Say you sit down between tasks. Before you settle, you explain the pause to yourself: it will help you get more done afterwards. That reason might make stopping feel possible. But what if you go back without feeling much fresher?
Hoping a pause will help is one thing. Needing it to help is another. With that need, the pause only seems fine if it pays off.
You don’t have to find a perfect motive. The useful question is whether your reason seems to make room for a pause, ask something of it, or both.
This module is for working adults who have a pause they can choose, however short.
What you’ll get from this module
In this module
By the end of this module, you’ll have a clearer way to think about the reasons you give yourself for stopping. We’ll look at experiments on beliefs about free time and thoughts about work, a review of short breaks, and a workplace survey. You’ll tell apart enjoyment, recovery and having the time at all, pick an everyday situation, and use an optional written exercise to notice your reason without having to change it.
Ask Jing
Become a Jingius.
What changes when rest needs a reason?
Experiments: the same video, different beliefs about leisure.
Gabriela N. Tonietto and colleagues’ 2021 research asked whether beliefs about free time change how much people enjoy it. In Study 3, 458 university students read one of four short pieces. Three described free time as wasteful, unproductive or productive. The fourth, about coffee makers, gave the researchers a group to compare against. Everyone then watched the same cat video and rated how much they enjoyed it.
Those who read that free time was unproductive enjoyed the video less than the coffee-maker group. The gap was big enough to count as more than chance by the usual standard.
The wasteful piece also led to lower average enjoyment, but that gap fell just short of the standard. The productive piece showed no clear improvement. That doesn’t prove it had exactly the same effect as the coffee-maker piece.
In Study 4, 351 students were put at random into a wasteful framing or the comparison group before the same video. This time, the wasteful piece described some benefits but kept the wasteful label. Enjoyment was lower in that group.
These were small, short-term effects on enjoyment, in one line of research with students. The useful difference is between describing free time as worthless and describing it as useful. Calling free time wasteful or unproductive can reduce enjoyment. These experiments don’t show that having a productive reason spoils rest.
Why it matters: The researchers chose the video. Whether a productive reason helps people take more breaks in everyday life is a separate question, still open.
Read the experiments on leisure beliefs and enjoyment.
Systematic review and meta-analysis: short breaks can support recovery.
Patricia Albulescu and colleagues’ 2022 review pooled experiments and studies with comparison groups that weren’t chosen at random. All looked at breaks of ten minutes or less. The studies involved students and employees, with different tasks and break activities.
On average, breaks gave small gains in how energetic people felt and small drops in tiredness. The overall gain in performance wasn’t clear. Feeling more energetic and doing better work are different results, so one can’t stand in for the other.
Why it matters: So taking a break to recover can be useful, even when better output isn’t shown. But the studies tested breaks. They didn’t test whether believing a break must be productive helps or harms recovery.
Read the review of short breaks, well-being and performance.
Laboratory experiments: switching off is not the only useful mental direction.
Sabine Sonnentag and Cornelia Niessen’s 2020 experiments compared different instructions about what to think after a normal work or study day. They put German university students, and separately some local employees, at random into five groups.
Two groups were asked to turn their thoughts away from work: one by thinking about a hobby, the other by thinking about anything but work. The other groups thought about work in a positive way, a negative way, or with no set direction. Researchers measured how people felt after about ten to twelve minutes.
The researchers compared thinking positively about work with the two switching-off groups taken together. Positive thinking about work eased bad feelings more in the student study. In the employee study, it raised good feelings more.
Everyone was told what to think about, so the experiments don’t show what would have happened with no instructions.
Why it matters: That pattern challenges the idea that any thought about work ruins a break. What people thought about mattered, not just whether work was on their mind. It also leaves room for different ways of recovering, rather than making a total mental switch-off the rule.
Read the experiments comparing detachment and work-related thoughts.
Workplace survey: valuing breaks and being able to take them differ.
Gerhard Blasche and colleagues’ 2021 paper reported a survey at a Vienna hospital in February 2016. It compared 215 nurses with 109 office staff.
On average, nurses thought better of breaks, yet felt they had less control over them and took fewer breaks an hour. The attitude measure mixed enjoyment and usefulness, so it didn’t single out a productive reason. The researchers compared people’s existing jobs and what they reported. They didn’t change anyone’s working conditions.
Why it matters: The contrast matters, because thinking well of breaks can go along with having little chance to take them. Someone may already value stopping and still have less say over when it happens. A question about your own reasons can’t supply the missing time or cover.
Read the hospital survey of break attitudes and behavior.
What this means for you
During a pause you already have, you can notice the reason you give for taking it. You’re noticing what you expect from this pause. A productive reason isn’t a problem on its own.
Separate a helpful reason from a required result
In the opening example, expecting to work better afterwards may help you allow the pause. You may want to keep that reason. If you also feel the pause must deliver extra work to count, you can notice that demand without working out what caused it.
