Say you’re trying to finish a report. You leave the document to check an email, go back to it, then open a browser tab. Later, you see a headline saying attention spans have collapsed. You wonder whether those switches mean you’ve lost the ability to focus.
Before you accept that explanation, there’s a useful line to draw. Changing windows tells us something about how you used your computer. Doing well on an attention test tells us something about how you did on that test. Neither one tells us, on its own, whether your ability to concentrate has changed over the years.
This module is for working adults who want to weigh up claims about attention. It is also for anyone looking for practical ways to manage their own. It doesn’t assume that everyone is getting worse at concentrating.
What you’ll get from this module
In this module
By the end of this module, you’ll know how to check an attention claim before you take its advice. You’ll link the research to real choices and pick a situation from your daily life. You’ll finish with a written check of one claim and a next step you can take. Workplace studies, a published attention graphic, a randomized field trial and reviews of structured mindfulness programs show why these differences matter.
Ask Jing
Become a Jingius.
What did the attention research actually measure?
Workplace observation: time in a window isn’t a limit on concentration.
Gloria Mark and colleagues’ 2016 study logged the computer use of 40 office workers who volunteered. They all worked at one US tech company, and the study ran for about 12 working days. The researchers tracked which window each person was using. They divided each day’s total recorded use time by the number of screen switches. A recorded stretch ended when someone changed windows or stopped using the mouse and keyboard for five minutes. The average across computer use was 47.0 seconds.
That number describes a pattern of computer use. It doesn’t mean the people in the study could no longer concentrate after 47.0 seconds. They could change windows while carrying on with the same task. Leaving a window and reaching the limit of your attention are different things.
Why it matters: The study also describes one workplace group during one period. To show that people have got worse at this over the years, you would need like-for-like measures taken at different times. This study doesn’t make that comparison.
Read the workplace study of online multitasking.
Workplace intervention: conditions can change the pattern.
What happens when the same workers face different conditions? A 2012 study by Gloria Mark, Stephen Voida and Armand V. Cardello followed 13 volunteer information workers at a US scientific research organization. They had three days of their usual email use, followed by five workdays with no new email. New messages were filed away, and the workers didn’t send email. Old messages and calendars were still there.
Average time in a window was 75.5 seconds during usual email use and 131.9 seconds during the no-email phase. The same people stayed in windows longer when their working conditions changed. So a short stretch shouldn’t be treated as a fixed personal trait without looking at the setting.
Why it matters: Everyone went through the phases in the same order, with no randomized control group. The study shows that screen habits changed in this setting. It doesn’t show a rise in how long someone could concentrate. It gives us a reason to look at the working conditions as well as the person.
Read the workplace study of work without email.
Published report: a graphic still needs a measurement behind it.
Microsoft Canada, Consumer Insights’ Spring 2015 report included a graphic claiming human attention fell from 12 seconds in 2000 to 8 seconds in 2013. It put goldfish at 9 seconds and credited the graphic to Statistic brain. The page gave no experiment, sample or measuring method for that comparison over time.
These are numbers printed in a report, not checked estimates of human and goldfish attention. To judge it, you would need to know how each number was measured. You would also need to know if the two could fairly be compared. The graphic doesn’t give that information.
Why it matters: The report’s well-known name can’t fill the gap. The missing trail back to a measurement is a reason not to treat the statistic as a scientific finding. You can name what is missing without making up a story about where the numbers came from.
Read the report containing the attention-span graphic.
Randomized field trial: blocking mobile internet improved a test result.
A weak headline doesn’t make every worry about technology groundless. In 2025, Noah Castelo and colleagues studied 467 iPhone users in the US and Canada. Most of them wanted to cut down their phone use. Some people, chosen at random, blocked all mobile internet straight away for two weeks. The others started the same block two weeks later. The block covered Wi-Fi and mobile data on the phone, while calls, texts and internet on other devices stayed available.
The researchers measured accuracy on a five-minute task that tested how well people kept paying attention. Accuracy improved a little during each group’s block. The groups also differed significantly in how their scores changed over time. So the results support a benefit of the block on this attention task. That goes further than a count of window changes.
The study’s conditions matter when you decide what to expect from that result. People knew whether their internet was blocked. The comparison group waited for the block rather than doing another activity meant to help. The main analysis included people with all the required measurements. Those who finished already had better attention before the block than those who dropped out. Only 119 of the 467 people met the target of blocking access for at least 10 of the 14 days.
Why it matters: The study found a modest benefit, but it also showed that keeping the block in place was hard for many people. It doesn’t show that everyone’s attention has declined over time, or that a lighter block would give the same result.
Read the field trial of blocking mobile internet.
Research reviews: structured practice has mixed results.
