moving, sketch a familiar route from memory, then compare it with a map. Note what matches and which turns or landmarks you’re still unsure of. One try can’t diagnose damage, explain what caused it or prove that you’ve improved.

If you sometimes take a familiar route without turn-by-turn directions, keep them ready. Use them as soon as you need them. Then, once you’re not moving, go back over the choice you were unsure of. What you get is a clearer picture of what you remembered and what still needs checking.

The Tokyo and London studies explain why that result should stay specific. Doing better at one task doesn’t mean a general upgrade. Choose your help by what you need for this trip and what you want to learn.

Use the AI comparison as an analogy

GPS offers a comparison for AI: help can change which parts of a task you practise. Navigation research does not show that AI weakens reasoning.

To make the comparison useful, name something you’d want to do later without help. For example, you might want to check the assumptions an argument starts from. Then work out which part of that task you stop practising when the help takes over. An assistant that asks you to explain your reasoning could give you more practice instead.

The real test is what you can do later without help. Finishing faster with AI, or feeling dependent on it, answers a different question. To show cause, researchers would need to know how able people were at the start and how much help they used. Their comparisons would also need to allow for who chooses help, and for other possible explanations.

The evidence would need to fit the people, the task, how the tool helps and how long people use it. Navigation studies can’t tell us how big an effect AI might have, or whether stopping AI would undo it. Last, ask why keeping that skill without help matters to you. Carrying on with the help can be a sensible choice.

What would you like to do on your own?

How about your daily life?

Is there a familiar place you can reach with directions but would like to understand better? Do you remember places you recognise along the way, or do you mostly follow the next instruction?

You might choose a shop you know, a regular walk or a route you’d like to sketch sitting down. Keep the choice familiar and low-risk. One good idea is enough.

A familiar situationWhat I would like to remember or understand
________________________________________
________________________________________

My chosen situation: ____________________

Take this situation into the exercise below. You can change it if the route or the conditions make using less help unsuitable.

Check one familiar route

Start with the situation you chose. If you’re starting here, pick a familiar, low-risk route that you’d like to be able to find on your own. Do the written comparison while you’re not moving, and use a map afterwards to check your memory.

Never do a memory or attention exercise while driving or moving through traffic. Keep any help you need to travel safely. If you can’t safely change how much help you use, keep using it and go over the route sitting down instead.

  1. Name what you want to remember. Choose a specific route, turn or link between places.
    What I want to recall: ____________________
  2. Recall before checking. While you’re not moving, sketch the route from memory. Include the turns and landmarks you remember. Mark what you’re unsure of, rather than making up a missing detail.
    My recalled route and uncertain points: ____________________
  3. Compare with a map. Note what matches and what needs putting right. A missing landmark and a wrong turn are different gaps, so write down the one you actually found.
    What matches, and what I need to check: ____________________
  4. Choose the help to keep. You might keep your usual directions and go over the landmarks. If you sometimes try the familiar route without turn-by-turn directions, keep backup ready and use it when you’re unsure. Go back over any uncertain choices afterwards, once you’re not moving.
    Guidance I will keep and a route detail to review: ____________________

Ask Jing

Become a Jingius.

See what you recall of one route

Loading interactive tool…

Your next step

Finish by naming what you remembered, what you put right or still need to check, and which help you’ll keep. One try is not a diagnosis of damage or proof that you’ve improved.

A note on the evidence

The studies asked different questions: how GPS habits relate to memory, which directions people remember, what practice improves and how the brain changes. The small follow-up can’t settle which way cause and effect run. The game-based study is evidence against a link that holds everywhere. Training results also vary by task. The AI discussion is still only an analogy, and it needs evidence about AI use itself.

How we prepared this module

This module draws on studies that observed navigation habits, on walking and training experiments, and on a long-term study of taxi training. It links their different results to choices about help and to a written route check. The opening scene and the bakery example are made up.

Sources