Does the reason seem to help you stop, demand a result, or both? You can also be unsure. You don’t have to settle on one answer. Noticing how the reason feels can’t show what caused that feeling.
You can leave the question unanswered and carry on with your pause. If looking at the reason turns into another demand, drop the question.
Keep recovery choices that serve you
The findings on short breaks give you a reason to keep ways of recovering that work for you. They also show why better output needn’t be how you judge whether time away was worth it.
You might want energy, enjoyment or just some time away from a task. Those are different aims. If you wanted time away, extra output answers a different question. Notice which aim you mean before treating a lack of extra work as a failed break.
In the same way, a pause hasn’t failed because a positive thought about work turns up. The experiments on thoughts about work support choice, not a rule that every work thought must vanish. Keep a reason or a way of recovering that helps you, without making it a must for every pause.
Notice when the obstacle is opportunity
Before trying the reflection, check that this is time you can really choose. A break that depends on enough staff or reliable cover for someone you care for needs more than a different explanation to yourself.
For a carer, a shift worker or someone with more than one job, the necessary duties don’t go away. Use only time you already have that fits around them. If no pause is yours to choose, set the exercise aside.
The hospital comparison helps show why that line matters. Valuing rest and having a say over it are different things. A pause you can’t take is not a failure to think the right way.
How about your daily life?
Where do you catch yourself giving a reason for stopping? You might think of a pause you have between tasks, or some time once the necessary duties are covered.
Write down one situation you’d like to understand. You can add more if it helps; one is enough.
| A situation in my daily life | The reason I tend to give for pausing |
|---|---|
| ____________________ | ____________________ |
| ____________________ | ____________________ |
My chosen situation: ____________________
Choose a pause you can actually use, and take it into the exercise below. Choosing a situation doesn’t mean your reason needs to change.
Notice your reason for pausing
Start with your chosen situation. If you came straight here, choose a pause you already have that fits around your necessary duties. If there isn’t one, set the exercise aside.
This is an optional reflection. You can stop without an answer, and you don’t need to feel restored or do better work to finish it.
- Notice the reason. What do you tell yourself makes this pause all right? You can write it down or leave it unsaid.
The reason I notice: ____________________ - Look at what it asks. Does the reason seem to help you stop, demand something back later, do both, or leave you unsure? This describes how the reason seems to you; it doesn’t show what caused a feeling.
What it seems to do: ____________________ - Leave room for your choice. Keep a reason that helps. You can leave the question unanswered and carry on with your pause. If the question becomes another demand, drop it.
What I want to keep, or leave unresolved: ____________________
Ask Jing
Become a Jingius.
Your next step
You have finished when you’ve noticed something about your reason, or chosen to leave it unanswered. Nothing needs scoring or repeating on a schedule.
A note on the evidence
The experiments on beliefs about free time measured short-term enjoyment in students. The recovery review measured different results, while the hospital survey described things that go together. Together, they support useful distinctions rather than one rule for resting that fits everyone.
Whether a productive reason changes how much people rest, or how well they recover, is still open. One person’s impression during a pause can’t settle that question.
How we prepared this module
This module brings together experiments, a systematic review and meta-analysis, and a workplace survey. An imagined pause shows different expectations. The written reflection helps you look at one reason while leaving room to keep it or reach no conclusion.
Sources
- Tonietto, Gabriela N.; Malkoc, Selin A.; Reczek, Rebecca Walker; Norton, Michael I. (2021). Viewing leisure as wasteful undermines enjoyment. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 97, 104198. Final published PDF; Studies 3 and 4, §§3.2–4.2, pp.5–6.
- Albulescu, Patricia; Macsinga, Irina; Rusu, Andrei; Sulea, Coralia; Bodnaru, Alexandra; Tulbure, Bogdan Tudor. (2022). “Give me a break!” A systematic review and meta-analysis on the efficacy of micro-breaks for increasing well-being and performance. PLOS ONE, 17(8), e0272460. Published HTML; Abstract; Results, “Description of the included studies” and “Effectiveness of micro-breaks,” Table 3.
- Sonnentag, Sabine; Niessen, Cornelia. (2020). To Detach or Not to Detach? Two Experimental Studies on the Affective Consequences of Detaching From Work During Non-work Time. Frontiers in Psychology, 11, 560156. Published HTML; Materials and Methods, Participants and Procedure; Results; Discussion.
- Blasche, Gerhard; Wendsche, Johannes; Tschulik, Theresa; Schoberberger, Rudolf; Weitensfelder, Lisbeth. (2021). Individual Determinants of Rest-Break Behavior in Occupational Settings. Healthcare, 9(10), 1330. Published PDF; §2.1, Table 1, p.4; §2.2 and Table 2.