Changing access isn’t the only approach researchers have studied. Mindfulness means paying attention to the present moment. Nur Hani Zainal and Michelle G. Newman’s review, published in 2024, looked at randomized trials of mindfulness programs. The trials covered people of different ages and health conditions. Its author manuscript reported a small gain in accuracy on tasks that need steady attention. That was across 23 studies, compared with active control activities. Active controls mean people did another activity, rather than just waiting or getting no program. Results varied a great deal across those studies.
An earlier review of adults only, by Tim Whitfield and colleagues, published in 2022, found no statistically significant improvement in attention. Across the thinking skills tested, mindfulness programs also didn’t do significantly better than other activities. Both reviews are about set programs with several sessions. They don’t promise that a short meditation will bring back a certain attention span.
Structured practice may improve scores on some attention tasks, but the reviews don’t give one clear answer. How much those gains help an ordinary working adult’s daily work is still uncertain. The comparison matters too: doing better than no program and doing better than another activity answer different questions.
Read the review of mindfulness and cognitive functioning and Read the adult review of mindfulness-based programs.
What this means for you
You can look at a difficulty in your own day without first settling a claim about everyone’s brain. Start with the problem you want help with, then look for evidence that fits it. That gives you a reason to choose a response, instead of borrowing advice from a headline that doesn’t match.
Name the outcome before accepting the conclusion
Ask what the study counted or tested. Time in a window, accuracy on an attention task and changes across a population over time are different outcomes. Keep the actual outcome in how you describe the result.
Go back to the made-up report situation. Say you open a source document to check a figure before going back to your report. The window changes, but the work may still be part of the same task. A count of windows alone can’t tell you whether that switch helped the report or got in its way.
Describe your concern in terms that fit your work. Perhaps you keep leaving a report unfinished, or you want to check it with fewer mistakes. Those are useful problems to look into; a headline’s number isn’t a diagnosis of you.
Follow the comparison and the source
Ask who took part, where the study happened and what was compared. Then check when and for how long the outcome was measured. The no-email study follows the same workers through one condition after another. The mobile-internet trial randomly assigns people to groups that start the block at different times. Neither comparison on its own shows a trend across the population over decades. A study’s publication year doesn’t supply that missing comparison.
Follow the claim back to the original text or table. Check that its words and numbers support the claim you’re weighing up. A citation to another website is a lead to follow, not a stand-in for finding the measurement. If the trail stops before you reach a study you can identify, write down that gap.
You don’t have to throw out everything a source says because something is missing. Keep the part that is supported and leave the extra claim open. For example, a screen stretch can describe behavior even when it can’t show that ability is declining.
Look at the size of the result and whether other studies tell a similar story. A small improvement on an attention task doesn’t justify promising a big improvement in your daily work. When results vary, as in the mindfulness research, a positive summary can hide that uncertainty. Keep the measured outcome and the comparison in view, and include relevant findings that didn’t show a benefit.
Match a possible change to your actual problem
If you want to change your mobile-internet access, first check whether a block would fit your responsibilities. Keep the communication and work access you need before you try it. The field trial kept calls, texts and internet on other devices, but that setup may still leave out a service you rely on.
A lighter block could be more practical, though it differs from the full block tested in the trial. Watch whether it helps the work you care about, not only whether it cuts screen time. In the made-up report example, that could mean checking whether you finished the report and whether mistakes remained. What you notice can help you decide what to keep doing, without showing a general change in your ability to concentrate.
If you want to practise attention, look for a defined program with several sessions rather than a promise to repair a fixed attention span. Think about the time and teaching it needs, alongside the outcome you want to improve. The reviews give reasons to keep your expectations measured: better accuracy on an attention test doesn’t guarantee better daily work.
A useful conclusion might be to try one change you can manage. It might be to look for what is missing, or to make no change for now. Waiting makes sense when the suggested response doesn’t fit the evidence or your circumstances.
How about your daily life?
Where have you come across an attention claim that could affect a decision? It might be a headline about screen switching, a reason to block mobile internet or a promise that comes with an attention-practice program. You could also start with a real difficulty, such as finishing a report, and find the claim behind a suggested fix.
Write down situations you’d like to understand better. One good idea is enough; use more rows if they help you choose.
| A situation in my daily life | The claim or choice I want to examine |
|---|---|
| ____________________ | ____________________ |
| ____________________ | ____________________ |
My chosen situation: ____________________
Choose one situation to carry into the exercise below. You can change your choice; picking a situation doesn’t show that a suggested fix will suit you.
Check one attention claim
Start with your chosen situation. If you’ve come straight here, choose an attention claim linked to a real task or decision in your day. Write the claim down before you decide whether to take its advice. This is a written check of the evidence, not a test of your attention.
- Identify what was measured. Name the task and the outcome, such as time in a window or accuracy on an attention task. Keep that description instead of swapping it for a general attention-span label.
