Concept

Studying and making something can serve the same learning goal.

Issue

Finishing another tutorial does not tell you whether you are ready to use what it teaches.

Solutions

Learn how to choose your next step, then plan a useful attempt.

Say you have just finished a spreadsheet tutorial. You could watch another lesson. You could try the technique. Or you could write a short note explaining how it works. Which would help you most right now?

The answer depends on what is missing. Sometimes you need to see how a solution works before you try it. Sometimes you are ready to make something small and check whether you have understood.

This module is for working adults with a specific learning or practical goal, when a small piece of work you can check fits your knowledge, time and energy.

What you’ll get from this module

In this module

By the end of this module, you’ll have a clearer way to choose between more study and a useful attempt. We’ll look at research on worked examples, teaching, work that gets judged, planning and deadlines. You’ll connect those findings to everyday choices, pick one situation, and plan a small piece of work you can check, or name the study you need first.

What makes input and output useful?

Research review: seeing a worked solution can help.

Christina Areizaga Barbieri and colleagues published a review in 2023. It looked at how people learn mathematics, from primary school to university. Across 55 studies, students who were given worked examples did better in mathematics, on average, than students in the comparison groups.

A worked example shows how to reach an answer, step by step. If you do not yet know how to solve the problem, you can study those steps instead of guessing where to begin.

The results varied a lot from study to study. The researchers also allowed for publication bias: studies with positive results may be more likely to get published. After that adjustment the benefit looked smaller, but it was still there.

Why it matters: The review supports studying a relevant worked example in mathematics. To use that idea in an everyday project, look for an example that walks through the task you are trying to do.

Read the review of worked examples in mathematics.

School experiment: trying it straight away is not always the better next step.

Tamara van Gog, Liesbeth Kester and Fred Paas ran a study in 2011. It compared ways of learning to find faults in electrical circuits. Secondary school students at two Dutch schools were put into groups. Some studied examples. Some solved problems. Some did both, in different orders.

Studying examples alone, and studying an example before solving a problem, both led to better scores on a test taken straight afterwards than solving problems alone. Studying an example first and then solving a problem was not clearly better than studying examples alone.

Why it matters: The students worked on only a few tasks and were tested right away. Finding no clear difference does not prove the two approaches work equally well. Still, if you are new to a task, studying another useful solution can be a reasonable next step. You do not have to make something after every example.

Read the experiment comparing example study and problem solving.

Research review: preparing and explaining can work together.

Keiichi Kobayashi’s 2024 review asked whether teaching, after you have prepared to teach, adds anything to learning. In a comparison across 14 studies, people who prepared to teach and then taught learned more than people who only prepared to teach.

This is a useful comparison because both groups prepared. The result supports the idea that teaching added something beyond the preparation in those studies. So reading and then explaining can be two parts of the same learning process.

Why it matters: For your own learning, preparing a short explanation is one way to use that idea. Keep the preparation. An explanation needs something accurate to explain.

Read the review of preparing to teach and teaching.

Research review: it matters what you would do instead.

Jesús Ribosa and David Duran published a review in 2022. It looked at students making teaching materials for other people. It found a small learning benefit overall, but the comparison changed the conclusion.

Making materials was clearly better than activities judged unlikely to help learning. It was not clearly better than other activities expected to help. That does not show the two are equal. It does stop anyone recommending that you always replace useful study with making something.

Why it matters: An explanation is one option, with a purpose. Its value depends partly on what else you would do with that time.

Read the review of learning through making teaching materials.

Which next step fits the gap?

Field experiment: a trusted judgement can make work mean something.

Amanda Pallais ran an experiment in 2014 with people applying for entry-level data-entry jobs on oDesk. Some applicants, picked at random, were given paid work and then a public review, either brief or detailed. A control group was not hired for the experiment.

After the reviews went public, the hired applicants did better at finding work later. A more detailed review helped the people who had done well and hurt the people who had done poorly. The experiment gave applicants both a job and a trusted account of how they did, one that other people could see.

