Concept

What makes an activity worth doing is a different question from whether it makes something or takes something in.

Issue

Sorting your time into work and leisure can leave your reasons for doing things unexamined.

Solutions

Understand the difference between an experience and the useful things that follow from it, then describe one episode from your week.

You finish something in your free time and at once look for what it was good for. Perhaps it helped you get ready for work, learn something or make something useful. But would the experience have mattered to you without that gain?

That question is about your reason for doing it. Making something or taking something in describes what you do. Valuing the experience for itself describes why you do it. You can value the doing in either kind of activity.

Say you write a proposal only to win a contract. You are making something for a further purpose. Say you listen to a story because the experience itself matters to you. You are taking something in and valuing the experience itself. These are made-up examples, not advice about how to spend your time.

This module is for working adults thinking about why they did certain things during one week.

What you’ll get from this module

In this module

By the end of this module, you’ll have a clearer way to describe what mattered to you in one activity. Ideas about leisure and play from philosophy, a theory of what drives people and a study of daily life will explain the differences. You’ll look at what they mean in practice, choose a moment from your week and describe your reasons for it, including anything you’re unsure of.

What makes an experience worth having?

A philosopher’s argument: an end is not the same as a means.

In Book X of Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle separates amusement used to rest before more effort from contemplation valued for itself. The difference is about what the activity is for. By contemplation, he means thinking about and understanding what is true. Rest gets you ready for later activity; contemplation, in his view, is worth doing for itself.

Why it matters: Aristotle gives contemplation a special place. He does not give every amusement the same value. His argument offers a difference worth looking at: something can be worth doing because of what follows, or because the doing itself matters.

Read the philosophical argument about amusement and contemplation.

A history of play: play can have rules and meaning.

Johan Huizinga’s Homo Ludens, in the 1949 edition reprinted in 1980, describes play as free and absorbing, with limits and rules. He sets it apart from making a quick material profit, while noting the jobs it does in a culture. He also notes an exception to that freedom: play that is part of a ceremony can carry duties.

This helps separate what you are trying to do inside an activity from what you hope to gain outside it. A goal can give the experience a direction while the experience itself is still what matters. Having rules or taking an activity seriously does not mean you are doing it for a separate reward.

Why it matters: Huizinga is giving an account of play and culture. Someone watching can describe what an activity does for a group without knowing why each person takes part.

Read the chapter on the nature and significance of play.

A review of theory: choosing freely and valuing the experience are different.

Richard M. Ryan and Edward L. Deci’s 2000 review defines intrinsic motivation as doing something for the satisfaction in the activity itself. Extrinsic motivation means doing something to get a result outside the activity itself. That difference asks why someone acts, not simply whether someone else made them do it.

The authors also explain that people can choose these further purposes for themselves. You can freely choose an activity because its result matters to you. A willing choice can still have a further purpose.

Why it matters: The review discusses measures such as going back to a task freely and saying you find it interesting or enjoyable. These measures help researchers study motivation. They do not show that the person has no other reason for taking part. Enjoying something and wanting a useful result can go together.

Read the review of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation.

Why did they do it?

An observational study: everyday reasons don’t split neatly.

Ronald Graef, Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi and Susan McManama Gianinno’s 1983 study followed 107 full-time workers from five Chicago companies for one week. People carried pagers and wrote down what they were doing and how they felt each time they were paged.

To study motivation that comes from the activity itself, the researchers combined two answers. Had the person wanted to start the activity? Did they now wish they were doing something else? They counted a report as intrinsically motivated when the person had wanted to start and did not wish to be doing something else.

Some answers did not fit together: someone could have wanted to start but now wanted to do something else, or the other way round. These split answers, about 40% of all answers, were left out of the analysis. Those left-out answers matter: wanting to begin and wanting to stay were not always the same answer.

People whose reports met that definition more often said they were happier and less tense. The analysis took the type of activity into account. This was a link between reported experiences, not the result of an experiment. It does not show that changing someone’s reasons would cause those results.

Some people had no reports counted as intrinsically motivated during the week studied. That does not show that these people had never valued an activity for itself. The study did not look separately at what followed for people with none of those reports.

Why it matters: The useful difference is between what a measure recorded and what a person’s life holds. Reports from one week can tell us something useful without describing a whole life.

Read the daily-life motivation study in its authorized reprint.

Read one week fairly

What this means for you

Think about one particular occasion and why it mattered to you. The same activity can mean different things on different days. Your answer can hold several reasons at once.

Start with an episode, not an activity label

Think back to one occasion and what made it worth having at the time. The name of the activity leaves that out. Making something does not tell you whether you valued the making itself. Taking something in does not rule out valuing the experience.

In the made-up proposal example, the contract is the reason. In the story example, the listening is the reason. The visible difference between making and taking in is not what decides either answer. What matters is the reason already given in each example.

This also leaves room for your reasons to change during a moment. Describe the change if you remember one, rather than forcing the whole occasion into the purpose it started with.

Separate a reason from a consequence

Write down what you wanted from the moment. Then tell apart a result you were after from something that simply happened.