Measured task and outcome: ____________________ - Identify the people and setting. Note who took part, how they were chosen and where the study took place. Write down missing information rather than assuming the group stands for everyone.
People, setting and missing details: ____________________ - Identify the comparison and period. Was this a randomized comparison, a before-and-after observation or a comparison of different groups? Write when and for how long the outcome was measured. A publication year alone doesn’t show change over time.
Comparison and period: ____________________ - Locate the original support. Open the actual text or table and note its source, version and where in it the support is. Compare it with the claim’s wording and numbers. If you can’t reach the measurement behind it, say where the trail stops.
Source, location and supported result or gap: ____________________ - Decide what the evidence lets you conclude. Think about how large the result was and how sure it is.
Ask whether other studies agree or disagree. Ask whether it supports the suggested fix for these people over this period. Write what the evidence supports, and keep any extra claim separate and open.
What the evidence supports, and what remains unknown: ____________________
Now go back to your practical situation. Choose a practical next step only if it fits the problem and the evidence. Before you block any access, keep the communication and work access you need. A lighter block is different from the full two-week block described above. For structured practice, think about the time and teaching it needs, and the uncertainty about benefits for daily work.
Name an outcome that matters for your task, rather than relying only on minutes saved. If evidence or practical arrangements are missing, write what you need to find out or why you will make no change now.
Next step, or reason to wait: ____________________
Outcome I would observe and access I must preserve: ____________________
Ask Jing
Become a Jingius.
Your next step
Finish with a conclusion the evidence supports and a practical next step, or a clearly stated open question. Your own experience can guide your decision. On its own, it can’t show a trend for everyone or diagnose your ability.
A note on the evidence
These studies measured different things in different settings. Workplace logging describes behavior; the field trial and practice reviews measure scores on attention and other thinking tasks. Many people in the trial didn’t finish or didn’t keep to the block, which matters when you apply the result to everyday life. The practice reviews differ in who they include, what they compare and what they measure. Keep those differences attached to any result you use.
How we prepared this module
This module draws on workplace research, a published report, a randomized field trial and reviews of structured practice. It uses the differences in what they measured to build a written check of a claim and choices for an everyday situation. The report-writing example is made up.
Sources
- Gloria Mark, Shamsi T. Iqbal, Mary Czerwinski, Paul Johns, and Akane Sano. (7–12 May 2016). Neurotics Can’t Focus: An in situ Study of Online Multitasking in the Workplace. Proceedings of CHI 2016, ACM, pp. 1739–1744. Published article; Method p.1740; measurement, Results and Table 1 p.1741.
- Gloria Mark, Stephen Voida, and Armand V. Cardello. (5–10 May 2012). “A Pace Not Dictated by Electrons”: An Empirical Study of Work Without Email. Proceedings of CHI 2012, ACM, pp. 555–564. Author-hosted copy of the published paper; Research Setting/Methodology pp.556–557; Table 2 p.559.
- Microsoft Canada, Consumer Insights. (Spring 2015). Attention spans. Microsoft Advertising, research report. Original report via mirror; p.6, graphic and attribution.
- Noah Castelo, Kostadin Kushlev, Adrian F. Ward, Michael Esterman, and Peter B. Reiner. (18 February 2025). Blocking mobile internet on smartphones improves sustained attention, mental health, and subjective well-being. PNAS Nexus, 4(2), pgaf017. Published article; Results, Compliance and attrition; Materials and methods, Intervention effects on psychological functioning.
- Nur Hani Zainal and Michelle G. Newman. (June 2024; online 30 August 2023). Mindfulness enhances cognitive functioning: a meta-analysis of 111 randomized controlled trials. Health Psychology Review, 18(2), 369–395. Author manuscript; Table 2, Sustained attention accuracy; Results, active controls; Discussion limitations.
- Tim Whitfield, Thorsten Barnhofer, Rebecca Acabchuk, Avi Cohen, Michael Lee, Marco Schlosser, Eider M. Arenaza-Urquijo, Adriana Böttcher, Willoughby Britton, Nina Coll-Padros, Fabienne Collette, Gaël Chételat, Sophie Dautricourt, Harriet Demnitz-King, Travis Dumais, Olga Klimecki, Dix Meiberth, Inès Moulinet, Theresa Müller, Elizabeth Parsons, Lauren Sager, Lena Sannemann, Jodi Scharf, Ann-Katrin Schild, Edelweiss Touron, Miranka Wirth, Zuzana Walker, Ethan Moitra, Antoine Lutz, Sara W. Lazar, David Vago, and Natalie L. Marchant. (September 2022; online 4 August 2021). The Effect of Mindfulness-based Programs on Cognitive Function in Adults: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Neuropsychology Review, 32(3), 677–702. Published article; Abstract; Discussion, Attention and Conclusion.