This matters when you think about showing your work. A job that someone has judged gives another person something they can use to assess your ability. Simply posting a collection of your own files does not give them the same information.

Why it matters: This finding is about paid work and public reviews in one particular marketplace. When you choose work to show, ask whether it shows a relevant skill and who can judge its quality.

Read the field experiment on entry-level hiring.

Explain what a folder of work does and does not show

Research review: tie the action you intend to a cue.

Paschal Sheeran, Olivia Listrom and Peter M. Gollwitzer reviewed planning research in a paper published in a 2025 issue. It brought together 642 separate tests across many goals and outcomes. It supports plans that link a situation to a response.

An if-then plan names both. If a particular situation comes up, then you will take a particular action. The review found a benefit overall. The estimate got smaller after allowing for the chance that published studies leaned towards positive results.

Why it matters: The findings cover planning in many settings. They are not a tested schedule for creative work. The useful idea is simple: say what will prompt your next action, and what that action will be.

Read the review of when and how to plan.

Retracted deadline experiment: the original finding is no longer reliable evidence.

Dan Ariely and Klaus Wertenbroch published a paper in 2002. It described a proofreading experiment with 60 students, each put at random into one of several deadline arrangements. It reported that people did better with evenly spaced deadlines set for them than with deadlines they set themselves, and better with self-set deadlines than with one deadline at the end.

Why it matters: The journal retracted the paper in September 2026. It could no longer stand behind the reliability of the findings. The advantage the paper reported can no longer count as reliable evidence for choosing a deadline.

Read the journal’s retraction notice.

Replication study: the deadline advantage did not show up again.

Kyle Hyndman and Alberto Bisin tried to repeat the experiment. They described the attempt in a manuscript in April 2025, and it was published in July 2026. Changing the deadlines had next to no effect on their three measures of performance. Evenly spaced deadlines set for people did not stand out.

The original materials were not available, and some procedures differed. The task was done on a computer, and the rewards were different. The repeat did not find the original advantage. That does not prove every deadline is useless.

Why it matters: For your own learning project, you can keep the deadline and the size of the task adjustable. The repeat gives you no reason to copy the original study’s deadline arrangement.

Read the published replication study.

What this means for you

Choose your next activity by what you want to achieve and what you already understand. Reading or watching a useful explanation can help you learn the basics. Making something small gives you work you can check, correct or show when that would help with your goal.

Name what you want from the activity

Name a practical question before you decide what to make. An explanation, a worked solution, a short decision note or a small usable object could help answer it. Choose the form that fits the question.

If the point is enjoyment or rest, you do not need to make anything. You do not have to turn reading, watching or listening into homework to justify the time.

For a learning goal, name something specific you could make and check. “Learn spreadsheets” does not tell you what to try next. In our made-up example, explaining one technique gives you a clear question: can you describe how that technique works?

Study the missing piece before you force an attempt

Ask whether you understand enough to make a sensible attempt. If the steps would be guesswork, find a reliable worked example or a relevant source first. Look for material that covers the missing part.

In the spreadsheet example, another lesson helps if it explains the operation you do not understand. Browsing something unrelated does not fill that gap. Once the relevant example makes sense, you can try the technique on practice data, or prepare a short explanation.

Studying more examples is still a valid choice. The school experiment gives no reason to demand that you apply every example straight away. Let the gap in your knowledge decide whether more input is useful.

Explain one thing, then check it

Prepare an explanation for a real or imagined reader. Keep it on the question you chose, so you have one clear piece of work to look over. You do not have to post it anywhere.

Before you rely on what you have made, compare it with a reliable example, a source or someone who knows the subject. A polished explanation can still contain an error. Fix the differences you can resolve and mark anything that stays uncertain.

Say your spreadsheet explanation describes a step differently from the reliable worked example. Go back to that step and find out why before you use your explanation as instructions. If you cannot resolve the difference, keep it marked as a question that needs more study or some help.