Something useful may have happened without being what you wanted from the activity. In the same way, choosing freely does not mean you wanted only the experience. As Ryan and Deci explain, you can freely choose something for a further purpose. Either way, you need to think about your reasons, not just what happened.

Keep both reasons when both matter. Mixed reasons describe the moment; they are not a failed search for a purer answer.

Ask what would remain without the separate gain

Imagine losing a separate gain while keeping the experience and what you were trying to do inside it. Would the experience still matter to you?

Keeping the experience the same helps you see how much that separate gain mattered. If taking away the gain would also change the experience, the comparison becomes unclear. Write down that you’re unsure rather than treating your imagined answer as proof.

The goal inside an activity can be part of what you enjoy. You can keep its goals, rules and meaning in mind while you imagine the separate gain disappearing.

Describe what you found without grading your life

Use a candidate valued for itself when the experience itself seems to be what made the activity worth doing. Use mixed when the experience and a separate gain both matter. Use chiefly instrumental when you mainly did it to get a further result. Use uncertain when you can’t remember clearly or can’t separate the experience from the gain.

These descriptions help you put your thinking into words. They do not rank activities or ask you to replace one. Having several reasons for something you do in your free time does not make it lacking.

If nothing stands out, write “none identified in this week.” That reports the limits of what you found. It does not show that none exists or predict that something is missing. The research here does not show what follows when someone has none at all.

Limited time, money or freedom can narrow your choices. An empty list is not a judgement on your character. You may finish with a clearer description, or with a better sense of what is still unclear.

What made one moment worth it?

How about your daily life?

Which moment from the past week would you like to understand better? Perhaps you were making something, listening to something or doing something for a useful result. Those are prompts to help you remember, not a list of things to take up.

Write down an occasion and what you would like to make clearer. One suitable idea is enough.

An episode from my weekWhat I want to understand about my reasons
________________________________________
________________________________________

Which episode would be most useful to explore now?

My chosen episode: ____________________

You can change your choice. Carry this episode into the exercise below; choosing it does not settle your reasons for it.

Describe one episode from your week

Start with your chosen episode. If you came straight here, think back to one occasion from the past week whose reasons you want to understand. Describe it without choosing something to do instead or setting yourself a target.

  1. Recall the occasion. Write what you were doing and what made it worth doing to you at the time. The name of the activity alone is not enough.
    Episode and what mattered: ____________________
  2. Separate reasons and consequences. Name any separate result you were after and anything you valued in the experience itself. Allow both, and note any change during the moment.
    Sought outcome, valued experience and changes: ____________________
  3. Consider the comparison. Imagine the separate gain disappearing while the experience and what you were trying to do inside it stayed the same. Would the experience still matter? Use your answer to reflect, not as proof. If taking away the gain changes the experience too, write down that you’re unsure.
    My answer and what I cannot separate: ____________________
  4. Describe the result. Use a candidate valued for itself if the experience itself seems to be what mattered. Use mixed if both the experience and a separate gain mattered. Use chiefly instrumental if you mainly wanted a further result, or uncertain if you can’t tell. Write your reason and keep any doubt about your memory or the comparison.
    Description and reason: ____________________
  5. Keep the conclusion within this week. If nothing stands out, write “none identified in this week.” Do not turn that into a diagnosis, a prediction that something is missing or a claim that none exists. Limits on your time, money or freedom are not faults in your character.
    What I found, including any uncertainty: ____________________

Ask Jing

Become a Jingius.

Describe one moment from your week

Loading interactive tool…

Your next step

You have finished when you can describe what mattered to you in that moment or explain why you are still unsure. Keep that answer without turning it into a rule to spend your time differently.

A note on the evidence

The philosophers make arguments about value and play. The motivation review separates reasons for acting, while the Chicago study records what people said about themselves during one week. Together they do not add up to a test of pure reasons that works for everyone. The links in the study also do not show what would happen if someone changed their reasons.

How we prepared this module

This module links ideas from philosophy, a theory of motivation and research on daily life with a written reflection on one moment. Made-up examples of a proposal and a story explain why the form of an activity does not settle its purpose.

Sources

  • Aristotle. (Undated web transcription). Nicomachean Ethics. W. D. Ross translation, Internet Classics Archive. Book X, sections 6–7, paragraphs beginning “Happiness, therefore” and “And this activity alone”.
  • Johan Huizinga. (1949, reprinted 1980). Homo Ludens: A Study of the Play-Element in Culture. Routledge & Kegan Paul edition. Chapter I, printed pages 8–10 and 13.
  • Richard M. Ryan and Edward L. Deci. (2000). Intrinsic and Extrinsic Motivations: Classic Definitions and New Directions. Contemporary Educational Psychology, 25, 54–67. Published journal version; “Intrinsic Motivation,” pages 56–57; “Extrinsic Motivation,” pages 60–63.
  • Ronald Graef, Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi and Susan McManama Gianinno. (1983). Measuring intrinsic motivation in everyday life. Leisure Studies, 2(2), 155–168. Authorized reprint in Flow and the Foundations of Positive Psychology (2014), chapter 8; “Sample and Method,” pages 116–117; “Results,” page 120 and Table 8.3, page 121.