Choose when to begin and how much to attempt

Choose a situation that can prompt your next action. For example: “If I open the learning material for my next session, then I’ll pick the one task I want it to help me finish.”

Keep the task small enough for the time and energy you really have. If the cue does not fit your day, change it. If the task is too big, make it smaller instead of adding money penalties or forcing yourself to publish.

The deadline research does not give you one best schedule. Choose an amount of work and a stopping point that fit your day, and change them when you need to.

Keep or show work for a reason

Keep what you have made if it might be useful again. Share it only when another person’s judgement or use would help. Check that sharing is appropriate and respects anything confidential.

The oDesk finding helps explain why it matters who judges the work. Someone who understands the task can tell how well you did it. Simply counting your files cannot. Quality matters too: a judgement can reveal weak work as well as strong work.

After the attempt, go back to your original question. Did the work help with it, and was the effort worth it? Use that answer to change the amount of input, the piece of work or its size next time.

What will you make with what you learn?

How about your daily life?

Where are you choosing between another piece of information and trying something yourself? You might be learning a spreadsheet technique, preparing an explanation, or deciding whether useful work is ready to show someone.

Write down situations where a clearer next step would help. One idea is enough. Use more space if you would like to compare possibilities.

A situation in my daily lifeWhat I want to understand or accomplish
________________________________________
________________________________________

My chosen situation: ____________________

Choose a specific learning or practical goal that fits your knowledge, time and energy. Carry it into the exercise below. You can change your choice.

Plan a useful attempt

Start with your chosen situation. If you are starting here, choose one learning or practical question and a small piece of work that could help answer it. The task must fit your knowledge, time and energy.

If the point is enjoyment or rest, stop here. You do not need to add a piece of work. For practical learning, use the steps below.

  1. Name the purpose and the possible output. Choose an explanation, a worked solution, a decision note or a small usable object that answers your question.
    Question and possible output: ____________________
  2. Choose when to begin and how much to attempt. Write an if-then plan naming a situation you will recognise and your next action. Choose a task size and a stopping point that fit your time and energy. You can adjust them without adding money penalties or forced posting.
    If this happens, then I will: ____________________
  3. Study what is missing. Choose a reliable worked example or source that covers the task. If an attempt would be guesswork, study the foundation first. You can keep studying examples before you make anything.
    Input I need, or why I’m ready: ____________________
  4. Explain or apply when you are ready. Make the small piece of work. For spreadsheet practice, use practice data. An explanation can be for a real or imagined reader, and it can stay private.
    My attempt, or remaining study need: ____________________
  5. Check and correct before you rely on it. Compare it with a reliable example, a source or someone who knows the subject. Correct what you can. If a difference stays unresolved, mark it and name the further study or help you need.
    What I checked, corrected or still need to resolve: ____________________
  6. Choose what to keep or share. Keep the work if it might be useful again. Show it to someone only when their judgement or use would help, and when sharing respects anything confidential.
    Keep, share appropriately, or leave it—and why: ____________________
  7. Review the fit. Ask whether the attempt helped your original purpose and whether the effort was worth it. Adjust the input, the output, the cue or the size for next time.
    What helped and what I’ll change: ____________________

Ask Jing

Become a Jingius.

Plan an attempt worth checking

Loading interactive tool…

Your next step

You’re finished when you have checked your attempt or clearly named what you still need to learn. You should know how your work answers the original question, or what to study or ask about next.

A note on the evidence

These studies measured different things. The education studies help explain your learning choices. The marketplace experiment shows how trusted reviews can affect hiring. That hiring result does not tell you how much you could earn from a personal collection of work.

The original deadline paper was retracted, and the repeat did not find the advantage it reported. This evidence gives no reliable basis for insisting on its deadline arrangement. Choose an activity for a particular purpose, and review how well it fits your situation.

How we prepared this module

This module brings together reviews of learning and planning, experiments on example study and judged work, and a deadline replication alongside the retracted original report. A made-up spreadsheet situation illustrates the choices. The written exercise helps you connect useful study with a small attempt and a check.

Sources